Transcript: Planning Commission Meeting
October 7, 2026
Each time links to the meeting video at that moment. Speaker names appear only where the source gives them; otherwise the speaker is shown as Unknown speaker. Open the meeting video (opens in a new tab).
- 0:02:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 2020.
- 0:02:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to welcome to the October 7th, 2026 meeting of the Planning Commission.
- 0:02:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The time is now 6.32 p.m.
- 0:02:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and I call this meeting to order.
- 0:02:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can we please rise and say it pleasant for our deletes?
- 0:02:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Doug Aliens, due to the flag of the United States of America.
- 0:02:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker He's been a new public, or which is Tanz, one nation
- 0:02:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker under God, an invisible ruler of the Indian justice overall.
- 0:02:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can the Secretary please call the roll?
- 0:02:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Missioner Booth is absent and excused.
- 0:03:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Brutus.
- 0:03:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hip Hill.
- 0:03:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Here.
- 0:03:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Leaf is absent
- 0:03:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and excused.
- 0:03:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Shorts.
- 0:03:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair Dreckman.
- 0:03:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Here.
- 0:03:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Chair Sawish.
- 0:03:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Life and tunnel.
- 0:03:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have a chorm.
- 0:03:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have
- 0:03:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker an agenda before us.
- 0:03:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are there any changes to the agenda?
- 0:03:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are no changes.
- 0:03:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can I receive an approval?
- 0:03:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Motion to approve.
- 0:03:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Second.
- 0:03:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was a motion
- 0:03:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker from Commissioner Hampill and second by Vice-Chair Dreckman on Favorite AI.
- 0:03:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hi, I'll post any.
- 0:03:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is unanimous.
- 0:03:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That brings
- 0:03:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker us to the approval of the minutes from the September 16th, 2026, planning commission meeting.
- 0:03:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are there any changes from staff?
- 0:03:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No changes from staff.
- 0:03:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any changes from the
- 0:03:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker commissioner?
- 0:03:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can I receive a motion?
- 0:03:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So moved.
- 0:03:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:03:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is a motion from Commissioner Brotis and a second from Commissioner Shots on
- 0:04:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Favorite AI, I'll post ANA.
- 0:04:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is unanimous.
- 0:04:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That now brings us to the public comments portion of the
- 0:04:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker meeting have there been any individuals who have signed up for public comment.
- 0:04:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I do have one and it's an answer.
- 0:04:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, let me quickly read off of my scripts.
- 0:04:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just to confirm this is on business.
- 0:04:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is on an item that is not on
- 0:04:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our current agenda is it related to any one of the current general business items okay so that is a public hearing so we'll open
- 0:04:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker up a separate testimony period for public comment during that public hearing when we get to it.
- 0:04:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just to type, we have a moment.
- 0:04:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I can
- 0:04:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker actually we have one of those in public hearing, but we can probably do comments during it.
- 0:05:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, now it's actually noted as above here for the Cole Creek property.
- 0:05:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so are there any other individuals signed up I have no one else signed up for public comment and nobody online correct
- 0:05:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker okay well
- 0:05:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker then we will move on to the first general business item.
- 0:05:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just confirm there's nobody else in the room providing general public comments.
- 0:05:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:05:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll move on to the first general business item that is a public hearing resolution of the planning commission recommending approval of a special reviews for Monitoring Children's World at 480
- 0:05:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Street.
- 0:05:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The time is now 635 and the public hearing is open.
- 0:05:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I will turn it over to Seth.
- 0:05:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:05:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And good evening in the first cases mentioned that I have for you this evening is the special reviews for the Monster Children's World at
- 0:06:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 480 cheeseman and this application is a little different than you're probably used to seeing so we often see a special reviews in a site plan
- 0:06:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker application together.
- 0:06:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In this case, the project did not trigger a separate site plan application or site plan review, so it's really just the special reviews.
- 0:06:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
- 0:06:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so in this case the use childcare would be allowed if it was a considered a small childcare which or small childcare facility that's less than 16 students
- 0:06:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would be allowed as a use by right in this sound district but in this case because the proposal would be to be or would be to have greater than six or more than 16
- 0:06:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker students,
- 0:06:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that tips it into the Special Reviews category in this zone district.
- 0:06:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And currently there is an existing building there.
- 0:06:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was formally the Lion's
- 0:06:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Club that has been vacant for a little while now.
- 0:07:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And tonight, as usual, I'll get into the background a little bit more, talk about some of the specifics
- 0:07:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the proposal review and evaluation in terms of the approval criteria and then finally give staff recommendation so the property is very
- 0:07:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker close.
- 0:07:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a block that way.
- 0:07:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker At the corner, south, east corner, I guess, of Cheesmin Street and High Street,
- 0:07:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and minor park is just to the south
- 0:07:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there.
- 0:07:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A Little street view to help you orient it.
- 0:07:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's a parking lot that sort of splits the block,
- 0:07:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the building in question here is the red one although I hear it's no longer red that's recently in painted and then this top picture here is looking east
- 0:07:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you can see the existing ADA ramp, which will be improved, and then new windows that were also recently installed,
- 0:08:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or will be installed, sorry.
- 0:08:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The comprehensive plan designates this area as residential low.
- 0:08:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker However, of course, the comprehensive plan does allow for some secondary uses and
- 0:08:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This sort of uses exactly what's in mind for those types of secondary uses,
- 0:08:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so limited scale, neighborhood commercial that provide or that help integrate data-day
- 0:08:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker services and amenities into existing neighborhoods.
- 0:08:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And for their staff, find that there are a couple specific policies in the comp plan that support this application, including exploring opportunities
- 0:08:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to increase access to child care for residents and employees and encourage infill development and adaptive reuse of existing structures and this of course is adaptive what we consider adaptive
- 0:08:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker reuse because it's proposing a new use synexisting structure the the proposal is also consistent with the zone district as
- 0:08:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mentioned,
- 0:09:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's a little funky, so the code permits a small child-cared facility as I used by right, and this neighborhood mixed use zone district, but as
- 0:09:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mentioned for a large childcare facility it thumbs it up into the special views category however we find this is also consistent with the overall purpose of the neighborhood mixes sound district
- 0:09:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which also similar to the language I just read out of the complaint anticipates the sort of small small compact neighborhood scale commercial that sort of mixed in with residential
- 0:09:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now I'll get into some more details of the proposal itself.
- 0:09:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the use itself, as I mentioned, is a large childcare center.
- 0:09:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the operating hours are 7.30 to 5pm.
- 0:09:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The current staff would be four teachers, excuse me.
- 0:09:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I don't have an exact
- 0:09:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker number that Apple can probably talk to this process a little bit more, but there are state licensing requirements that determine the maximum number of students based on the square footage of
- 0:10:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the score footage of the facility and then other operational considerations like the number of staff and things like that.
- 0:10:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so the applicant can probably talk to that process a little bit more with the state.
- 0:10:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so this is what I would call a site plan light, so as I mentioned, that didn't trigger a formal site plan review application or
- 0:10:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker site plan application.
- 0:10:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But this sort of rough site plan gives us an idea of the extent of the use.
- 0:10:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so a coal minor park is
- 0:10:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the town park just to the south here and the operation would include some of the parking or would specifically include some of this
- 0:10:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker parking a new fenced in outdoor play area and then the existing building which would receive some some internal in a couple sort
- 0:11:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of external upgrades as well.
- 0:11:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This might be a bit hard to see the linework might be a bit hard to see on your screen,
- 0:11:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but some of the proposed
- 0:11:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker upgrades for the building are of course the meat building code requirements and some of these things included new windows, new doors, and a new ADA
- 0:11:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ramp and also a number of interior improvements like accessible bathrooms on the inside.
- 0:11:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so now I will get into the approval criteria.
- 0:11:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So staff do find that this application is consistent with those secondary uses I mentioned in the content plan.
- 0:11:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
- 0:11:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker furthermore it is consistent with the overall intent of the neighborhood mixed use zone district and criteria see here references a specific section and code
- 0:11:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and that section in code is our section that contains use specific standards and for childcare it actually just refers back to state law so the applicant is aware of and complying with state
- 0:12:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker law.
- 0:12:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Staff also find that this fits in wall with a surrounding neighborhood, primarily of course because it's an existing building,
- 0:12:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's not a proposed new building or new construction.
- 0:12:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there are a number of benefits to this location, proximity to the park,
- 0:12:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker access to existing sidewalk infrastructure and utility infrastructure.
- 0:12:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And of course, it's well integrated with it within an existing residential neighborhood that, of course, can be,
- 0:12:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and for any families looking for nearby daycare facility.
- 0:12:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And staff do not expect any significant adverse impacts from this use.
- 0:12:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And as I mentioned, there are existing utilities and infrastructure that are available to serve or that already do serve this site.
- 0:12:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So with that,
- 0:13:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sorry, not quite yet.
- 0:13:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There was a neighborhood meeting as required by the UTC before this public hearing and the applicant can talk about that a bit as well, but there were
- 0:13:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a couple of neighbors that showed up with some questions and then also a few that voice support of the application public notice requirements were met for this
- 0:13:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker hearing this evening and in summary staff do find that the Monitoring Children's World Special Review use complies with the approval criteria and do
- 0:13:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker recommend that PC adopt a finding of recommendation of our website.
- 0:13:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Staff
- 0:13:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker recommend the PC recommend approval to the town council and with that the applicant is also here with a presentation um
- 0:13:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I will note this is an updated presentation from what was in the packet.
- 0:14:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I believe we can add this to the public record.
- 0:14:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would be fine with that if the town attorney, yes, it can be added to the public record.
- 0:14:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 0:14:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we will move on to the applicant presentation.
- 0:14:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Good evening, everyone.
- 0:14:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My name is Mona Chat.
- 0:14:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker From Children's Ordinary Story.
- 0:14:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like Harry putting out.
- 0:14:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're here to request a large take care status because currently our preschool is a small digest.
- 0:14:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll briefly tell you just a little bit about myself and about the program.
- 0:14:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I saw my journey in the field of education 25 years ago.
- 0:15:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When I was teaching elementary in that elementary school, I noticed in all the kindergartens not coming in,
- 0:15:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't have the skills
- 0:15:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we need for academic or social motion.
- 0:15:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When I started looking into programs,
- 0:15:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I realized that it was rare to have those two skills together.
- 0:15:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do things together.
- 0:15:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and that's when I establish this children's for monetary program not very very many people know about that program
- 0:15:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker even though we've been there for 10 years the reason being because we've been at capacity at all times we've never advertised
- 0:15:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just with WordMouth recommendations from neighbors, friends, and family.
- 0:15:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what keeps us at capacity.
- 0:15:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what we're requesting a
- 0:15:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker larger number, because most of the time families have to stay on the waiting list for a very long time.
- 0:16:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just to chat about what the monitoring concept is.
- 0:16:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's the education philosophy that in my case, because it's preschool, so it's going to be, it comedy is shown from two and a half to five, and there
- 0:16:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the same environment.
- 0:16:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a mixed age.
- 0:16:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's hands-on.
- 0:16:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they're doing as they're learning and monasteries being around
- 0:16:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for about 120 years in all parts of the world.
- 0:16:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In the United States, I think we started in the 1950s.
- 0:16:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And all the research that's been done
- 0:16:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on early childhood endorses the monetary philosophy as being as supporting the child development.
- 0:17:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All the materials that we use
- 0:17:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the classroom are research-based and they encourage cognitive development or social emotional development.
- 0:17:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So not only is the
- 0:17:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker curriculum very rich, it also the best thing for me is it is it instills the love of learning and curiosity that you can take with them.
- 0:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mentioned social emotional education.
- 0:17:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is what teachers define
- 0:17:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as social emotional,
- 0:17:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but being able to manage your behavior, able to interact, teamwork, live skills,
- 0:17:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in real life, and that
- 0:17:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sounds like a tolerable very little children from two to five but that's exactly what what the program does um there's a national survey
- 0:17:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of teachers from 76% of teachers who believe that social emotional development plays a key role in academic success as
- 0:18:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker well.
- 0:18:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 80% of the teachers believe that this skill can be taught and that's the reason I have our programs puts all the big emphasis on the social motion learning.
- 0:18:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did a little survey of the programs.
- 0:18:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It really only has two monasteries goals, but we looked at
- 0:18:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker nearby areas like Lafayette, Louis, Wogmann, Boulder, Broomfield, and out of the 16 schools,
- 0:18:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker half of them do have social emotional learning
- 0:18:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker program and there's different ways to the program.
- 0:18:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's not maybe a complete program, but these did do offer that learning.
- 0:18:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some of them had
- 0:18:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker very basic parent education program or one of them had the behavior modification or self-regulation and if you didn't find
- 0:19:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker any schools that have any of the parent coaching.
- 0:19:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So what makes the children's or monetary program different is we take all those five elements and
- 0:19:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker offering together in the program and the monitoring education in promotes that independence and life skills social emotional learning teaches
- 0:19:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker them how how to how to act like how to make friends and how do it actually control your emotions so parent
- 0:19:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker education teaches appearance like how what are they missing why is the child how to connect with that child basically now how can they support the child developmentally
- 0:19:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker These are some of the pictures.
- 0:19:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is a mixage classroom.
- 0:19:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The young children learn from the older ones.
- 0:20:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're very dependent and they'll do, you know, they'll serve themselves, you sell them, they'll use nice safe ones, of course,
- 0:20:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and surely are
- 0:20:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, able to do those things, they'll take care of the environment and their own needs.
- 0:20:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there's no
- 0:20:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker such as a cleanup time or cleanup song.
- 0:20:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They just do it at all there every day.
- 0:20:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the best part is they're doing their motivated to do it.
- 0:20:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nobody,
- 0:20:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they're not getting there's no rewards in passion so it's not they'll get a time out of they did something wrong or or stigar did it something differently they take it in the environment because that's
- 0:20:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker how they'll learn from the environment.
- 0:20:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Our social emotional program is called Ruthen Wings and what
- 0:20:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it does is it teaches all the social emotional skills necessary,
- 0:21:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it teaches kindness, responsibility, teamwork,
- 0:21:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it teaches empathy sharing, like how do you communicate, how do you resolve conflicts,
- 0:21:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker express emotions self-regulate I I was able to catch a couple things that I see all day every day and I'll kind of explain
- 0:21:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker blame, younger ones, they're helping each other always in the classroom.
- 0:21:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Here's the CN Children at Spill.
- 0:21:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's just kind of an example of a teamwork like how they come together
- 0:21:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and automatically like another child will come in and they'll start helping in at the you know there'll be a whole bunch and they just do it to support
- 0:21:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker each other.
- 0:21:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're not tools like you have to do this.
- 0:21:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They just do it because it's intrinsic motivation.
- 0:21:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's the right thing to do and that's what they
- 0:21:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker learn to do in and practice.
- 0:22:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like this young friend was really sad because after the drop-off and even before an
- 0:22:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker adult stops in,
- 0:22:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker their peers are there for just apart and kind of be there.
- 0:22:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One of the really main focus of the program is to be able for the children to learn to have a focus,
- 0:22:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which is a little challenging because it's a preschool custom bustling with activity and noise but
- 0:22:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker children as little as two like this young friar mine can do it they can focus they could work together as well they do that all day
- 0:22:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker long every day and they play a very long together.
- 0:23:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The paired coaching program,
- 0:23:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it teaches parents
- 0:23:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the tools, how to handle behavior, or what, and kind of understand what the behavior means,
- 0:23:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and do it not only developmentally or appropriately, but also
- 0:23:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker according to values their values so they can kind of teach children accordingly so what the parent coaching does is it kind of gives them
- 0:23:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the tools to navigate the challenges and be successful.
- 0:23:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I truly believe in
- 0:23:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this one that if we as adults do better, our children do better, and the whole community is better at the end.
- 0:23:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And thank you.
- 0:23:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:23:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are there any individuals that have signed up for comment
- 0:24:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on this item.
- 0:24:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I do not have any.
- 0:24:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did receive a public comment that was submitted
- 0:24:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to the commission so we're going to admit that into the record for transparency purposes a copy has been provided to the applicant the applicant has said
- 0:24:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we'll do it again just with record are you fine with us submitting this to the record yes okay i isn't going to find rest of comments made yeah
- 0:24:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what I'll just do is since many individuals up here haven't seen this because it was sent,
- 0:24:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think, last night, I'll read it
- 0:24:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker off and then you can address any comments too.
- 0:24:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'll read this off.
- 0:24:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker With regard to SRU
- 0:24:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for the monastery childcare and business item VIA and tomorrow's planning commission meeting, application indicates that the operation may receive a state operating license for more
- 0:25:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker than 16 children.
- 0:25:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I count only 14 spaces on their side of parking lot, inclusive of the 280 A spots.
- 0:25:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is the city comfortable with overflow use of the city's free parking for minors park for
- 0:25:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker their special use if enrollment goes substantially over 16 children or on street parking pickup is not likely an issue since the timing of
- 0:25:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pickups tend to be staggered, but drop off Curtis primarily at one time each day.
- 0:25:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As someone who served on the board of a monastery school in Boulder County, I am both supportive of the use, but also
- 0:25:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker familiar with drop-off traffic another item for which I would encourage consideration there does not appear to be a continuous sidewalk along the north side of the parking lot and either the proposed
- 0:25:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker site plan or from this image on Google Maps.
- 0:25:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This could potentially be a safety issue if the lack of a safe pedestrian path to the front door forces parents and their children to walk into the
- 0:26:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker parking lot, throwing drop off and pick up, especially during implement weather.
- 0:26:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In terms of path of travel, the ADA ramp on the West elevation would be better ramped to
- 0:26:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the south in the direction of the handicap parking instead of away from it.
- 0:26:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker However, the ramp is existing and a new one would be required to make this improvement.
- 0:26:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Presumably any new signage will
- 0:26:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker follow town requirements.
- 0:26:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Finally, it should be noted that further reduction of parking could occur due to snow storage when the parking lot is ploughed.
- 0:26:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Will
- 0:26:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the applicant be responsible for snowflowing and snow removal in a similar vein who is responsible for the maintenance and upkeep of the asphalt parking lot?
- 0:26:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It appears cracked and possibly in need
- 0:26:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of resurfacing from the satellite image.
- 0:26:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And this is signed resident Paul Leaf of Erie Colorado.
- 0:26:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just to confirm, we
- 0:26:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have no other public comment correct.
- 0:26:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is correct.
- 0:27:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so I'll close the public comment portion and I will move to
- 0:27:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to commissioner questions but before we do that obviously since I just read that all off if there's anything that you would like to address that was noted in this
- 0:27:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker item Yes.
- 0:27:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As far as parking, and I know Mr.
- 0:27:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lee said it in the morning, we got the drop-off times of the
- 0:27:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker same they they do stagger a little bit but even then it's a rolling drop off where parents who are driving and just drive up scan scan the QR code and
- 0:27:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker keep going.
- 0:27:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They won't walk to the building.
- 0:27:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Even if they did the 14 spaces, it's going to change a little bit because
- 0:27:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker when there's a subdivision application in the process, well, the TANA fewer just separated the property and the park,
- 0:27:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the park loved really 100%.
- 0:28:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They'll
- 0:28:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker belong to the school it would not no longer be part of the town's park so that would give us plenty even if we had extra to have
- 0:28:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker extra parking and yes we will we will be responsible for plowing its northern level the other the continuous sidewalk
- 0:28:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker since it's going to be a private part a lot side i don't think we'll have we won't have a challenge because just like when people park across on the other
- 0:28:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on the other side towards a park to walk over i think it's going to be a similar walk and again the pickup and drop-up are both
- 0:28:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rolling their parents don't come in they just scan and then the child can go 80 of them is on the west side but
- 0:28:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where the 80 parking are the very first two parking which are 88 that sidewalk is linked to the ramp so there's
- 0:29:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker wheelchair access from getting out from the parking space and going to the sidewalk and then on the ramp.
- 0:29:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that has already been repaired did I miss anything I think I got it
- 0:29:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm also happy to add some staff
- 0:29:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker response if that's appropriate to some too.
- 0:29:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, yeah, you could comment on that.
- 0:29:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, all the comment too.
- 0:29:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So starting with
- 0:29:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the parking.
- 0:29:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So yeah, as the applicant mentioned,
- 0:29:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there is an application that was recently
- 0:30:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker approved of the plot has not been recorded yet, but that plot will subdivide.
- 0:30:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So at this time, the or up until recently,
- 0:30:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the entirety of this block
- 0:30:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was privately owned by the applicant and the town merely had a lease for the minor park area.
- 0:30:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so recently we have worked on a subdivision application to actually purchase the southern half, but that property line, the new property line will subdivide the property.
- 0:30:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I
- 0:30:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't know if you can see my mouse on here.
- 0:30:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I guess you can.
- 0:30:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker At the green line here, and so as the applicant mentioned, the entirety of the parking lot actually will remain
- 0:30:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker privately owned with your in association with the monastery use and that was coordinated with park staff who felt that the
- 0:30:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker abundance of on-streep parking around Clementon Park and then also the proximity to the church lot, which the town has a long-term release over,
- 0:31:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was more than sufficient for the neat parking needs of the park itself.
- 0:31:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then with that being said,
- 0:31:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker according
- 0:31:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to the UDC, commercial uses and old town and MU and the DTs on district actually are not required to provide
- 0:31:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Austria parking.
- 0:31:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so that's sort of the first thing.
- 0:31:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker However, if we were to be requiring Austria parking here, of course,
- 0:31:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in this situation, there already is existing Off Street parking, so this is sort of a mood point.
- 0:31:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But if we were requiring the applicants to provide Off Street parking for this use,
- 0:31:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our code calculates
- 0:31:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the parking need for daycare facilities at one space per six students.
- 0:32:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so with these, even just counting the northern row of parking
- 0:32:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with the 14 spaces.
- 0:32:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's, I can't do mental math, so I read it down earlier.
- 0:32:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That would allow for actually up to 84 students, which is far more than
- 0:32:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the state would allow through their permanent process anyway.
- 0:32:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So yeah, I guess the first point being that Off Street parking is not required for this huge supporting to code,
- 0:32:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But if it were, the parking that is being provided would actually exceed what would require.
- 0:32:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then regarding the sidewalk in the ADA
- 0:32:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker access I think the the applicant mentioned but the in the the letter from the member the public mentioned as well but there is an existing ramp that the applicant will be improving and that
- 0:32:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker does that's on the west side of the building and it does as mentioned in a letter sort of flow I guess to the right if you're exiting out of the building but the
- 0:33:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ADA path as reviewed via a building department would be exiting the building and then coming down here.
- 0:33:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think there are a couple reasons the
- 0:33:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fact that it's an existing ramp meant that it would be easier to just improve what's there rather than tear it out and build up completely new configuration.
- 0:33:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then as mentioned, the current ADA
- 0:33:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker spaces are actually in the Northwest Corner, which do have Direct sidewalk access.
- 0:33:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the code doesn't actually require specifically that all
- 0:33:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker parking spaces be accessed by a sidewalk.
- 0:33:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think that is something that keep in mind and the applicant could explore other improvements in the future if it felt like
- 0:33:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there were conflicts of the current between pedestrians and vehicles but at this time that was in a particular concern of staffs and I
- 0:33:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker think that was all I wanted to say to you.
- 0:33:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks.
- 0:34:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:34:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Brotis.
- 0:34:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just have a comment, which is talking with, well, we're going to go questions.
- 0:34:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, yeah, sorry.
- 0:34:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll leave comments for a collaboration, okay?
- 0:34:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So any questions?
- 0:34:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker good questions okay thank you uh my share your reckon um just have curiosity how do they come up with your enrollment range like how does it how will the state determine what your max enrollment
- 0:34:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker can be uh the state licensed it for doodly okay thank you uh commission chat
- 0:34:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker think my questions have been answered so far.
- 0:34:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Good.
- 0:34:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:34:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hampill,
- 0:34:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's probably
- 0:34:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker more a question for staff, but just to confirm, I'm reading 1031 table per minute uses correctly.
- 0:35:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Residential oh density residential and old town residential both have childcare center large permitted by right whereas neighborhood mixed use
- 0:35:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker has a special review use that's correct.
- 0:35:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is correct and also a bit odd, I would say.
- 0:35:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Great.
- 0:35:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:35:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's all my questions.
- 0:35:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so just so I can understand this,
- 0:35:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're talking about a property that
- 0:35:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is also currently with coal minor park and coal minor park and the parking lot have been leased from the applicants for how many ever years it's
- 0:35:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker been and we're going to have a future application that subdivides the two and the parking lot is the applicants
- 0:35:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we're not going to have a parking lot for coal miners park if i understand that correctly correct yeah okay um i'm assuming
- 0:36:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in terms of the building code, that will, I see.
- 0:36:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:36:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Anybody who belonged to a director of parks from the creation, so it
- 0:36:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was an administrative subdivision, so you will not be seeing an application for that subdivision.
- 0:36:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council has already proved a purchasing-sale agreement from the applicant as
- 0:36:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Harry stated that is in process right now once we have recorded we will set a closing hopefully by the end of October so yeah you will not I just wanted
- 0:36:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to correct that, you will not be seeing an application for that subdivision.
- 0:36:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:36:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:36:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure.
- 0:36:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Luckily, we had you here.
- 0:36:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't.
- 0:36:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker um i don't have any other questions any last questions from the commissioners okay um we will
- 0:37:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker now move to deliberation.
- 0:37:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll start with Commissioner Brotis.
- 0:37:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sorry, we're going early before.
- 0:37:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just one quick comment, which is the CEO of the Early Childhood
- 0:37:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council of Polar County,
- 0:37:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker considers Erie to be her exact words where an early childcare desert,
- 0:37:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and so having more childcare available is
- 0:37:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a very good thing that Erie needs.
- 0:37:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So thank you.
- 0:37:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice-Chair Dreckman.
- 0:37:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nothing.
- 0:37:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:37:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mr.
- 0:37:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Schatz?
- 0:37:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I
- 0:37:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have been on this commission for five months.
- 0:37:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is a second special review use.
- 0:37:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll reiterate what I said last time.
- 0:37:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't understand why
- 0:37:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker site plan isn't sort of automatically part of the process, whether we characterize it as a site plan or as in other jurisdictions it's just inherently part of the process.
- 0:37:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think
- 0:37:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here it would be appropriate to make some conditions because maybe I should have asked a hypothetical during the questions period but if this
- 0:38:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker parking lot under the control of this land owner were to go away that very much changes the impact of this use
- 0:38:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on the neighborhood.
- 0:38:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So a condition would be that the parking lot is assumed to serve this use, and if there is a change or reduction in a number of
- 0:38:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker off street parking spaces that the use must go through some sort of pipeline process.
- 0:38:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I would propose that condition.
- 0:38:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that's
- 0:38:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sort of inherently of concern we've already talked about parking and then I think defense and play area probably should be memorialized
- 0:38:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in some way.
- 0:38:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I don't have any problem with the application.
- 0:38:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have more problem with our code, but the remedy for that is to do as with most special uses in
- 0:39:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker my experience and conditions that respond to that issue.
- 0:39:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then a final note is, you know, if this were ever to be 100 students, that would change our findings probably tonight
- 0:39:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is now we're near that obviously today you're looking to grow above 16 I'm going to assume that state code in the size of the building and
- 0:39:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker all the things that would happen if you actually had to get anywhere near what would change the suitability this parking lot would prompt a whole new application so in that case I don't think a condition
- 0:39:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would be appropriate.
- 0:39:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But depending on the Will the Commission, I would propose a couple conditions.
- 0:39:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:39:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Before we go on to Commissioner Happell, can you repeat
- 0:39:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what what you had in mind so in terms of the reliance of this use on the current offstreet parking if
- 0:39:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there is a change to the use of this this this use and its availability the availability of the offstreet parking particularly
- 0:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to reduce the number of austry parking spaces that conserve the use that the applicant will initiate a site plan process that would address
- 0:40:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that or some modification of the special use.
- 0:40:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay,
- 0:40:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so first I'm going to confirm with staff to verify that
- 0:40:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it would be if this is approved it's permitted but any other use is also permitted they just have to follow
- 0:40:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the current parking spaces off street parking requirements that we have is that correct there are no parking requirements and this is on district okay so
- 0:40:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it doesn't change my opinion.
- 0:40:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, that's why we do special use.
- 0:41:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's especially small children, but where this
- 0:41:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is located downtown, it's not about off-street parking.
- 0:41:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is about this use and separating this traffic from other
- 0:41:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker traffic.
- 0:41:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I do not imagine that we're talking about Austria parking per se.
- 0:41:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're really talking about loading.
- 0:41:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So maybe I can more artfully phrase
- 0:41:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it, but again, the concern here is that we don't have people taking up space on the road and intermingling with other traffic to get their kids to school.
- 0:41:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I see what you're saying.
- 0:41:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, I guess the question is why are we doing a special use?
- 0:41:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, maybe we need to reduce
- 0:41:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the number of special uses in our code.
- 0:41:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't think so for daycare.
- 0:41:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, just as a point of reference.
- 0:41:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the SRU section,
- 0:41:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 10, 11, 11,
- 0:42:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker alterations of approved uses, no approved special reviews made modified, physically extended hours of operations extended or otherwise altered unless amended in accordance with the
- 0:42:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker procedures, applicable to the initial approval of the SRU set out in the UDC.
- 0:42:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if there's any changes to that loss of parking or the use, they have to come back through the process.
- 0:42:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I got witches at again.
- 0:42:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 10, 7, 11, 10, 7, 11.
- 0:42:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which specific that A, per 10, 7, 11, C,
- 0:42:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 1 D.
- 0:42:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One,
- 0:42:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mr.
- 0:42:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Chair, may interact with our planning police.
- 0:42:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think your contention is that
- 0:42:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker covers it and thank you for directing us to that.
- 0:42:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think my final question, and I know I can leave this, I do think our code has a problem, but I'm not sure I've defined
- 0:43:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it yet.
- 0:43:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we'll see if this is the one, but my concern with that provision is that it assumes we've defined the use.
- 0:43:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And without a site plan, how have
- 0:43:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we defined the use?
- 0:43:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, it's not a contention necessarily just providing information for the planning commission.
- 0:43:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's all.
- 0:43:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's up for you folks here to decide how that all works together.
- 0:43:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't want to
- 0:43:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker insert myself into your decision or discussion just spreading information.
- 0:43:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's very good information too.
- 0:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just, I'm concerned we haven't defined the use because we have this code
- 0:43:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where this site plan light as the planner has got on screen it isn't the applicant's presentation I don't think
- 0:43:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We do, I mean,
- 0:43:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we do have a part of the material is a chronicle site plan.
- 0:44:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But it's not a true site plan, obviously.
- 0:44:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is it a site plan that was submitted?
- 0:44:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sorry, this is me, Mr.
- 0:44:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Chair,
- 0:44:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is it a site plan that was submitted in a way that we can call that the application?
- 0:44:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's with the SRU application as the
- 0:44:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker additional materials?
- 0:44:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that would be a good question for our deputy town attorney.
- 0:44:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, and I'm trying to
- 0:44:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker open the, so bear with me while I,
- 0:44:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as my computer doesn't want to open documents.
- 0:44:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think the question I'm hearing is what was submitted in that with the application.
- 0:44:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the
- 0:44:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker question is, we're doing an SRU.
- 0:44:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The concern is parking.
- 0:45:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Say if the parking lot was
- 0:45:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ever removed and there was no longer offstreet parking.
- 0:45:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now you have a concern of loading and outs for these children.
- 0:45:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What's being contemplated is how will we require that there is
- 0:45:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at all times Austri parking available for this establishment due to the use that is specific to this establishment that we are approving.
- 0:45:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that correct?
- 0:45:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think the even narrow, thank you, good reiteration of the issue as a whole, even narrow issue here is the site plan we're looking at that was supplementary and they can
- 0:45:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker thank everyone for backfilling my shotty preparation, I guess.
- 0:45:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But is that site plan a part of the SRU for the purposes of
- 0:46:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker section 10, 7, 11 that would require the use to be modified,
- 0:46:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, if that site plan were modified.
- 0:46:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, so I'll turn to staff
- 0:46:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to see how they what's submitted and what we would consider as part of the application the approved SRU and plan Well,
- 0:46:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the SRU application doesn't require a sight plan in this instance.
- 0:46:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So will we have a supplemental to help demonstrate the
- 0:46:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker conditions on the site but it was not required as part of the application per code so that's why the applicant would not provide one would as it did not provide one those
- 0:46:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one.
- 0:46:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker prepared by staff.
- 0:46:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's correct as a demonstrative image to help Planning Commission understand the conditions on the site.
- 0:46:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can we, yeah, could you just throw up the thing we're talking about on the screen?
- 0:47:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is it not this?
- 0:47:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is it something else?
- 0:47:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Pretty much this.
- 0:47:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So for clarification from staff was a site
- 0:47:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker plan exhibit and other site plans to mill requirements shall be prepared in accordance with the site plan user guide was a site plan exhibit required for this application
- 0:47:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is the site plan exhibit.
- 0:47:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I just want to distinguish a couple things here.
- 0:47:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's a formal site plan application
- 0:47:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that in the past you've often seen come along with a special review.
- 0:47:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And in this case, one was not required because that's only required for either new development,
- 0:48:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker increase in stories, increase in the floor area by more than 10% of 5,000 square feet or increase in the permeable surface by more than 2,000 square feet.
- 0:48:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so none of those conditions were met that
- 0:48:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would require a formal site plan application but to your specific question as part of those aren't necessarily equivalent so that the
- 0:48:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker site plan exhibit tends to be just a single page,
- 0:48:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like rough site plan exhibit rather than our full, you know, often like 10 or 20 page set of
- 0:48:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker landscaping and grading and architecture and all those things.
- 0:48:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this site plan exhibit constitutes that requirement for the special reviews
- 0:48:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker user guide thank you okay so if i understand uh commissioner shots what you would like to have is um
- 0:48:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the,
- 0:49:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You would like to have a requirement where the parking lot the parking requirements
- 0:49:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are,
- 0:49:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we have no parking requirements in that district.
- 0:49:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you can't even say the parking requirements are maintained in perpetuity,
- 0:49:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are no parking requirements.
- 0:49:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I should write this out.
- 0:49:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So what I'm proposing, again, this is not a fall-on.
- 0:49:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My sword, there's a really technical issue.
- 0:49:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The use is fundamentally sound.
- 0:49:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As far as I'm concerned since we're in deliberation, we're going to prove this and rightly so,
- 0:49:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but is to backstop special
- 0:49:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker uses and this one included on things that are fundamentally part of the application and the one issue we've talked about tonight is that
- 0:50:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this parking lot is available really for loading.
- 0:50:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's why parking requirements isn't the issue.
- 0:50:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's that this off-street situation is available for
- 0:50:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for the use so that it can be separate from on-street and traffic conflicts.
- 0:50:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hypothetically for the town's journey,
- 0:50:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if the applicant in the future wanted to expand out their facility and they wanted to
- 0:50:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker eat into some of that parking area.
- 0:50:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Obviously, they would have to pull building permits, but would they have to come back before this commission or the
- 0:50:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker council to do so.
- 0:50:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In that case, I would say yes based on the UDC
- 0:50:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker provision that Darrell cited, which references physical expansion of a use.
- 0:51:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if they are expanding, building, the footprint of the building,
- 0:51:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would say that clause would be triggered, which would require
- 0:51:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the SRU to come back for additional review.
- 0:51:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think what I'm hearing, which shots what you're saying, is that the
- 0:51:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker paved area to the south on the southern end of the property should be maintained as either parking or drop-off for the duration of the
- 0:51:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker use as a large child care facility.
- 0:51:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, I correct.
- 0:51:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the scenario is also that the landowner and we're going to say you're great.
- 0:51:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and this is about a hypothetical where for one reason or another you sell the business and now like a lot of industries it's someone that doesn't live here is not a part of our community and
- 0:51:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is looking to maximize it or minimize their capital costs and they get rid of the parking lot just that's the first thing that happens and that's you know probably
- 0:52:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker something that this section 10, 7, 11 addresses as well.
- 0:52:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Clearly in the expansion scenario, I would guess that triggered.
- 0:52:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's more the neglect
- 0:52:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker scenario that my technical mind still doesn't know the answer.
- 0:52:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, what was the other item that you had related to the fence?
- 0:52:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think I'm going to withdraw that.
- 0:52:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, that it is on there in red, the fenced in play area.
- 0:52:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And again, when we look at uses that deserve special review, the reason is because there are special
- 0:52:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker populations in this case children that probably need to be secure.
- 0:52:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm not going to say we have to do that condition.
- 0:52:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe there's a condition that
- 0:52:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just says that site plan fixes those two things or something, but I'm willing to defer to the provision of code.
- 0:52:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, and I know
- 0:52:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there was an item in comments that noted the six foot high fence would require a separate permit.
- 0:53:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So yeah.
- 0:53:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, let me move on to Commissioner
- 0:53:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hampill and then come back,
- 0:53:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hampill.
- 0:53:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:53:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My mind having the neighborhood mixed used as a special
- 0:53:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker review use is interesting and it being available by right makes this an easy yes vote for me in other locations that
- 0:53:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it and to commissioner shots I would be opposed to restricting or requiring any sort of pavement requirement
- 0:53:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker offshree parking.
- 0:53:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if that condition occurs, I would vote no, but if the application as is, I would book this.
- 0:53:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:53:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I will say I appreciate that this area is being looked to have some activation occur to it because it
- 0:54:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker really has not been used in years.
- 0:54:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This seems like a very good use of that location, especially when there is a park next door.
- 0:54:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So my
- 0:54:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker son goes to a monastery school, so I'm very familiar with the monastery program.
- 0:54:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I keep looking at the pictures and saw my son.
- 0:54:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But I
- 0:54:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I understand what it is that you're trying to do there.
- 0:54:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And as Commissioner Brotis said, there is a desert of childcare in this area.
- 0:54:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I know that's to be true
- 0:54:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because of what I went through when I saw the year to two and a half year wait list that are within the area.
- 0:54:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they're very much as a need.
- 0:54:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's go back to commissioner shots and
- 0:55:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In his request,
- 0:55:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Brotis, what are your thoughts?
- 0:55:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm okay without it, but if the commission feels like it's really that critical and it's not going to stop me from voting, yes, either way.
- 0:55:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice-Chair.
- 0:55:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair Jack.
- 0:55:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Johnson, do you say you were fine deferring to code?
- 0:55:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Didn't you just say that?
- 0:55:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I kind of want to read the code for myself right now, but...
- 0:55:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sorry.
- 0:55:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm trolling
- 0:55:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker navigating.
- 0:55:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, I did.
- 0:55:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, I don't, I just don't know if it's necessary.
- 0:55:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's okay.
- 0:55:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:55:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And are we on me?
- 0:55:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's read it again.
- 0:55:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Go free.
- 0:55:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm thinking out loud now to say alterations of approved uses as a code section.
- 0:55:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No approved special review use may be modified.
- 0:55:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker physically expanded hours of operation extended or otherwise altered that's free brought so I'm good and we're
- 0:56:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker good
- 0:56:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, any other deliberation items?
- 0:56:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, is there possibly a motion?
- 0:56:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Votion to approve.
- 0:56:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm gonna have that, do you have that?
- 0:56:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm texting somewhere.
- 0:56:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't have to pull that.
- 0:56:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's...
- 0:56:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sorry, should have...
- 0:56:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I didn't
- 0:56:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker frenemase.
- 0:56:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, he's got...
- 0:56:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:56:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:56:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Motion to approve resolution of the planning commission of the Town of Area recommending approval of a
- 0:56:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker special review use for the monastery children's world at Forates Earl Cheesman Street.
- 0:56:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Second.
- 0:56:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so that is a motion from Vice Chair Jackman and a second from
- 0:56:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Rhodes because this is a quad judicial application can we please take role on this?
- 0:56:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Rhodes.
- 0:57:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 0:57:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hampill.
- 0:57:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 0:57:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Shots.
- 0:57:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I.
- 0:57:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair German.
- 0:57:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 0:57:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, I wish.
- 0:57:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 0:57:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Motion passes unanimously.
- 0:57:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 0:57:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So time is 727.
- 0:57:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that closes all curing on the side.
- 0:57:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:57:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:57:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 0:57:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:57:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 0:57:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now that will bring us to the second item
- 0:57:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on our agenda under General Business.
- 0:58:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is a public hearing, a resolution of the Planning Commission of the Town of Erie recommending approval
- 0:58:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the Cole Creek property resoning the time of 727 p.m., and I am opening the public hearing, and I will turn it over to Seth.
- 0:58:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Good
- 0:58:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker evening again.
- 0:58:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The second application I have for you is the Cole Creek property resonating.
- 0:58:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is also formerly
- 0:58:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker known as the page property just to clear up any of that language confusion.
- 0:58:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The request tonight is for approval of a rezoning request from
- 0:58:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the existing zoning, which is ag holding to different zen districts.
- 0:58:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, or I'll explain this more later, but two different zen districts that cover different areas,
- 0:58:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker reserved on the space and ag open space the total acreage is 46 and a half acres and at this time this this
- 0:59:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of course,
- 0:59:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was purchased in X and Zone into the town in late 2023, really 2024, I think when that was approved.
- 0:59:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And at the time it was assigned the ag holding zone district, which is typically used as sort of a placeholder zone,
- 0:59:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker while we were, while council was sort of deliberating and while we
- 0:59:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker were discussing what the future of this property would be so that is why initially was given this ag holding zone district but we're looking now to be a little more specific and call it reserved open space
- 0:59:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in Hag OS.
- 0:59:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that does have an impact on the allowed uses, which I'll get into a little bit more.
- 0:59:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker At this time, of course, we have Director of Parks and Rec here who
- 0:59:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker can talk about this on during question I answered it or a little bit later on in some slides but at this time the rezoning is the only proposal so there are no proposed
- 0:59:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker improvements that are part of this resonating request.
- 1:00:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's no site plan or associated subvision plat or anything like that.
- 1:00:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll get into a little bit more the background and then talk about the proposal and finally get back into the approval criteria.
- 1:00:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
- 1:00:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this is, yes, the page property, Cool Creek property,
- 1:00:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker official address is 1025 County Road 1.5.
- 1:00:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it's pretty hilly, but yeah, you drive past it as you go up, wealth county road, one and a half here.
- 1:00:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it sort of exists in two parcels currently because it's
- 1:00:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker separated by an irrigation ditch.
- 1:00:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And as you can see, yeah, there's quite a bit of slope out here and an existing
- 1:00:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker house or sort of farmhouse,
- 1:00:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some stands of trees and then irrigation ditch.
- 1:00:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there is a pond on site as well.
- 1:01:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Currently, as I mentioned, the property is zoned ag holding, which we don't have a whole lot of in the town, and typically where we do have it, it's on properties that we're recently
- 1:01:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker annexed because as I mentioned it tends to be a placeholder zoning.
- 1:01:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Actually I'll go back up to the slide.
- 1:01:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can see there is already AGO S zoning
- 1:01:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that covers most of the Collier's Hill open space just to the east.
- 1:01:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The park and open space land that's to the northwest is
- 1:01:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker part of the north ridge pd so that's why you see it here on this map as pd rather than some kind of agriculture or open space zoning
- 1:01:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The Compliance No Surprise does call this area, parks open space, and protected lands.
- 1:01:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Of course, we were developing the comprehensive plan as
- 1:01:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some of this was going on.
- 1:01:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So of course, yeah, we find that this application is consistent with the designation as it exists in the Future Linux plan and
- 1:02:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker also is specifically supported by a couple big policies including I guess consistency with the post plan connecting the community through a network
- 1:02:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of public and private parks up in space greenwheels greenways and trails and of course protecting maintaining and managing up in space so that has significant value now
- 1:02:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll get into a little bit more of the proposal itself.
- 1:02:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there is, as I mentioned,
- 1:02:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker two zones happening here, so the
- 1:02:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker bulk of the area will be zone to RO reserved open space.
- 1:02:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's 13 and a half acres.
- 1:02:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the AGOS zoning will cover 14 acres.
- 1:02:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the the big differences here and the reason i think we're doing this at all is because the existing ag holding zone district is not not really
- 1:03:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sufficient
- 1:03:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for our goals or for what we're aiming for here.
- 1:03:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's fairly allowed or it would allow for a bunch of different types of uses that of
- 1:03:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker course we're not interested in at this time so the agos zoning is a little more specific and that again is the smaller portion so that's let me turn back on the laser pointer
- 1:03:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The agos is the smaller parcel too and then the easternmost sliver of land here.
- 1:03:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so that agos the reason that is recommended to be agos or is proposed to be agos in this application is because it does
- 1:03:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have some flexibility for future uses in case Parks and Rec decides to utilize some of the space or the existing building
- 1:03:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that exists in home as an office and then also some flexibility to allow things like keeping of animals and cultivation and
- 1:04:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker grazing and things like that if there were ever to be goats or some kind of other wives stock animal they're helping to maintain the keep the weeds down and things but
- 1:04:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of course the town has no intention of looking into animal hospitals or canals or anything like that, but that is one of the things that is listed in AgroS.
- 1:04:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then the RO, the reserve oven space zoning is the most restrictive of all.
- 1:04:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the only allowed uses in that zone district are open space and park.
- 1:04:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if I go back up,
- 1:04:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you can see that that is the bulk, the 32.5 acre bulk of the middle of the property here is that reserved open space that only allows open space and park uses.
- 1:04:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And as I mentioned, at this time there aren't any improvements planned besides some trail connections,
- 1:05:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the reason for that is of
- 1:05:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker course,
- 1:05:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we anticipate and envision more community engagement and engage, of course, collaboration with Town Council and O staff and things like that
- 1:05:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on the future of this property and what improvements might be included.
- 1:05:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So some of the things that have come up that may be considered in the future are
- 1:05:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker how the property is accessed and how in particular how it's accessed from old town,
- 1:05:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker whether future programming would require parking and what's for the needs of those would have.
- 1:05:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then of course the additional parker recreation facilities or programming.
- 1:05:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so that loop can talk to that more as well.
- 1:05:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker With that, I'll get
- 1:05:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker into the approval criteria.
- 1:05:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So staff is eventually defined that this application is consistent with the complaint and also is supportive of
- 1:06:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the public health safety and journal welfare.
- 1:06:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker At this time, as I mentioned, because there are no major improvements planned to the property,
- 1:06:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this
- 1:06:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker criteria is not exactly applicable.
- 1:06:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So at time of a future, if there were a future programming or new development plant or, I guess, not development, but new facility planned
- 1:06:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker anything like that, town staff would need to evaluate the existing utilities out there and determine what improvements might be needed.
- 1:06:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Staff don't find that this razoning
- 1:06:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is likely to cause adverse impacts on the natural environment.
- 1:06:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Of course, it is helping to preserve the natural environment.
- 1:06:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And no significant adverse
- 1:06:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker impacts are expected on the surrounding properties.
- 1:06:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is sort of the least intense development in terms of zoning or, I guess, a least intense zoning
- 1:06:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker category,
- 1:06:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so no anticipated impacts or no adverse impacts are anticipated there.
- 1:07:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and as I mentioned no new development is proposed with this implac or sorry with this application sorry I'm running out of words I guess I've been talking too much night
- 1:07:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and
- 1:07:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker while this resonance to AGO SNRO reserve events faces does not maybe directly contribute to the town's economic goals, it does indirectly
- 1:07:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker contribute to the town's high quality of life and desirability, so in that sense it sort of indirectly contributes to the town's economics.
- 1:07:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And with that,
- 1:07:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the public notice requirements were met for this hearing this evening.
- 1:07:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Town staff did hold a neighborhood meeting on this application on September 10th,
- 1:07:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and it was fairly lightly attended but we did have a number of folks a few folks come by and just inquire about what the future plans for programming
- 1:08:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or any improvements would be if there's a timeline for that asked about future trail connections and then yeah understanding the difference between the two
- 1:08:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker zoning categories,
- 1:08:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but there were generally was support for this application at that neighborhood meeting.
- 1:08:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And in summary, staff do find that this
- 1:08:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker resonating application complies with the resonating approval criteria and recommend the planning commission.
- 1:08:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Improve the resolution which would recommend approval to town council.
- 1:08:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
- 1:08:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there is no applicant presentation because the town is the applicant.
- 1:08:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So yes, but I'm going to say you are the applicants and see you are officially the applicant in the
- 1:08:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker application so if you have anything else to add would you like to at this time I do not thank you all right now we are going to
- 1:08:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker move to public comments and i assume we have one individual that is at least still signed up okay
- 1:09:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so let me read this off.
- 1:09:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're welcome to come up to the Podium up here for public comment.
- 1:09:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was going to read this off real quickly and then you can say what you need to.
- 1:09:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this brings us to the public comment portion of the hearing.
- 1:09:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Public comment is not an
- 1:09:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker interactive question and answer.
- 1:09:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It will be provided three minutes to talk about this topic.
- 1:09:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When you're at 20 seconds, you're going to receive a warning and
- 1:09:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at the three minute mark I will ask you to wrap things up and then you can sit back down so you're more than welcome to come up here now if you could just state your name and city of residence for the record
- 1:09:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My name is Ann Van Anansay.
- 1:09:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I go by Manette.
- 1:09:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I live in Erie in the North Ridge neighborhood and I'm just here to make a gratitude statement.
- 1:10:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was here on the 12th when Ms.
- 1:10:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Room was packed for the town council meeting.
- 1:10:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I followed the page properly closely and I just wanted to convey the support, the excitement,
- 1:10:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the gratitude of the Erie community that you listened and that just let you know we continue to support this whole process and this
- 1:10:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker project for all the reasons that you define for us.
- 1:10:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm just here to say thank you.
- 1:10:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:10:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:10:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are there any other individuals that are
- 1:10:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker signed up?
- 1:10:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I do not have anyone else signed up for public comment.
- 1:10:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, and just to confirm, I'll be else in the room once to provide public comment.
- 1:10:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:10:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 1:10:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I am going to close pole comments and we will now move to commissioner questions.
- 1:10:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I started
- 1:10:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with you last time, so just real quickly before we get to the questions,
- 1:11:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we will be having a joint study session upcoming to talk about reserve open
- 1:11:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker space in the future.
- 1:11:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We will not be talking about this application or the property because if it is approved today, then it will not be before council.
- 1:11:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is going to be
- 1:11:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the one time to ask some property specific questions.
- 1:11:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So with that, I'm going to turn the commissioner shut.
- 1:11:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well,
- 1:11:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you've anticipated my question, which is why the difference between the two sides of the property are, oh, on one, an
- 1:11:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I go open space on the other.
- 1:11:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks, Harry.
- 1:11:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker He's going to get to that map.
- 1:11:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the reason that Ostab recommended the difference between ROs and picking
- 1:11:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that separation is one.
- 1:11:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You have the cottonwood extension ditch that essentially serves as the border.
- 1:12:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That e-side also contains the
- 1:12:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker single family home and the existing shop and that is where we anticipate if any future programming office space
- 1:12:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker shelters,
- 1:12:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker trail connections, any activation on the site would occur on that.
- 1:12:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's easier to do with the ag open space versus the reserved open space.
- 1:12:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The most I
- 1:12:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker them really wanted to protect as much as the cocry quarter as they could so that's why they kind of chose that line if you will which is again the cottonwood extension ditch and
- 1:12:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just one more question, and I think it's probably for planning staff or people on the commission if we could only testify, but the agos versus RO,
- 1:12:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker those are both consequential for the purposes of the charter correct.
- 1:12:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, I would say that the reserved open space is a consequence of the
- 1:12:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker charter and Elliot can kind of explain a little bit how that came about.
- 1:13:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yep, so the reserve open space was established after the adoption of the charter,
- 1:13:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker specifically for the purpose of creating a zone per section 11.02 of the charter for proper to be zoned as charter designated open space
- 1:13:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And this is the first application to utilize the zone and a charter designation process,
- 1:13:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but the ARO zone specifically
- 1:13:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was specifically created to designate open space under the provisions of the charter.
- 1:13:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Other question.
- 1:13:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner.
- 1:13:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Ahaba?
- 1:13:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sist.
- 1:13:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll phrase it as a question even though I know the answer.
- 1:13:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If it's
- 1:13:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker reserved as open space, how does it get resoned?
- 1:13:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It has to appear that Charter has to go to a vote of the people.
- 1:14:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:14:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For the split,
- 1:14:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the ag open space,
- 1:14:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lying following the ditch,
- 1:14:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would you expect to effectively build a road through
- 1:14:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that to access that house or facilities.
- 1:14:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's already an existing access off of Kenny Road 1.5 right where Harry's pointer
- 1:14:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is.
- 1:14:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So no new roads on the property.
- 1:14:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The only construction that would happen on the property is installation of the trail that would connect the North Ridge trail to the north
- 1:14:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and to the co-creed trail to the south.
- 1:14:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I guess if the entire property was zoned as reserved open space, that building would
- 1:14:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker effectively be condemned is that correct?
- 1:14:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Not necessarily.
- 1:14:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:14:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just be basically
- 1:14:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker unusable I mean you couldn't have any kind of activation of it or yeah it'd be really really limited and what it could be used
- 1:15:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:15:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's all I have.
- 1:15:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:15:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commission breakfast?
- 1:15:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No questions for this one.
- 1:15:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair Jackman.
- 1:15:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that occupied
- 1:15:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sacrifice now?
- 1:15:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is not.
- 1:15:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is used for storage.
- 1:15:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, is that going to continue?
- 1:15:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that the plan to continue with it afterwards?
- 1:15:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is the medium term plan.
- 1:15:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We haven't determined
- 1:15:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the final use of that structure yet just because of timing and budget and other projects that are occupying staff time well next year we do have some money in the budget to do an
- 1:15:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ecological restoration plan for the property and then once that happens then we'll turn around and figure out what we want to do with the final property.
- 1:15:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I excuse me the final the
- 1:15:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker home in the shop.
- 1:15:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's on the site.
- 1:15:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, I guess.
- 1:15:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just had a heresy.
- 1:15:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is the pond?
- 1:16:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does it have any use?
- 1:16:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like, is it?
- 1:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it was built for a recreational
- 1:16:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pond.
- 1:16:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think the long-term plan, and this is what I just alluded to, the plan to kind of give us some more study next year,
- 1:16:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the desire and the hope is to turn that into a recreational pond for community
- 1:16:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker right now it's just a seepage pond right okay there's more questions thank you for welcome
- 1:16:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Currently there is a building on the property.
- 1:16:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Correct me if I'm wrong, but that is on the reserved open space side.
- 1:16:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There is a small pump structure in the middle of the property pretty much right where Harry's
- 1:16:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker laser poinry is but that will be removed and that's it because it's a non-functioning building it used to manage the old pump system the home and the shop
- 1:17:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker around the ag open space side.
- 1:17:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so we have we'll remove that item off there and there will be absolutely nothing on there and it will
- 1:17:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker be reserved open space in perpetuity as per charter 1103.
- 1:17:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think it is.
- 1:17:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, not in perpetuity.
- 1:17:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If we can vote it out, it's not perpetuate.
- 1:17:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Correct.
- 1:17:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, a less voter.
- 1:17:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The appraiser will be specific.
- 1:17:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 1:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that will be titled in everything so that it
- 1:17:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is restricted on the title and I guess how would that it wouldn't be on the title per se it would be the zone district I
- 1:17:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker think the creation of the RO district was specifically for the charter.
- 1:17:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So once a property is
- 1:17:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker zoned RO, it would trigger, it would be considered designated open space under the charter and would be afforded those protections.
- 1:18:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, I mean, it couldn't be the, to
- 1:18:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker resonate, there were need to be a process and, you know, an application could be filed, but it couldn't be approved in my source of the people.
- 1:18:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:18:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're going to talk a lot more about this on the 24th.
- 1:18:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know.
- 1:18:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know.
- 1:18:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And how exactly are we doing?
- 1:18:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What do we have in mind for keeping the inventory of this because we're doing this reasonowing so that is in relation to the
- 1:18:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker charter specifically.
- 1:18:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know that it says we have to have an inventory of the properties, but now we're creating an inventory of those that are
- 1:18:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker zoned, I assume we have a process in mind of maintaining the inventory of those that have already been zoned.
- 1:18:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We use our GIS software to keep in Motori of all open space that we own in maintain.
- 1:19:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so it gets a lot easier for us in the future through the GI.
- 1:19:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Not necessarily.
- 1:19:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so we have a way to record.
- 1:19:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:19:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are there any other questions from the individuals up there?
- 1:19:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Actually, one quick one, sorry.
- 1:19:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There had been a concern at one point about some of the waste that was on the property.
- 1:19:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I believe that was found not to be an issue.
- 1:19:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Correct.
- 1:19:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We get a conduct
- 1:19:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker environmental site assessment both phase one and phase two and and they had no findings thank you um i know
- 1:19:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this is a weird one because we're the applicant.
- 1:19:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There have been many derivatives of this that have been proposed and we
- 1:19:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are doing this because of the homeral charter requirements that OSTAB has to provide a recommendation.
- 1:20:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Why was it that the property as we
- 1:20:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker see it, the zoning that is proposed, there is this large portion that is the reserve open space, and then that small portion that is the ag open space.
- 1:20:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What
- 1:20:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was the final recommendation or the reason why Ostab decided that we want to have everything in there or was it not Ostab's recommendation was a
- 1:20:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker council's.
- 1:20:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What you're seeing as proposed zoning is O-Stab's recommendation.
- 1:20:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They wanted to protect as much of the Coqui corridor as they could in a large portion of
- 1:20:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the property.
- 1:20:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's why the large portion is reserved open space.
- 1:20:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've already explained the ag open space reusing on the east side of the Cottonwood extension ditch.
- 1:20:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The parcel two ag
- 1:20:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker open space,
- 1:20:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they felt it provided some opportunity for future pollinated gardens or parking connectivity with Reliance Park.
- 1:21:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
- 1:21:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we wanted to have that flexibility for that smaller parcel in case there was some use that would be restricted from the reserve open space.
- 1:21:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:21:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And just so we can put it on the record again, this is the most restrictive zoning class that we have.
- 1:21:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is park open
- 1:21:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker space or wireless carrier facility that are permitted and almost all direct current okay all right any other questions there's a question
- 1:21:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker please along the co-creek trail there's a retaining wall i guess that would be part of the property and maintained by parks and right no that's actually part already part of uh town of
- 1:21:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Various property along Cole Creek.
- 1:21:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:21:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then I guess just the comment I'll pull it up.
- 1:21:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Reserve open space permitted uses are parked
- 1:21:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and something that's park adjacent park and open space and then parking lot by special review you could go wireless facilities on reserve open space
- 1:22:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe right.
- 1:22:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is the time to ask the question on this one, sir.
- 1:22:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, you are correct.
- 1:22:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Reserve open space cannot even have the wireless facilities unlike every other one.
- 1:22:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I guess another comment slash question.
- 1:22:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Staff advention,
- 1:22:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker potentially a park in AGOS or parking on AGOS for reliance parts.
- 1:22:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's not allowed by special reviews or by right in AGOS.
- 1:23:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Unless I'm wrong, question mark.
- 1:23:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For a much one.
- 1:23:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Agos, I believe the parcel too that's mentioned,
- 1:23:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker separated by the boulder ditch it was mentioned that maybe used as a parking lot for reliance park but at least on what I'm
- 1:23:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker seeing parking is not an available use in AGOS.
- 1:23:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, if that's the gold, then we
- 1:23:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker should not designate that, or it can be redesignated.
- 1:23:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is correct.
- 1:23:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Egg OS.
- 1:23:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eggo West does not allow a parking lot.
- 1:23:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so we wouldn't put a parking lot.
- 1:23:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or you could just resound there.
- 1:23:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or could as we resound?
- 1:23:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just use money.
- 1:23:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:24:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:24:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's all I have.
- 1:24:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any of the last questions?
- 1:24:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This does not appear as it does.
- 1:24:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Park or open space permit a trail.
- 1:24:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does it permit a trail
- 1:24:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to be constructed through the property if it's reserved open space?
- 1:24:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, yes, oh, yeah, I go us in.
- 1:24:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Ah, I don't do.
- 1:24:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, perfect.
- 1:24:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 1:24:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No other questions.
- 1:24:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Go on once.
- 1:24:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Go on twice.
- 1:24:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:24:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, the time is 754.
- 1:24:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to close the public comment portion and we will move on to
- 1:24:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker deliberation.
- 1:24:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm going to start again with Commissioner Shots.
- 1:24:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I can make a motion.
- 1:25:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commons deliberation.
- 1:25:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It
- 1:25:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What's good?
- 1:25:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commission have a nice to see the charter provisions starting here.
- 1:25:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is there a open
- 1:25:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker space on the books?
- 1:25:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is it exciting?
- 1:25:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Brutis, yeah.
- 1:25:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've been with this property since we first started talking to Mr.
- 1:25:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Page about it and it's
- 1:25:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker gone through many, many iterations.
- 1:25:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is good to finally see it resolved.
- 1:25:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I also was the primary author of the Open Space part of the Charter.
- 1:25:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's good to see that as well.
- 1:25:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So thank you for everyone's preservations through this one.
- 1:25:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair Drecklin.
- 1:25:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Great job staff.
- 1:25:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Very important work you're doing.
- 1:25:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:25:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker um i do want to reiterate uh this is the first of a long process upcoming so thank you essentially
- 1:26:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you in advance.
- 1:26:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I understand why there has been a want and need to have this reserved as reserved
- 1:26:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker open space for voter consideration if it were to require resonating in the future, especially with some of the funding mechanisms that were used
- 1:26:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker by the town to acquire the property.
- 1:26:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are some other things related to the funding mechanisms that is above our pagrades.
- 1:26:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh my god, go into those, but
- 1:26:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker may I have a motion let me get the so move to approve a resolution of the planning commission
- 1:26:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the town of Erie recommending approval of us.
- 1:26:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sorry.
- 1:26:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Revolution of the planning commission.
- 1:26:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The town of Erie recommending approval
- 1:26:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the co-creek property razoning.
- 1:26:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Second.
- 1:26:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so that is a motion from Commissioner Brutus and a second from Vice Chair Dreckman.
- 1:27:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can I have a roll call vote, please?
- 1:27:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Brotis.
- 1:27:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 1:27:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hempill.
- 1:27:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 1:27:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Shots.
- 1:27:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hi.
- 1:27:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair Drackman.
- 1:27:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 1:27:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Chair Sawish.
- 1:27:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 1:27:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is unanimous.
- 1:27:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:27:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you, Saif.
- 1:27:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know we will see you in a couple weeks to have a larger discussion about this.
- 1:27:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So thank you.
- 1:27:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you very much.
- 1:27:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, we're about to get into a
- 1:27:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker UDC item do we need a quick moment or are we good to continue moving on?
- 1:27:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to refill water, but I can hear you from outside.
- 1:27:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, let's just take a few minutes.
- 1:27:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll reconvene at 802 p.m.
- 1:27:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm good.
- 1:32:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This now brings us to the final item on our agenda.
- 1:32:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is a resolution
- 1:32:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the planning commission of the Town of Eury, recommending that the Town Council adopted an ordinance amending Title 10 of the UTC, adding Chapter 16 short-term rentals and amending Chapter 3 use regulations of Chapter 11 definitions.
- 1:33:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we will turn it over to theft.
- 1:33:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:33:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's good to be in this side.
- 1:33:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You'll look taller, I don't know.
- 1:33:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we'll talk about short-term
- 1:33:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rentals tonight.
- 1:33:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sure you're all quite excited, but this is an update to the EDC, so it is important.
- 1:33:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll go through some things real quick.
- 1:33:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll do my best to exploit
- 1:33:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the process and not talk too much.
- 1:33:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we'll talk about existing conditions.
- 1:33:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The outreach efforts we did as part of this.
- 1:33:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Aspects of regulations, which we all find riveting,
- 1:33:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker approval criteria and recommendations.
- 1:33:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So very quick high-level view of the conditions here in the town of Erie, evidence there are any questions later on as part of this where we got this data in all that.
- 1:33:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So as of right now, there are at least 60 STR shortenmentals in the town of Erie.
- 1:34:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As of note there, STRs are
- 1:34:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker not permitted in the town, but they are 60 plus that we know of that are operating.
- 1:34:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For STRs, you can break them down a couple of different ways.
- 1:34:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One of the most logical
- 1:34:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ways to do it is how the STR operates or how much of the property it takes up.
- 1:34:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what you have here in this little pi chart.
- 1:34:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As you can see, the largest
- 1:34:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker share is whole house shorten rentals.
- 1:34:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That means someone takes their entire home and offers that as an STR.
- 1:34:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The other large portion of that is attached ADUs or accessory
- 1:34:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker dwelling units.
- 1:34:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Something like a basement department, for example, would be an attached ADU.
- 1:34:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then you've got a couple of smaller categories, some properties that have multiple shortenmentals on
- 1:34:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker them.
- 1:34:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some that just share their space, like you have a room that you rent out as a short-term rental on Airbnb.
- 1:34:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then the smallest portion there is the detached ADUs.
- 1:34:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Think those garage apartments, for example.
- 1:34:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the map on the right shows it's a heat map and if we're not familiar with that that essentially shows us the the density of points on a map so the the the brighter yellow
- 1:35:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that is, the closer and more dense those points are together.
- 1:35:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if you can't see from this map,
- 1:35:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the most dense area of short-term rentals is Old Town,
- 1:35:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which should
- 1:35:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker surprise probably nobody here that the most short-term rentals are in the neighborhood with the most businesses that is the most walkable and also the most recently priced in the town of Viri you also see throughout town there's
- 1:35:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker other smaller pockets of shorten mentals, but the lines, which shouldn't say the lines sure, but the highest density is an old town.
- 1:35:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's part of this
- 1:35:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker effort we did, I would call it extensive outreach.
- 1:35:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There was a project page on Engage Erie where we took a couple of comments, including this one you can see on the right that I won't read,
- 1:35:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but you all are more than welcome to read it.
- 1:35:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did for current STR operators or owners.
- 1:36:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did mailers in advance
- 1:36:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of an August 16th meeting for those owners and operators at the ECC,
- 1:36:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as well as additional one-on-one office hours with myself, all offered those through the Engage Erie
- 1:36:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker landing page.
- 1:36:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Excuse me.
- 1:36:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker After that, we did an old town residence in business owners meeting.
- 1:36:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We noticed that by doing door hangings all throughout old town.
- 1:36:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So on
- 1:36:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one day in mid-August the entire planning staff walked out on a Wednesday morning and hung hangers on all the doors and if you live in old town and got one more than you'll welcome so that was a great time we
- 1:36:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker did that session at Foxdock coffee here in town.
- 1:36:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I guess all of me see what this next slide is.
- 1:36:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll back up a little bit because I didn't expound upon the first owners
- 1:36:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker meeting, we had four folks shop there.
- 1:36:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Give some various feedback on some very early drafts of regulations that helped us to craft.
- 1:36:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Will you see in front of you today?
- 1:36:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then I had one, one, one meeting with an
- 1:36:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker individuals who runs a short-term rental as well.
- 1:37:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker At that old-time meeting we had, I believe it's eight people show up.
- 1:37:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mix of business owners and residents,
- 1:37:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker through a presentation and interacted with some boards as well letting us know how they feel about shortened rentals that was really helpful and understanding exactly what happens in all time what folks want to see in more importantly how shorten
- 1:37:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rentals may impact them, given that we have the most shorten rentals there in Old Town.
- 1:37:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Additional outreach in September.
- 1:37:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did a traditional pop event,
- 1:37:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if you will, where we show up somewhere with limited or no notice, with a couple of posture boards and some planners and some stickers, and just our asking people questions.
- 1:37:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we did that at the ECC and the entryway there
- 1:37:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on the 21st from I believe it was 430 to 630.
- 1:37:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We interacted with Sent Mike 30 people.
- 1:37:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Got some good feedback on how folks engage with STRs and how they feel about them.
- 1:37:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then spoke this motherfolks as well kind of outside of those posters about how they feel about them.
- 1:38:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We had a second SCR owner operator meetings with the mailers again,
- 1:38:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but this time we added in emails we're able to grab email addresses from the utility billing side so we could effectively contact folks and get a hold of them and get them to show up and give us their feedback and shorten retails
- 1:38:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that was attended by Belief 14 or 15 folks this time around at the 24th at the ECC.
- 1:38:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So much more engagement from the owners of the operators community.
- 1:38:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, really good feedback that helped to crap what you have in front
- 1:38:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of you today.
- 1:38:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So as we move past the kind of engagement for some of this, we talk about short term rentals and key aspects and parts of regulation.
- 1:38:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can break regulations
- 1:38:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for short-term rentals into two categories.
- 1:38:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The regulatory and process category, which deals with the permanent life, the permanent cost, how you classify them, who owns the property, and then you look at the community impact side,
- 1:38:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which is the things that we hear most about short-term rentals, right?
- 1:38:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How many people are there?
- 1:38:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Where are the cars parking?
- 1:38:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What is the limit?
- 1:38:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are we sending notices out?
- 1:38:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How do we know it's there?
- 1:38:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So these are the two buckets those things can fall into.
- 1:39:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and those are the primary aspects of short-term mental regulations.
- 1:39:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can also break it down this way to kind of help understand the flow of it.
- 1:39:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you've got the permit, portion of it, which is the duration of the
- 1:39:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permit,
- 1:39:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the use and control portion, which is permit limits and types, owner and activancy,
- 1:39:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the site use and design, which is the posting and contact site layout and the correct evaction, which becomes
- 1:39:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the sort of most difficult portion, which is how do we enforce this, would a violations look like.
- 1:39:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So with any UDC update or any new regulation, you
- 1:39:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker first have to define exactly what you're regulating.
- 1:39:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So here you have the definition of short-term mental, which is a residential unit or any room therein or any accessory dwelling unit
- 1:39:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker available for at least for a term of less than 30 consecutive days, excluding bed and breakfast, hotels and hotels, and month-to-month leases.
- 1:39:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then with any new use that's defined, you also must define where it goes in the code in terms of what zoning districts allow it.
- 1:40:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is just a snapshot of the
- 1:40:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker primary use section of chapter three in the accessory use section of chapter three.
- 1:40:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And you'll see they mirror one another in terms of where short term rentals are allowed as a primary use, so think whole house
- 1:40:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker shorten mental, and then where they're allowed is an accessory use, think accessory, dwelling unit, for example.
- 1:40:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So those are allowed in most zoning districts in town, except for your airport districts,
- 1:40:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker your industrial districts, and your open space districts.
- 1:40:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And they'll also note that the Old Town Districts OTR downtown neighbored mixed use are subject to potential additional
- 1:40:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker regulations.
- 1:40:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Getting into the meat of this,
- 1:40:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I hit the high levels here of what the regulations call out.
- 1:40:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is allowable as a use as I said in all commercial residential and next use districts as primary and accessory use.
- 1:40:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And when we put a lot of this stuff together, we also did look
- 1:41:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at neighboring communities and prevailing good practices in this as well, but I didn't want to blow out the slide deck here for you guys with all of that, but just know that we looked at all of our neighboring communities,
- 1:41:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker folks who's in the region, and then did a literature review of good practices in short-term runter regulations, which is where mix of these things come from.
- 1:41:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's a by-anual,
- 1:41:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permitting process, so that means that if someone applies for a short and rental this year, it's good for this year and next year.
- 1:41:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the purpose of that is to reduce the burden on both the property owners and
- 1:41:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker staff and repermitting every other year.
- 1:41:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then a $200 fee.
- 1:41:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Those are non-transferable permits.
- 1:41:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you move yourself the house, that permit floats away and you cannot give it to the next person.
- 1:41:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or can you take it with you?
- 1:41:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the way we're going to deal with fire code, building code, homeowners associations is an AFET David sign to notarize that says
- 1:41:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker my property holds up to all building codes, all fire codes.
- 1:42:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And by the way, there are no conditions, covet, and restrictions as part of an HA that would prevent me from doing this.
- 1:42:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The applicant or owner must be either a person or a majority trustor or LLC owner.
- 1:42:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This one thing we heard back from SDR operators quite
- 1:42:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a lot is, you know, being in a trust or LC is a way to protect themselves from my ability.
- 1:42:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So while we initially said that had to be just a person who recognized that we didn't want to place undue
- 1:42:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker burden on folks who already operate these.
- 1:42:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Primer limits, one permit per applicant, one STR per property.
- 1:42:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you can't have a home with three
- 1:42:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker bedrooms and three separate short-term rentals.
- 1:42:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm a lot of people would call that a hotel.
- 1:42:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you just, you won't be able to do that under these regulations.
- 1:42:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then one pro applicant.
- 1:42:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you as a person
- 1:42:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker who owns a property, just that SCR permit, that's all you get.
- 1:42:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In Old Town Specific Lay, I know I mentioned there'd be some regulations for Old Town that would help to permanent
- 1:43:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker potential negative impacts.
- 1:43:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There must be a 250-foot walking distance separation between short term rentals from property line to property line.
- 1:43:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's a
- 1:43:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker established pedestrian paths of sidewalks, trails, crosswalks, those sorts of things to help to mitigate any potential impact of clustering of church and rentals in old town.
- 1:43:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now, running to be as permissive as possible,
- 1:43:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we realize that there may be instances where short-term rentals be closer than that to each other.
- 1:43:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we allow an SRU process
- 1:43:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to potentially have short-term rentals that are closer than 250 feet apart.
- 1:43:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker More stuff.
- 1:43:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So design and layout.
- 1:43:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I know you're all
- 1:43:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker really just enjoying this me reading from slides, but so design and layout, two occupants base.
- 1:43:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So what does that mean?
- 1:43:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sometimes you have an STR that doesn't have an established bedroom like an efficiency apartment.
- 1:43:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you can have two people in that as a base.
- 1:43:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then two additional occupants for every bedroom that's in the property.
- 1:44:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What we didn't want to do is restrict properties based on maximum accupencies as
- 1:44:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a hard number because that gets really hard to enforce.
- 1:44:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're leaving on the property owner and the property itself to limit regulate how many folks can stay in that short-term rental.
- 1:44:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Also one parking space
- 1:44:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker per bedroom.
- 1:44:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They'll have to show us on a sketch site plan where those parking spaces will be.
- 1:44:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They don't have to be on site.
- 1:44:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They can be on the street.
- 1:44:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We just need to know where cars are going to park for a short-term
- 1:44:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rental.
- 1:44:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Urgent response by owner.
- 1:44:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So in a lot of instances, we need an owner to either show up or answer the phone.
- 1:44:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's an emergency or tenants that need to be removed.
- 1:44:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they will have to either establish themselves as the person to originally respond within one hour or someone in their stead who can be there, answer to phone, and be unseen within one hour to take your venue
- 1:44:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in Burton Caesar issues.
- 1:44:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then finally, posted contact info.
- 1:44:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's something on the inside of the door that says, hey, this is where you call.
- 1:44:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is where you can find them.
- 1:45:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker By the way, this is also the address that you're
- 1:45:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at because a lot of times you stand short to rental.
- 1:45:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You don't know where you are.
- 1:45:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's an emergency you can call and you have to address right there.
- 1:45:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then violations and enforcement.
- 1:45:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So obviously a violation would be not having a permit number one.
- 1:45:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any violation of the ordinance like a noise ordinance or a parking ordinance?
- 1:45:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or failure to comply with any part of this section.
- 1:45:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker enforcement in terms of violations then in terms of how do we keep people from being repeated fenders how do we remove bad actors from the system this is a civil violation not a criminal violation goes
- 1:45:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker before the court here in Erie, three violations in a rolling 12-month period of results in a suspension,
- 1:45:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a second suspension in any time
- 1:45:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker results in a two-year permit ban.
- 1:45:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And actually, I think that's a missed type.
- 1:45:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Elliot, I believe we said five years out of the draft, so I think I just forgot to update that in the PowerPoint presentation, but just know that
- 1:45:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a second suspension within five years results in a two-year ban on a permit.
- 1:46:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's a typo on my part.
- 1:46:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I apologize.
- 1:46:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker With all that,
- 1:46:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker UDC sets out some approval criteria for amendments of the UDC in 10-1718-C9.
- 1:46:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's the
- 1:46:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker proposed amendment promote the health safety in general workforce, the community?
- 1:46:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does the proposed amendment, is it generally consistent with the complaint in the state of purposes of the EDC?
- 1:46:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And finally,
- 1:46:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is the proposed amendment necessary or desirable because of changing conditions, new planning concepts, or other social or economic conditions?
- 1:46:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So with that, there's a sample recommendation in front of you for ease of use, but I am happy to answer any questions, clarifications, or
- 1:46:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker concerns you may have?
- 1:46:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:46:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm assuming that there's going to be a number of questions on this one from the Commission.
- 1:47:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm the servantinus,
- 1:47:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just so we can go a different way instead of on the ends each time so I'm going to start and then we'll go on right left and then right left again okay first question by default
- 1:47:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker By definition, say we have a Lunar Super Home like in flat iron meadows, and somebody wanted to rent this out.
- 1:47:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Technically, a Lunar
- 1:47:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker super home is two different units that would not be permissible to rent out both of those because we are defining it as
- 1:47:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one separate unit or enclosure for an individual bedroom, ADU, etc., meaning they cannot separate
- 1:47:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the two as two separate units for rental.
- 1:47:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It can only be one section of it or the entire house, including both of those sections.
- 1:47:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some have familiar dose particular properties.
- 1:48:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's basically the idea of it was supposed to be the stages of life where you can have an in-law quarter.
- 1:48:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There is
- 1:48:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a separate entry into the home and you have your own separate grad space and it is also able to be locked off from the main portion of the home
- 1:48:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, if that's, it's technically one home.
- 1:48:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's one STR on the property.
- 1:48:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If it were two separate parcels, it'd be a different story.
- 1:48:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was one parcel, one home, one STR permit.
- 1:48:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, and so what you're saying
- 1:48:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is it can only have one.
- 1:48:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They can only pick the entire house, the main portion of the house, or that separate inlock order.
- 1:48:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We will not allow two.
- 1:48:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They won't.
- 1:48:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker okay um is there a rationale as to why we won't allow that uh the potential for adverse impact uh when you have two shorten rentals on one property
- 1:48:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker creates potential nuisance for the surrounding community and it protects the residential nature and quite enjoyment for folks who live around the area okay
- 1:49:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In many other,
- 1:49:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker my wife and I, we normally do Airbnb's VRBOs when we travel and subdivide a houses specifically
- 1:49:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for rental purposes are something that we see.
- 1:49:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If we look at your chart here,
- 1:49:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 35.6%
- 1:49:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are the entire house.
- 1:49:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 27.1 are attached ADU.
- 1:49:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 18.6% are multiple units.
- 1:49:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Shared space and so on and so forth.
- 1:49:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're saying that 18.6 per cent.
- 1:49:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so while we're talking about 11 of the 60 current STRs in Erie would
- 1:49:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker no longer be able to rent out all of the units.
- 1:49:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It would only be one of those units that they'd be able to.
- 1:49:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's correct.
- 1:49:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:49:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:50:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For the WTON attorney, there are no provisions for say
- 1:50:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the special event situation which we are going to be seeing January 1st through 31st where the provisions of multiple units specifically
- 1:50:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker can be relieved from the code for a time being, what does that call them?
- 1:50:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll
- 1:50:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker defer to Darrell.
- 1:50:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, thanks.
- 1:50:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm noticing in this presentation when we cut it down, I think one slide got dropped and it was referring to special event permits.
- 1:50:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So one thing in the ordinance that you have in front of you
- 1:50:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we are proposing is a short-term rental or special event as CR permits.
- 1:50:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you see that in Lewis Philippe Exclusively, and then superior does it as well alongside the regular permitting process, as
- 1:50:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I believe Boulder does.
- 1:50:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So what would happen is Town Council would establish certain special event timelines, probably Sundance for the first year or two, and then folks can pull a
- 1:51:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker special event SDR permit that would allow them to bypass some of these regulations.
- 1:51:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But it only allows for STRs in old town that are
- 1:51:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker within 250 feet correct.
- 1:51:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll point the commission to page 6 of the draft ordinance section 10, 16, 11, which sets the parameters for special event permits, and it
- 1:51:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker does allow for essentially the suspension of the normal rules in periods designated by town council
- 1:51:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, but it's very specific in terms of what rules are
- 1:51:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are no longer included during that time, and none of those are multiple
- 1:52:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permits for the same location.
- 1:52:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Direct.
- 1:52:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It
- 1:52:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is not permitted at any time to have multiple permits on the same location if I'm reading the drafted ornaments.
- 1:52:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We don't even allow under a special event
- 1:52:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker situation for multiple STRs to be on the same location.
- 1:52:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, that's correct.
- 1:52:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we have absolutely no hotels, no
- 1:52:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker hotels, no one or two bed and breakfasts currently.
- 1:52:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we know that this is important for the need that the surrounding
- 1:52:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker community is going to have is that maybe something we want to add in there where those can also be that specific portion can be suspended by resolution
- 1:52:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the council.
- 1:52:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So during the special event permit, timelight only not is a regular permit, they can have more than one permit.
- 1:53:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, it simply could do absolutely.
- 1:53:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, we develop code like this.
- 1:53:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have to balance the needs of the property owner or the desire of the property owner to engage and write for you to their property with the quite enjoyment of
- 1:53:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker folks around them.
- 1:53:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, well, I don't disagree that there is a need for lodging space.
- 1:53:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In Eri and throughout the region, this is a result of sun dance in this case.
- 1:53:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would
- 1:53:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker urge balance in approach.
- 1:53:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know that I consider it disagreed with that.
- 1:53:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Approach, but I would think about the potential impacts
- 1:53:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the folks who live around those units.
- 1:53:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Last question I have, then I'll turn it over.
- 1:53:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What is the application fee for a special review use?
- 1:53:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know what it is Kelly I don't either I don't have my fees memorized yet
- 1:54:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:54:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So an SRU is according to the town
- 1:54:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker website,
- 1:54:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 1,200 for oil and gas and 500 for all others.
- 1:54:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we are going to subject an applicant to our special
- 1:54:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker review use.
- 1:54:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A $500 application for a $200 permit.
- 1:54:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it has to go before this body and before council.
- 1:54:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's
- 1:54:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker correct we would that is not that that is a lot for somebody to have to do well we we
- 1:55:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker felt that if we didn't allow encroachment upon that 250 foot buffer,
- 1:55:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that it would potentially exclude a number of folks from holding permits,
- 1:55:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker especially some that currently at least one that currently exists in all town.
- 1:55:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we felt that the SRU process was the best way to balance potential increased impacts with an increased density of shortenmentals.
- 1:55:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rentals.
- 1:55:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can I understand what you just said?
- 1:55:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you said that was based on who are currently provided shorten rentals that we can find correct.
- 1:55:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, that were prohibited within the town.
- 1:55:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Currently prohibited, yes.
- 1:55:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're not enforced.
- 1:55:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We created code,
- 1:55:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker drafted code for allowing those that currently have a prohibited
- 1:55:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker use within the town to bring them into alignment with our code.
- 1:55:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's exactly what we did.
- 1:55:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We don't want to create any additional non-conformances.
- 1:56:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so the goal of code is to create a framework that
- 1:56:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker folks can comply with voluntarily.
- 1:56:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:56:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to stop with my questions because I'm at three.
- 1:56:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have a friend who went to the 24th meeting and she had
- 1:56:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker phenomenal things to say about you and how it was held so thank you i appreciate that yeah and she was hesitant going in so i think that's super important so for the one permit her
- 1:56:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker house ape if it's a duplex or something was that based that decision based on like surrounding communities or feedback from surrounding residents on those specific properties in aerie was that the one permit for me yeah
- 1:56:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sorry, if it's a house that you're like a duplex or something that you could potentially have to.
- 1:56:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 1:56:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we did have trouble that internally in determining how to handle like duplexes and condominium facilities.
- 1:56:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you look at most of the
- 1:56:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker communities around us, if not all of them, they do not allow more than one STR for property.
- 1:56:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we don't want to get into the habit of everyone does it we should do it, but also it might be a really good practice
- 1:56:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to do.
- 1:56:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we kind of found that that was a good practice to engage in.
- 1:57:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is it relates to, say, for example, duplexes on the same parcel?
- 1:57:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That becomes a
- 1:57:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker challenge, but the buffer tends to help us circumvent that by saying, oh, hey, you have due collects.
- 1:57:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And personally, the left gets an STR permit.
- 1:57:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then the personally, the right, can't unless they're an old
- 1:57:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker town, they can explore and I start you.
- 1:57:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right, that makes sense.
- 1:57:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:57:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then, um,
- 1:57:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it was another question.
- 1:57:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I understand the point of the
- 1:57:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker distance between the short-term runnels and then the permit not going with the sale.
- 1:57:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that common?
- 1:57:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm just looking at it, I guess, from the private property understand point or like a real, like
- 1:57:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a real estate sandpoint about like I you know in theory if I want to property in then I'm using it as a rental and I go to sell it to someone who's going to have to acquire maybe a second loan it's not a primary loan but they don't know if they're actually going to be able to secure that
- 1:57:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permit.
- 1:57:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like how is that decision come to her?
- 1:57:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Was it?
- 1:57:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, I can't speak for every single one off top of my head, but many of the surrounding communities with
- 1:58:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker STR regulations made it such that those are not transferable to property owners just because the way one property under uses an STR might be completely different.
- 1:58:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The next downer in charge of the space used or how it's used.
- 1:58:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:58:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're going to be able to just take a look at it and make sure that it's still in conformance with our regulations.
- 1:58:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:58:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That makes sense.
- 1:58:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then my last question was about the parking spot for like her bedroom.
- 1:58:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So streets parking.
- 1:58:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like even if it's up like it's public street parking but that's fine as long as there's like room and front of their house for four cars absolutely yeah again it's just to make sure that someone can account for the additional car right it might have yeah well
- 1:58:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker work with folks i mean we don't right the idea is not make it so restricted that oh if you can't work all you drive away you're out of luck and right make sure folks can do this but also we're not creating nuisance yeah that makes sense okay those are my questions
- 1:58:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 1:58:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hubba.
- 1:58:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This might be for W.D.
- 1:58:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Town and Tarani.
- 1:58:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The draft ordinance seems to use applicant
- 1:58:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker person and owner kind of not quite interchangeably but where all of those uses
- 1:59:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker intentional
- 1:59:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with the wording in the ordinance or is there what you start and then I'll remember what
- 1:59:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker my example yes because I think we defined applicant yes we did go through that practice I don't have you know I will look at the ordinance but they're
- 1:59:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we did have a conversation on how to use the terms depending on the status of the person, whether they had a permit or where they were in the
- 1:59:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker process.
- 1:59:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If there are certain references that, I don't think we define owner.
- 1:59:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We define owner in some of, do we define owner?
- 1:59:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, we do have to find owner.
- 1:59:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 1:59:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did go through the exercise of how do we define individuals based on or reference individuals based on various statises
- 2:00:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of their process,
- 2:00:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker how they fit into the regulations.
- 2:00:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, I guess I think what
- 2:00:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker prompted this question was the 10-16-12 violations in enforcement.
- 2:00:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it just talks about the owner having...
- 2:00:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like the permit but then in an earlier one it talked about no person can have more than one
- 2:00:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker STR.
- 2:00:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, I don't have a solid example, but I think it might be worth just another reading.
- 2:00:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, no,
- 2:00:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we will come through it before ecosystem yeah it's hard to catch all that so yeah and then onto the parking there
- 2:01:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was a neighbor could comment about parking spaces equal to bedrooms minus one and you said you consider it what considerations did you make for
- 2:01:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that so we tried to look at parking all the sickly in terms of where short-term rentals would occur and
- 2:01:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we've found that reducing by one space wouldn't in most cases have any kind of effect on whether or not we'd approve of STR permit so
- 2:01:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we wanted to keep it the same in that for ease as well, like looking at number of bedrooms and parking spaces is pretty simple.
- 2:01:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the argument from the community
- 2:01:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for the operators, it was such that, you know, not everyone comes in their own separate cars.
- 2:01:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sometimes they carp a little bit in STR and totally agree.
- 2:01:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like, I've used their being before and sometimes they come in a whole car.
- 2:01:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but we also looked at the other side of that, which is we live near a couple of universities and we're folks come from out of town and all over and sometimes eight people show up in eight cars.
- 2:02:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we need to balance that appropriately
- 2:02:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we've felt like just keeping it as is was the best way to balance.
- 2:02:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:02:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I had one more, but I forgot and
- 2:02:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll remember when it comes back to me.
- 2:02:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Alright, Commissioner Broth.
- 2:02:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so 10, 16, 9 standards for STRs in Otown
- 2:02:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Residential.
- 2:02:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Why do some of these things only apply to Old Town?
- 2:02:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It seems some of these should apply like noise,
- 2:02:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker should apply everywhere.
- 2:02:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm looking at B1.
- 2:02:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, that's a great question.
- 2:02:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So when we developed the CB1, so when we identified something for
- 2:02:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker USR, we need to have additional sort of things for planning commission and town council to look at to evaluate.
- 2:02:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One of those would be noise or character, just something
- 2:03:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we can look at in SRU and balance that potential impact to make sure that that additional density of shorten rentals is not increasing the potential
- 2:03:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for noise, for example.
- 2:03:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, but I didn't see noise anywhere else.
- 2:03:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Correct.
- 2:03:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:03:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because if you look at an
- 2:03:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker STR, we already have no's ordinances for a lot of different things so that we didn't want to recreate additional enforcement or violation sections.
- 2:03:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But we
- 2:03:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker needed to have something to look at when you look at an SRU outside of the regular districts.
- 2:03:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker L if you have anything else, I'm not finding words real well at this,
- 2:03:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so feel free to jump in because it is 830 and I'm having trouble but so you understand my question as to
- 2:03:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so you can't create noise in old town but you can't everywhere else in the town and the the section is in i'm looking at 1069 it's the additional one side
- 2:04:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker layout.
- 2:04:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's the additional standards for SRU, for NSTR.
- 2:04:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So when we looked at that, well, oh,
- 2:04:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't think
- 2:04:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this...
- 2:04:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just two of us are standards in old town.
- 2:04:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 1069 standards for residential district.
- 2:04:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 1069 correct, Mr.
- 2:04:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
- 2:04:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then I just didn't see SRU
- 2:04:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it ends.
- 2:04:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So are you asking how do these relate to our nuisance laws?
- 2:04:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In essence, yes, because it seems that these things
- 2:04:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker should apply everywhere, like having enough trash cans and things like that.
- 2:04:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just don't understand why it's only an old town.
- 2:04:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's all.
- 2:04:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think specifically what I'm seeing is
- 2:04:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the reference the potential nuances include and we call out certain right potential nuances yeah but again it's why I
- 2:05:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker may agree we need these restrictions.
- 2:05:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I lived in an area where some of the units or some of the subdivisions had limits on short-term rattles, some did not.
- 2:05:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and those that did not have had a lot of noise, a lot of trash issues and I sort of make sure we're not saying that
- 2:05:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in other neighborhoods we don't really care about trash or noise.
- 2:05:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think in this instance it is so this is for the distinction of
- 2:05:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker STRs that require an SRU.
- 2:05:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The way the page is broken up, it's not, I had to read it three times myself, just because the page break is at,
- 2:05:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but, you know, a property within
- 2:05:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 250 feet of a legally established STR and the Old Town Residential Zoning District may be allowed to be used as an STR as a special review view.
- 2:05:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then it lays, yeah, it's kind of hiding in there, unfortunately.
- 2:05:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mail
- 2:05:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Milly is that these additional conditions that we should be being planning to measure town council should inspect with additional inquiry, I think.
- 2:06:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:06:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, but my question I think is to hold.
- 2:06:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:06:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they already can't violate our existing town noise ordinances, right?
- 2:06:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So those are already on the books.
- 2:06:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:06:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, it's just, all right, there's something to think about with
- 2:06:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that.
- 2:06:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Understead.
- 2:06:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so at least in this area, you did come up with,
- 2:06:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or for all time, you can't put the distinction between the different zoning types
- 2:06:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and for more dense zoning types well at least for old town there are other restrictions and I didn't see those other restrictions for
- 2:06:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker other
- 2:06:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker zoning types where there could be more density, but it's not all down.
- 2:06:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So when we looked at existing
- 2:06:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker PDs or residential districts, for example, a lot of those are included in HOA with conditions, governance, and restrictions.
- 2:06:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we find is that a large majority of CCNRs tend to make
- 2:07:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rentals and not permitted activity within the HOA.
- 2:07:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's why you also don't see many of them outside of old town.
- 2:07:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we felt like that would be co-just for the sake of
- 2:07:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker code and we didn't want to write anything that would not be applicable.
- 2:07:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:07:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:07:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We also don't have a lot of street zoning, right?
- 2:07:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Districts.
- 2:07:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that's the other one there's a lot of murpides so yeah it would be hard to regulate that way okay um thank you and one another quick thing which is more of a nit because i don't remember
- 2:07:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the medium low density tried out to be for future land use and not correct correct so that's why it's not in the correct way yeah that's fine three for now
- 2:07:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, Commissioner Jats.
- 2:07:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So why aren't we enforcing on the 60s on established uses?
- 2:07:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's intentional that we're not or it's impossible for some legal reason i would say the answer is yes um a little bit tangent cheek in the sense that uh
- 2:08:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker enforcing is really hard, unstructured mentals,
- 2:08:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and it takes a lot of outbursts to do that and a lot of personnel.
- 2:08:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As to the why we're not enforcing that,
- 2:08:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think it's because it's not hard, because it is hard, rather.
- 2:08:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not easy to do.
- 2:08:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We haven't done it in the past ever,
- 2:08:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and I believe this whole code
- 2:08:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker writing exercise stemmed from the fact that some dance is coming and town council saw additional need for lodging and felt like this was something that should be permitted
- 2:08:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here.
- 2:08:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would just add we also in the last two years, year and a half have just added code inspection
- 2:08:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to do enforcement in planning.
- 2:08:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we have not had staff to do enforcement.
- 2:09:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:09:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Were these, I'm
- 2:09:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker looking at the ordinance.
- 2:09:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:09:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Great staff board.
- 2:09:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm looking at the ordinance.
- 2:09:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I actually share and it's more of a comment, the section with
- 2:09:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker standards for old town matter different from arrested town is a really interesting touch point,
- 2:09:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but I'm going to back up to where did we get these from?
- 2:09:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Did we use, do we crib?
- 2:09:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But,
- 2:09:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker mean, are we looking at other jurisdictions?
- 2:09:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or did we invent these at a whole clock?
- 2:09:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A little bit of everything.
- 2:09:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we looked at what folks are doing around us.
- 2:09:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have personal experiences at the planner of
- 2:09:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jurisdiction setting up these sorts of regulations as well, so pointing for my own experience, and also pointing from similar literature that's out there in terms of what are the best practices or the good practices rather for regulating short-term rental.
- 2:09:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's a mix
- 2:09:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of everything really okay so just as a super tech relying on our legal staff for you know staying within
- 2:09:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker yes, pull some of the break.
- 2:10:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But what we're allowed to do, I think, you know, originally there were some thought to,
- 2:10:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because what we heard from Council was it should be
- 2:10:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker restricted to residents and some municipalities do that, like you had to be a resident of the town to hold a permit and we learned it's not exactly
- 2:10:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker constitutional.
- 2:10:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we had to abandon that.
- 2:10:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:10:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it's just one again technical touch point on this scatter plot provision.
- 2:10:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and thank you for clarifying it as once there's this scatter plot of the established uses, then you get the 250 foot radius around all those.
- 2:10:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker who is who gets the frontier there I mean is it the ones that are currently violating or incentivizing current violations or is it a rush to
- 2:10:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker get your application in the day this happens?
- 2:10:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's something I've been thinking about the last week and it's a really good question.
- 2:11:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What I've done in the past and building these programs is you take
- 2:11:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permits for a month before it goes live?
- 2:11:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then if you notice that some folks are going to be fighting quote unquote for a permit, you do some kind of random draw to make it fair.
- 2:11:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because you
- 2:11:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't want to create a rush.
- 2:11:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You don't want to line out the door.
- 2:11:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You don't have to be will fighting.
- 2:11:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you don't make it as fair as possible.
- 2:11:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So in that event, it'd be a random draw.
- 2:11:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Almost better that way than incentivizing current violation.
- 2:11:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that is not what
- 2:11:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker established means in that provision we're not saying the people that are the 60 people in your staff reporter whatever throughout town get a special status it's the first how
- 2:11:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker many people in old town correct because some of those folks and that's ghetto put might never apply and we have to go violate them right and give them a notice and say come in and apply so
- 2:11:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it might not be those folks I hope it is all 60 but it might not be I don't know okay I'm done with three
- 2:12:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I saw something I forget where it was.
- 2:12:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was a copy
- 2:12:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of this code must be included within the STR.
- 2:12:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Was that pulled from
- 2:12:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker somewhere?
- 2:12:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because I've seen like,
- 2:12:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, here's the permit and maybe like the ordinance that said it initially, but not like the entire chapter, all eight
- 2:12:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pages somewhere within the building.
- 2:12:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some communities do that.
- 2:12:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some Jews distinguish and say, hey, just here's, if to display the rule, some just have to display the permit number,
- 2:12:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we felt like giving
- 2:12:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker folks the entire ordinance was more helpful than trying to cherry pick with to give them.
- 2:12:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, okay.
- 2:13:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And in terms of the violations and enforcements, we're just generally
- 2:13:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker saying what could be subject to and saying we can enforce it but typically it's going to be another section of the code that is where the violation fees
- 2:13:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sexual charges, if you will, would be correct.
- 2:13:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Section 141 is the
- 2:13:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker general penalty provision, 144, the general penalty provision of a code.
- 2:13:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I believe the ordinance refers back to that as the enforcement
- 2:13:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker mechanism or the process that would be used to enforce a violation of the code.
- 2:13:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that code, it establishes the general penalties,
- 2:13:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker criminal
- 2:13:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or similar criminal or civil violations and just the overall framework for the prosecutor to prosecute a good violation in court.
- 2:14:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just to confirm,
- 2:14:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we require one parking space per bedroom as part of this
- 2:14:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker correct identification and unparking space correct you know if you'll build one but you have to identify where cars are going to park correct okay what about because we just saw this in an neighborhood
- 2:14:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker mixed use which does not require any parking.
- 2:14:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're saying that the STR would require parking so it's going to make
- 2:14:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our current parking guidelines subservient to this essentially.
- 2:14:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is going to take precedent in the situation of an STR use
- 2:14:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker explicitly.
- 2:14:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not requiring parking.
- 2:14:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're just showing where they're parking.
- 2:14:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It can be on street parking,
- 2:14:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on a public street.
- 2:14:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so like in old town where there is no required parking you have your drawing and you just say they're parking here on the street anywhere over
- 2:15:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there anywhere yep forever yep okay um vice chair dragon i know more questions thank you commissioner happel
- 2:15:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I did remember almost immediately after I gave my time up.
- 2:15:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 2:15:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The 200 feet, or 250 feet limit,
- 2:15:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker about how many houses
- 2:15:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is that separating an old town?
- 2:15:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know property lines are a little weird, but yeah.
- 2:15:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I believe properties are 40-ish feet wide, give or take somewhere near or
- 2:15:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker summer wider.
- 2:15:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's about half a blocks.
- 2:15:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think blocks are what 500 feet.
- 2:15:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is it 400, 400?
- 2:15:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 400, that's what it is.
- 2:15:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 2:15:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you end up with potentially two short-term rentals on a block face,
- 2:15:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which we felt like is not so many words so dense that it's going to take over the neighborhood so that would allow folks in a radius
- 2:16:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to have reasonable use.
- 2:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would say that was a concern we heard from the old town residents.
- 2:16:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well,
- 2:16:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they do utilize them because you know the houses themselves in old town tend to be a lot smaller and they like having
- 2:16:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the ability to host family, you know, just down the street or whatever, but like they didn't want to have all of old town overrun with,
- 2:16:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, SDRs on every block and yeah, and people displaced from old towns.
- 2:16:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Part of that 250 feet is publicly accessible routes.
- 2:16:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are the alleys publicly accessible?
- 2:16:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I guess there are
- 2:16:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker alleys through the old town that connect blocks.
- 2:17:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you could leave the back of one to go to an alley and go to another, that's 250 feet, so
- 2:17:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it kind of limits the block to not just on the street but also to the next street over would that be fair my interpretation of that would be that there's never
- 2:17:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pedestrian walking space, it's just for vehicles.
- 2:17:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Perhaps the town attorney has a different definition of that, but we were looking at just, I guess, a really good question.
- 2:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We were
- 2:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker looking at just sidewalks, just paths, just places where there's an established pedestrian walking path.
- 2:17:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, and there's a similar,
- 2:17:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and I think this was, how do
- 2:17:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we pieces all together?
- 2:17:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are similar provisions in the alcohol licensing provision in state law about pedestrian path marijuana licensing.
- 2:17:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it
- 2:17:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is the pedestrian pass would be sidewalks.
- 2:18:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if there's soft, there's not a sidewalk in the alley, which I don't think
- 2:18:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we ought to have any in-old town, those would not be considered part of a direct pedestrian pass access.
- 2:18:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But we do a meadow sweet farm in Orchard Glen.
- 2:18:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They do not have
- 2:18:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sidewalks they do not have sidewalks correct that is not ultra no i know but would it
- 2:18:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're right.
- 2:18:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My mistake, yes.
- 2:18:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's easy.
- 2:18:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've been doing that.
- 2:18:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have whole time.
- 2:18:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 2:18:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You are not alone in that trust me.
- 2:18:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:18:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what I have for now.
- 2:18:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:18:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hope, Mr.
- 2:18:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Barnes.
- 2:18:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker These have been fast.
- 2:18:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Refire.
- 2:18:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They have
- 2:18:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker decide enough to David.
- 2:18:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so there's no coordination with the amount of defired department.
- 2:18:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They don't have any appetite to inspect 60-some properties.
- 2:18:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they're okay with the signing that
- 2:18:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker arrives after day bye fine um back to solid waste how was a sufficient number determined we had the discussion too um okay
- 2:19:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so if we've thought about it our goal here in like I told the public you're not going to believe me because I'm a public servant but our goal here is to be as fair as possible and to be
- 2:19:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker allowing people to allow people to do these kind of things.
- 2:19:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're not going to say, well, you've got your trash cans or fifty-five gallons.
- 2:19:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You need 60 gallons.
- 2:19:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like, we just want to look at a property and say, okay, you've got a space for two
- 2:19:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker trash cans for short-term rental.
- 2:19:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's the whole house.
- 2:19:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's acceptable for us.
- 2:19:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:19:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's reasonable.
- 2:19:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, as if scenario was a major problem.
- 2:19:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, because people's trash was everywhere.
- 2:19:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:19:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I don't want to bring that to you.
- 2:19:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the last one is about urgent response, so that means that you can't take a vacation more than an hour away.
- 2:19:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's why
- 2:19:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you would have a designated individual, right?
- 2:19:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you were on a vacation, you would want to have somebody else designating an individual on your permit with a town in case something happened.
- 2:20:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's like if you had a
- 2:20:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 10-initiative STR who was being rambunctious, need to be removed.
- 2:20:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The police are not going to remove them unless you come give them authority to do so.
- 2:20:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:20:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks.
- 2:20:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, thank you.
- 2:20:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Schatz?
- 2:20:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so question for, I think, legal counsel.
- 2:20:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There isn't any question that the town can prohibit as the code does today
- 2:20:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker short-term rentals.
- 2:20:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No, I don't believe...
- 2:20:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, I believe we could prohibit that.
- 2:20:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, because we do.
- 2:20:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because we don't have a question of why we're not enforcing and is it better to bring in regulation to deal with the current enforcement problem, right?
- 2:20:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So but there's no question
- 2:20:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we can prohibit it legally okay so again to the technicalities here under
- 2:20:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker violations and enforcement following shall constitute violation operating without a permit failing to comply with any part of this chapter which chapter means the by the way you might want to check your chapter
- 2:21:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker heading there because it says 13 but chapter 16 uh so really only referring to this part of the udc magnif all statement on application
- 2:21:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but then the catch-all is violating any town law, rule, regulation, or applicable standard, relating to the operation use occupancy or maintenance of an STR.
- 2:21:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, that confines us to chapter 13, or the property where an STR is located.
- 2:21:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm wondering about the old scenario, the party Airbnb,
- 2:21:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and let's just say noise which doesn't even reside in the UDC.
- 2:21:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does this capture that?
- 2:21:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I would interpret that in the legal mind and the rim
- 2:21:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker can correct me if I'm incorrect because obligatory I'm not a lawyer that when you say I think the wording was any violation that's related to the operation of an SDR I think that noise for
- 2:22:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker example, would be related to a operation of NSTR.
- 2:22:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And therefore, you could cite someone for a noise violation, and then that noise violation would therefore reflect upon your three strikes.
- 2:22:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But that's
- 2:22:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what we call a conclusory statement, like where is that in the S?
- 2:22:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if I'm confined to chapter 13 or 16,
- 2:22:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where's the noise thing?
- 2:22:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The only noisy revision is when you're a special use after the initial scatter plot in old town.
- 2:22:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if we legalize this all around town, we start seeing when there
- 2:22:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker manera's part from old town.
- 2:22:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Where's the noise provision in the STR regulations?
- 2:22:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or are we trying to capture that under the second clause of
- 2:22:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that provision, which says, just, I assume, operation use occupants here maintenance of the property where an SDR is located, which again,
- 2:22:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker unlike, is that
- 2:22:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker not confining us to UDC?
- 2:23:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does that capture us under general provisions of the code like the noise ordinance?
- 2:23:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We wouldn't be prohibited from the police writing a noise ordinance violation under the Erie Municipal Code section where
- 2:23:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker were that right but is that a violation of an estiya is that a violation pursuant to 10 16 12 is yeah and i think what the goal or intent was and maybe we need to look at
- 2:23:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this but was to also bring um because it's the the individual who makes the noise i think the way our noise ordinances drafted it's that the person engaging in the conduct
- 2:23:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that creates the noise, we wanted to loop in and hold the owner accountable for the two-strike policy, so to say.
- 2:23:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But as you say, noise is an
- 2:23:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker personome type of violation in Ren.
- 2:23:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So here we go.
- 2:24:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do we even capture it?
- 2:24:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:24:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to, sorry, I was worried about the same thing.
- 2:24:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think four,
- 2:24:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker eight, four, maybe covers it, which is violating any town model or regulation.
- 2:24:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, that's what we're parsing.
- 2:24:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So when you read that out, there
- 2:24:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are two clauses.
- 2:24:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The first clause is confined to those things verbs that are related to an STR or the property where an
- 2:24:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker NSGR is located so the question is, how much do we capture under that second provision?
- 2:24:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I'm not reporting to answer it, but I'm greatly concerned that we actually have no
- 2:24:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker standards in this code so that's I'm just going to say that now in somewhat of a summary comment so here's another one that I just I
- 2:24:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't get,
- 2:24:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the short-term event, the short-term event,
- 2:24:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I can get a permit during the special period of Sundance or whatever, but there didn't appear to be any
- 2:25:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker exploration.
- 2:25:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is how we multiply all of the Airbnbs in the old town.
- 2:25:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, I'm just wondering if that's an
- 2:25:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker oversight or what I'm missing.
- 2:25:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is the intent that during Sundance there is some short-term type of STR permit?
- 2:25:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, that's correct.
- 2:25:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that SCR special event permit would commence at the beginning of the period and end at the end of the period.
- 2:25:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So let's use
- 2:25:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sundance for the example if they wanted to go one week before and after, much like the city of Lewisfield does, what would happen is roughly January 11th through, I don't know, February 10th or something therein, you would have a special event
- 2:25:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker period and they would expire data special event periodents where does it say that 10 16 11 a the resolution would have to specify it
- 2:25:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because it's a special type of STR permit is a special event STR permit.
- 2:26:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because there's this
- 2:26:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker whole,
- 2:26:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker okay, I'm going to reserve for the column.
- 2:26:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 2:26:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just set a curiosity if
- 2:26:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going through this.
- 2:26:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Old town is the only location where you can't have house after house after house.
- 2:26:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of short term rentals.
- 2:26:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker GREAT.
- 2:26:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there is a potential where we could have some neighbourhoods
- 2:26:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where it is house after house after house of short-term rentals.
- 2:26:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So,
- 2:26:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker potential, yes.
- 2:26:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Given the current pattern of short-term rentals,
- 2:26:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker staff didn't feel like it was super appropriate to place a buffer on short-term rentals outside Voltown.
- 2:27:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How do we identify the current short-term rentals?
- 2:27:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a great question.
- 2:27:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we have a web scraping tool that we used roughly every other day for the course of a month, or we pull short-term rentals
- 2:27:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker from Airbnb simply because number one that's where the scraping tool worked and number two because that's our most folks if not all folks list their shorten rentals we pull those right over the day a couple of times a week and create a list
- 2:27:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and compared that list daily to see which ones dropped off which ones are added which ones are continuing to go which ones are for rent all throughout the year we can't put these list of I think it's like
- 2:27:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 64
- 2:27:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:27:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Did we find anybody who owned multiple properties that they may rent out both properties,
- 2:27:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker even if they aren't next to each other say they're on completely different streets because it looks like 10 16 6 would not
- 2:27:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permit an individual from holding more than one STR,
- 2:28:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker regardless of where those homes are in our community.
- 2:28:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We found a couple of LLCs.
- 2:28:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I believe
- 2:28:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it was that own a couple different shortenmentals.
- 2:28:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 2:28:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we are preventing an LLC from holding multiple permits.
- 2:28:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If they have one that is designated
- 2:28:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as the STR.
- 2:28:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They cannot have the other one designated as an STR.
- 2:28:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they're going to have to create a create another holding company, another LC in order to have
- 2:28:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker another short-term rental issue that's correct now what if we had a management company that was designated or I
- 2:28:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker guess now it would be the ownership and not designation.
- 2:28:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mr.
- 2:28:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Chair, can I just place something?
- 2:28:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Where is the prohibition
- 2:28:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if there's supper properties from the same 10?
- 2:28:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so 10, 16, 6.
- 2:28:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, it is limited to one.
- 2:28:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can only hold one STR permit in this town,
- 2:29:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one single bedroom, one single whatever it might be.
- 2:29:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's legal.
- 2:29:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Has it a question?
- 2:29:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's legal.
- 2:29:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll draw.
- 2:29:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yep.
- 2:29:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, easy way around that is you just created another LLC, right?
- 2:29:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, or if you own
- 2:29:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the property with your spouse, each spouse has a property where that might happen.
- 2:29:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there's no way to control for that, but we want to make sure that one individual is not buying
- 2:29:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker up 10 different properties.
- 2:29:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Realizing their loopholes to it, again, it's all the enforcement idea that it's really, really hard to enforce.
- 2:29:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:29:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any other questions?
- 2:29:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any other questions?
- 2:29:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One more place.
- 2:29:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Please, there any discussion about limiting the total number of short-term rentals across the entire town?
- 2:30:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There was early drafts of this regulation
- 2:30:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker had a calculation of, I think, one short-term rental for 100 single-family units.
- 2:30:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But at the end of the day, we thought that was number one really hard for us to track without a framework in place, a number two unnecessary,
- 2:30:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker given the number of shorter minerals we have currently.
- 2:30:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:30:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there was in a lot of app tight at the study session with Council for that.
- 2:30:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that's the important part.
- 2:30:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:30:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:30:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm just wondering, I brought it up with a study session about the small town field.
- 2:30:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think it captures it,
- 2:30:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but making sure that a whole
- 2:30:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker neighborhood doesn't turn into a shortcomment tool, but the code could be modified if that becomes a problem.
- 2:30:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:30:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's an important point to make, Commissioners, that we enact this short-term
- 2:30:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker run of regulation.
- 2:30:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They have some kind of regulation on the books that are based on good practice, as this would be.
- 2:30:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then one year after Sundance, we really get a full grass of what they look like in town, and we can adjust this necessary.
- 2:31:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we have a UDC update coming to.
- 2:31:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's a particular opportunity for us to adjust ourselves.
- 2:31:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We find that some things are not matching with the conditions on the ground.
- 2:31:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 2:31:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Shaz, I know you're going to have some more questions.
- 2:31:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So let me ask two questions.
- 2:31:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mass violators.
- 2:31:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If
- 2:31:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they keep having violation after violation, but they can get there within an hour,
- 2:31:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker does that basically just remove their potential of the violation mean they could literally every single day
- 2:31:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have a violation, but as long as they get there within an hour, it doesn't pull their permanent.
- 2:31:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Responding within the hour doesn't cure the violation necessarily.
- 2:31:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It just makes them come out and deal with it, whether
- 2:31:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's removing somebody or doing with an emergency.
- 2:31:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They may still be cited for any potential violations of the UDC, so responding doesn't release them from that.
- 2:32:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker An owner who holds a permit may avoid prosecution for a violation of this chapter that
- 2:32:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is reasonably capable of being cured by responding to the STR property either personally or through a responsible agent within one hour after receiving verbal notice of the violation taking all reasonable
- 2:32:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker steps to cure the violation.
- 2:32:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think Maize, yeah.
- 2:32:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:32:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they may be released from that.
- 2:32:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They make your it.
- 2:32:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's I think at the discretion of the town attorney of the Tom Prosecutor I should say but it doesn't necessarily see if you respond you're okay but it gives it
- 2:32:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker us a little bit of latitude and discretion and saying, okay, this was not this person's fault.
- 2:32:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We don't want to cite them because they had one bad actor in their property.
- 2:32:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They should be able to cure it if they got here in time and address it.
- 2:32:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That said, we also don't want to put a prison in code that says, if you get here, you can just be released.
- 2:32:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you've got a mass-free defender who every week has a party at their SDR, because they're not vetting their residents appropriately or tenants appropriately.
- 2:33:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There was a Commissioner Shashi, he brought enforceability, and that makes it seem like, well, we might come out there.
- 2:33:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've had
- 2:33:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some mass violators, if you will, in the past.
- 2:33:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we've had repeated offenses, if you will, violation after violation, but we haven't
- 2:33:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker done anything as edges of a symptom of us not being able to enforce it really or is that a may situation can can
- 2:33:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you receive the question?
- 2:33:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've had some situations, some very specific properties where there have been violation after violation, right?
- 2:33:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just in general, right?
- 2:33:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we haven't really had the enforceability through the municipal, should I say, the UDC code.
- 2:34:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we haven't really enforced it too much, but we have responses out there continuously.
- 2:34:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that a situation where it's because we haven't had much teeth to
- 2:34:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker enforce it or is that a situation where we may and we've just been at our discretion whether we're going to actually enforce it.
- 2:34:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
- 2:34:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker when you talk about violations of those like disorderly conduct and noise violations at the PD response to,
- 2:34:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or constant nuisance violation of, you know,
- 2:34:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker weeds you name it I'm just looking at how we've dealt with violations in the past not specific to SDRs how have we deal with those because SDRs
- 2:34:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are going to be bringing more people out with pitchforks, if you will, and certain situations.
- 2:34:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure.
- 2:34:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And is it related to historic enforcement
- 2:34:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of code issues I'll turn to like a hot kelly because you know you're longer yeah and new sense enforcement is pd so i i don't know yeah the answer to
- 2:35:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that is a very hypothetical situation, so it's very hard for me to answer.
- 2:35:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've had some weird situations.
- 2:35:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll
- 2:35:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pull from my own personal law enforcement experience prior to this career until you that a lot of it comes from discretion of an individual who responds to the call.
- 2:35:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if you have different offers of responding at different times of the day, different hours
- 2:35:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and different days, that discretion extends to multiple officers who may not realize there's an ongoing issue there.
- 2:35:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if there's a potential issue for nuisance, you'd want to follow up
- 2:35:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with the PD.
- 2:35:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And on that instance, if there's nuisances to be the short-term rental,
- 2:35:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, hopefully the PD would issue their citations.
- 2:35:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But also hopefully, and we need to work on this, and we are working on this with the PD, that there's
- 2:35:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker communication between our department and the police department, especially as it relates to short-term rentals to ensure that they're getting called out to a short-term rental at midnight.
- 2:35:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Of course, we're not going to know bodies.
- 2:35:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're not here, but we need to be able to find that out so we can follow
- 2:36:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker up and take the appropriate action against the owner.
- 2:36:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, yeah, that is a...
- 2:36:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You are the perfect person to answer in that question.
- 2:36:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not often, then I get to...
- 2:36:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Last
- 2:36:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one I have,
- 2:36:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the SRU approval criteria is different than the current SRU approval criteria.
- 2:36:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are additional matters that
- 2:36:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker can be taken into account.
- 2:36:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's correct, yes.
- 2:36:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's an additional on top of.
- 2:36:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, it does replace it.
- 2:36:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's just additional.
- 2:36:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because we need something that applied to this particular
- 2:36:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker instance of a short term mental and those aren't addressed with the existing SRU conditions.
- 2:36:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay,
- 2:36:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker how are we supposed
- 2:36:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to look at these and use these requirements?
- 2:36:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maintains the appearance and character of the surrounding neighborhood.
- 2:36:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Other circumstances of falling are
- 2:36:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker additional circumstances, do we consider owner accumdencies, size number, whether the STR is the principal unit or the ADU, like are those good things or bad things?
- 2:37:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think that's the great thing about
- 2:37:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker being a recommending body is that you can look at the code and say, how are we going to educate this?
- 2:37:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When you look at the surrounding neighborhood, it's our job as
- 2:37:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker staff to, in the applicant's job, to bring you information that satisfies those requirements.
- 2:37:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if we're looking at, for example, maintaining the single family nature of the neighborhood or the surrounding area, we would want to make sure that they're not adding
- 2:37:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker an additional door on the front or additional driveway that makes it now look like it does not align with the rest of the community.
- 2:37:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you have single family homes with one driveway with one front door, then you've got one house that's got two driveways in two front doors.
- 2:37:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker suddenly is that detracting from the single family character of the neighborhood.
- 2:37:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's for Pliny Commission beside.
- 2:37:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I feel like we might get into a little bit of an arbitrary situation around
- 2:37:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker other circumstances specifically because it's very vague it can bring up a whole lot of different things and isn't explicit and
- 2:38:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean you will get our requirements right they're they're pretty explicit as it is these are kind of you know different yeah so
- 2:38:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we want to do ensure that number one planning commission and talent council had specific metrics or items to look at to base their decision on.
- 2:38:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Number two,
- 2:38:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we also didn't want to exclude particular instances based on some inclusionary language and just putting a period and that's it.
- 2:38:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if there's a specific instance where a short-term rental has a different
- 2:38:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker potential nuisance than has listed.
- 2:38:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If it's not listed there, you might not be able to look at it because then you are being arbitrary and capricious, potentially by looking outside of the code.
- 2:38:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So in my interpretation, and I'll look again to Eliot because
- 2:38:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I am not a lawyer.
- 2:38:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If we put in others such instances, for example, or other related things, whatever the exact language is that I can't see right now,
- 2:38:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it gives us us being
- 2:38:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker planning Commissioner Town Council, the ability to weigh those particular instances against the SRU application.
- 2:39:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, and I will say, Chair, I do
- 2:39:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker understand your concern because I think with the other approval criteria, SRU or any, it's a fairly standard that you could say, yes, it meets it.
- 2:39:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think the way this was drafted, it's almost like
- 2:39:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker when I'm thinking through when we're talking through a staff, it's almost like these are intended to be what's considered as part of the character of the neighborhood,
- 2:39:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker almost as a subset of these
- 2:39:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are considerations of the character and staff you could correct me if i'm stating that wrong um but i think the the way this was structured i think you're right you you can't
- 2:39:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's difficult to make a, what are you making a finding on that?
- 2:39:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's owner-occupied or that's not owner-occupied.
- 2:39:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And how does that impact your decision?
- 2:39:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But I think the considerations here go to the
- 2:39:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker character of the neighborhood and maintaining kind of the status or character of the surrounding homes
- 2:40:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker an old town.
- 2:40:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It makes me think of generally consistent with the comprehensive plan.
- 2:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's been so many times where individuals have tried to use that as the basis for
- 2:40:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker why not but it's like well it's still generally consistent you know so i think um if we can maybe do some tightening up there yeah potentially
- 2:40:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think the LEA's point, we're looking at things that planning commission could address within there, but I don't disagree that it is nebulous for sure.
- 2:40:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we can tighten that up.
- 2:40:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mr.
- 2:40:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Schultz, anything else?
- 2:40:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Probably not other than to say I think the question is, can we really put this genie back in the
- 2:40:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker bottle if this doesn't turn out to be robust enough.
- 2:40:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I'm concerned that it's mostly procedural and very little of substance.
- 2:40:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we
- 2:40:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't have much choice on ADU.
- 2:41:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's like going to plow through every other thing.
- 2:41:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And now you can have a hotel, you know, on the other part of your property, basically,
- 2:41:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if we do this and it's a it's a bandwagon i don't want to deny people the right to you know take advantage of the need for for housing drinks on dance but
- 2:41:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm not convinced that this is the genie we want to cram back in the bottle if we let it out but that's my really question so you're
- 2:41:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you have some reservations and some things.
- 2:41:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, I'll tell you that in my HOA government neighborhood, we've looked at the declarations and there
- 2:41:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is pretty clear authority but a scenario that 30 years ago in those declarations were drafted that
- 2:41:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker anyone even thought was possible.
- 2:41:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So my concern is we really are letting the genia out of the bottle.
- 2:41:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And this, like I say, is kind of a bandwagon right now.
- 2:42:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think we would
- 2:42:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have a strong answer if this had more standards not just how you get a permit and who can get a permit and all that kind of stuff but you can't you know any
- 2:42:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker trash is a violation period to say it.
- 2:42:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And, you know, any noise permit is violation.
- 2:42:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Within the four corners of this piece of code, that
- 2:42:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to me would be a lot more comforting so I guess I'm kind of transitioning into my final speech here but you know I think we need to broaden those
- 2:42:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker violation,
- 2:42:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the definition, particularly that catch-all section four.
- 2:42:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think we need to be clear about when things expire in the calendar, your thing with exploration
- 2:42:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker doesn't make any sense to me.
- 2:42:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, some people get a, you know, two full years and some people get a year in the bank.
- 2:43:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You know, we can do it in an expedited manner.
- 2:43:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, any other
- 2:43:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker questions?
- 2:43:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I will say the one thing that I look at in this that makes absolutely no sense is that for somebody to want to do
- 2:43:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a special review use.
- 2:43:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They are going to have to pay.
- 2:43:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
- 2:43:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This scenario we have two people on the same side of the street.
- 2:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker set there within 250 feet.
- 2:43:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Both of them have been running it out in old town.
- 2:43:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One of them comes in and applies.
- 2:43:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The other one hasn't heard
- 2:43:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker about it they come in to then apply and sorry you're going to have to do the SRU so it's going to be a $200 permit plus a $500 special reviews not
- 2:43:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to mention that you're going to have to have one of planning staff that is going to have to now have this project because they're going to have to go through the full SRU
- 2:44:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker process.
- 2:44:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This body is going to have to meet.
- 2:44:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then council is going to have to meet.
- 2:44:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is not something that I could see as really beneficial
- 2:44:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for our time and councils time to deal with or your time or like there has to be a way that we can expedite that or something maybe like
- 2:44:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a liquor licensing board situation like we have the liquor licensing authority.
- 2:44:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe there's some sort of process that we could set up because I don't doubt there is
- 2:44:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a reason for the public hearing aspect of it where the other neighbors can come out and say, why they don't want to allow it.
- 2:44:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But in the same breath, we could have multiples of these
- 2:44:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker real quickly and they would have to be done real quickly and they would take up a lot of your time real quickly.
- 2:44:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just
- 2:45:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the thought on how to address this, I know we're going to be doing some trial and error.
- 2:45:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So into that point, I will say that this was a compressed timeline for us.
- 2:45:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we
- 2:45:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker had a full year to look into this, we probably have some really great frameworks we could rebuild,
- 2:45:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker much like the enforcement piece of the violation space we just had to borrow and sort of reference other
- 2:45:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker parts of the code.
- 2:45:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In a perfect world where you've got a year and a half to draft a code, you can build your own enforcement framework for this particular section because it is different.
- 2:45:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can build a specific framework for folks
- 2:45:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker who might be within a buffer.
- 2:45:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I want to agree that it's maybe an imperfect approach, but as you said, trial and error and the point is taken.
- 2:45:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I will say I have been saying for about three to four years now that we've needed a short term rental code, so I'm glad that there is something before us
- 2:45:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker finally.
- 2:45:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This has been a long time coming.
- 2:45:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, and I know you've had a lot to do with it.
- 2:46:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So thank you.
- 2:46:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks, sheet that.
- 2:46:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And thank you for our time and turnies
- 2:46:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker office.
- 2:46:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're obviously weighing in on it and obviously all of our plenty of stuff.
- 2:46:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So any other questions, comments, anything?
- 2:46:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Motions.
- 2:46:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One, please
- 2:46:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker comment real quick as Commissioner Shots pointed out on page three of the ordinance.
- 2:46:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It says chapter 13, Georgian Randolph Santa.
- 2:46:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to do stuff too.
- 2:46:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:46:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now,
- 2:46:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker when the comment is, I'm worried about things outside of Old Town.
- 2:46:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As we've talked about,
- 2:46:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm worried about noise and trash and stuff,
- 2:46:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but we've got to get something in place and as you said, we can amend it as things happen.
- 2:46:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker i'm sure there's things we haven't thought about guarantee so i'm like unique we'll pop up here yes yeah it's true so on that note how do we
- 2:47:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker suspend STRs if we need to say like we didn't think of something and like something has gone horribly wrong?
- 2:47:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How do we suspend STRs and the permits themselves do we have a way to do so i mean the way would be to because the ftr
- 2:47:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's essentially a use, it would be to amend the use to be, you know, currently we don't, they're not addressed in the code.
- 2:47:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You repeal this ordinance
- 2:47:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker essentially and get back to the status quo of them not being allowed.
- 2:47:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that creates other potential issues, but that would be throughout
- 2:47:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's a more tutorial legal use here.
- 2:47:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, we'd have to go two years then, wait for the permit to expire because they would then have the rights,
- 2:47:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker investors vested rights questions and it's a use correct yeah which may be a reason to make it a year as was recommended or suggested yeah yeah and even
- 2:48:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker then my suggestion, and it was writing a staff report, not the ordinance per se, how the code table would look, is maybe there's a category in there.
- 2:48:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We would dodge
- 2:48:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the vested right non-conforming use a little by not making it a P, but making it a license or some special foot-noted category so that we can at least unwind
- 2:48:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as needed.
- 2:48:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, it really is, I'm going to vote no.
- 2:48:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Not because I'm against the concept, but because I just think this is not providing a
- 2:48:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker whole lot to step back and if we get this established and there's a big rush and everything it's going to be it is going to be hard to put the genie back in the bottle okay so we're saying that
- 2:48:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker saying we want this for Sundance or correct.
- 2:48:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Someone knows.
- 2:48:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council, right?
- 2:48:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council staff.
- 2:48:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's the community, the residents.
- 2:49:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This has been coming up.
- 2:49:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They want it because they know the need for some hats.
- 2:49:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What about a recommendation that we do a trial run for
- 2:49:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the time period of January 1st of January 31st with this implemented.
- 2:49:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We don't allow
- 2:49:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it the entire 365 247 situation specific to Sundance.
- 2:49:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We get this
- 2:49:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker up in running instead of have that well there please there's some suggestions i don't want to take you all with me no i i'm going i'm going no i
- 2:49:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But I think the split vote is going to be the message.
- 2:49:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think there's been a lot of good suggestions that can improve this.
- 2:49:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have concerns on some of these things that we
- 2:49:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker need something and i understand where time is the issue because it's not just getting to us it's not also getting to council because then you have to go and notice everything and then you have to 10 days after it goes into a faction we have
- 2:50:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to get it to January 1st, and they have to be able to then put these up on Airbnb, VRBO, all the places that they need to legally be permitted to do this.
- 2:50:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we have a
- 2:50:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker very short window because people are already booking their their stay needs but we have a serious issue where we
- 2:50:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't know if this is right yeah and my my concern is to charge $200 for a permit for a one month period
- 2:50:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You already do that.
- 2:50:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The code says you can do a short-term rental, right?
- 2:50:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In a special event period, it doesn't have any differentiation right now for the
- 2:50:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker license for me.
- 2:50:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sorry.
- 2:50:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It doesn't have any differentiation for the permit.
- 2:50:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It says that we can have suspended rules for the period of time.
- 2:51:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No matter what, you're still paying the
- 2:51:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker same fee if we read it here.
- 2:51:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's a value that is for the permit.
- 2:51:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You pay for the permit.
- 2:51:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Doesn't matter if you use it for one month, two years.
- 2:51:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is the reminder
- 2:51:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that the permit fee is memorialized in the town's permit fee schedule resolution so the fee is not memorialized here within the code so there's serious reservation about the fee amount we can potentially have
- 2:51:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that get that feedback okay my point was if we're limiting it we're only going to give permits for one month period then i'm worried about what the fee should be
- 2:51:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll just say the fee schedule is approved by Council and Planning Commission does not weigh in on that.
- 2:51:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would not be on board with recommending
- 2:51:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a one-month trial period.
- 2:51:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think for staff, that would be just the nightmare to temporarily do all this to put in place for a month.
- 2:51:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I understand the reservations, but I would not support one like a
- 2:51:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker recommendation.
- 2:51:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I would ask Elliot, I don't think that's a possibility?
- 2:52:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, I don't think that would take.
- 2:52:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I recommend it.
- 2:52:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It has a term to it of, yeah,
- 2:52:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'd have a
- 2:52:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker conditional approval or yeah, I do like Mr.
- 2:52:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Shot's thought about maybe making it one year instead of two years at the beginning just to give us learning time for the for
- 2:52:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the permit length yes okay because as jarred subventioned if you have to stop it having away two years is a long
- 2:52:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of future.
- 2:52:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:52:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just a thought.
- 2:52:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I, again, I'll defer to Aliot and ask about the legality of giving someone a property right and then
- 2:52:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker taking said property right away yeah there are potential issues yes which is so i mean timing wise when
- 2:52:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would this go into effect, because we're all ready to say, well, your two year window is going to start in end of November beginning of December.
- 2:53:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it's calendar years, so
- 2:53:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's going to be one year and one month essentially.
- 2:53:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're already saying it's going to be about a year and we have two years in code.
- 2:53:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I guess it's a
- 2:53:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a mood point.
- 2:53:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the purpose of that section, maybe I didn't make it clear, was to relieve the burden on staff to renew 65-780 permits every year,
- 2:53:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because that can get to be a pretty heavy lifts so we can try to split it up understanding that we're going to get a rush the first year but eventually it will kind of even itself out that was the purpose for that code section
- 2:53:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 2:53:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any other questions, comments, concerns,
- 2:53:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or emotion?
- 2:53:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nobody wants to make a motion.
- 2:53:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll make a motion to approve resolution number P-26, that's 16, a resolution
- 2:53:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the Planning Commission of the Town of Erie recommending that the Town Council adopted an ordinance, amending Title 10 of the UTC to enact a new chapter 16, Entitled Chalk Tournamentals, and amending chapter 3 use
- 2:54:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker regulations in chapter eleven definitions.
- 2:54:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Second.
- 2:54:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, can we take our rope?
- 2:54:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, let's do a roll call vote.
- 2:54:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Groves.
- 2:54:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 2:54:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hempel.
- 2:54:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 2:54:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Shots.
- 2:54:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No.
- 2:54:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice-Chair Dreckman.
- 2:54:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 2:54:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Chair Sawish.
- 2:54:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
- 2:54:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Motion passes for
- 2:54:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker two one and we can't vote guess with reservations yeah yeah we can't um i know we just gave you a lot to
- 2:54:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker think about for all staff in the room because this is, we're going to be running into some challenges in a moment of guarantee and we'll just have to figure it out.
- 2:55:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And this isn't iterative processes new.
- 2:55:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I appreciate the questions and comments and the concerns and we'll continue to address things that come up and make adjustments as necessary.
- 2:55:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 2:55:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
- 2:55:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
- 2:55:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That brings us to staff reports to staff of anything to report.
- 2:55:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well,
- 2:55:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you're getting situated.
- 2:55:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would just clarify if you are going to make comment as a member of the public
- 2:55:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if you could explicitly state that so that it is very clear,
- 2:55:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know Commissioner Lee's made comment
- 2:55:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker by email and it was not explicitly clear that it was as a member of the public so if you will wish to do that
- 2:56:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the future,
- 2:56:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would caution against it.
- 2:56:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't think it is good practice.
- 2:56:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It does appear to have.
- 2:56:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
- 2:56:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker anyway.
- 2:56:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, it's not explicitly prohibited by the UTC or any policy of the town, but it does create an appearance of improper.
- 2:56:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, if you can't attend a meeting, just
- 2:56:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker don't send emails to the entire commission just refrain so especially on public hearings yeah so thanks um yeah
- 2:56:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know we're talking about that briefly, so something we should definitely have addressed in one of the orders of procedure.
- 2:56:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, we are still working on that with
- 2:56:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a town administration and they're hoping to bring all of them for all of the boards and commissions to council altogether and sort of having to peacemail everything.
- 2:56:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So as you can imagine,
- 2:56:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that's taking quite a bit of rainfalling but we will bring them back to you all for consideration as well okay other items if you haven't finished your security training please
- 2:57:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker do so.
- 2:57:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, please.
- 2:57:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because we get emails all the time.
- 2:57:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll lose access.
- 2:57:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They will.
- 2:57:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eventually, they'll pull it, and that won't be fun for anybody.
- 2:57:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you have any trouble accessing
- 2:57:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker your town email or anything, please reach out as well.
- 2:57:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let us know.
- 2:57:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It can be hard to navigate that stuff sometimes.
- 2:57:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You'll have regular jobs too.
- 2:57:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is my regular
- 2:57:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker job so please feel free to reach out if you need help with any IT stuff security training stuff access stuff we're here to help make sure you all can access those things the
- 2:57:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker other big item is the UDC update.
- 2:57:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We had interviews with the perspective consultants the last couple of days, the last week in this week,
- 2:57:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and they went well and we will hopefully
- 2:57:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have someone selected here quite soon.
- 2:57:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Didn't bring you a kickoff meeting and get the whole process started.
- 2:57:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you think tonight was fun, just wait.
- 2:57:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You have a whole UDC to do.
- 2:58:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a
- 2:58:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lot of fun.
- 2:58:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But you guys will be an integral part of making sure we move that forward.
- 2:58:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you won't be left on the cold, don't worry.
- 2:58:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that's
- 2:58:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker all I have.
- 2:58:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks to Kelly for being here tonight and helping to assist with things.
- 2:58:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And thanks to our new attorney back
- 2:58:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the corner there, Melissa.
- 2:58:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Should we join you all here at some point?
- 2:58:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm alone with Elliot to cist with land use stuff, so it's good to have her here.
- 2:58:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker She's been at the town for a while now, and she'll
- 2:58:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker be assisting elite at some point with attorney duties here for the planet commission so all right no that's all i have okay uh mr shots
- 2:58:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, alone.
- 2:58:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I need to get that security training down.
- 2:58:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was me.
- 2:58:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That was me.
- 2:58:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And my only other comment is just,
- 2:58:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker again, I'm really proud to serve with you.
- 2:58:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I do think a good board is one that can have a split vote.
- 2:59:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so, you know, great work tonight.
- 2:59:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Hampoo.
- 2:59:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Balots are out.
- 2:59:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Make sure you vote.
- 2:59:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Commissioner Rotis.
- 2:59:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nothing.
- 2:59:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Vice Chair Drecklet.
- 2:59:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nothing.
- 2:59:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There is a
- 2:59:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker town hall tomorrow night here on FlockCamers, 6pm.
- 2:59:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Next meeting, we are going to be having
- 2:59:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a joint study session with the Open Space Trails and Advisory Board.
- 2:59:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have a presentation slide deck that was sent to staff for review
- 2:59:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for that meeting.
- 2:59:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As soon as it has cleared staff review in the internal process there, we're going to send it out to
- 2:59:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this body and OS tab so that we and them can review it.
- 2:59:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's going to be a lot of information trying to get everybody up to speed because we're going to be talking about a really complex
- 3:00:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker situation in a moment.
- 3:00:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just keep in mind we will not be able to talk about the property that we just had.
- 3:00:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We will not be able to talk about any
- 3:00:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker property.
- 3:00:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We are going to look to staff specifically, Elliot, to set some ground rules.
- 3:00:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So come with your questions.
- 3:00:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're going to be diving into that
- 3:00:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker LBOD.
- 3:00:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that is all I have.
- 3:00:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And here, so I'll move to a jerk.
- 3:00:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Second.
- 3:00:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We are adjourned at 9.30pm.