ErieAI-written from the public meeting video

CivicCast BriefErie

Back to the episode

Transcript: Town Council Special Meeting

October 20, 2026

Each time links to the meeting video at that moment. Speaker names appear only where the source gives them; otherwise the speaker is shown as Unknown speaker. Open the meeting video (opens in a new tab).

  1. 0:00:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The order of the Town Council, Town Area Council Special Meeting on October 20th, 2026.
  2. 0:00:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker will you please rise and join me in the budget?
  3. 0:00:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've won the agents to the Latin of the United States of America and to the Republic
  4. 0:00:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for which it stands, Lord Nation, under God, Indonesian, would literally suggest us for all of them.
  5. 0:00:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, well the town court.
  6. 0:00:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Please take forward.
  7. 0:01:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council member Mortalaro.
  8. 0:01:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Councilmember Pessimarelli.
  9. 0:01:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Councilmember Bear.
  10. 0:01:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker President, can you hear me?
  11. 0:01:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  12. 0:01:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  13. 0:01:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mayor Pro Tembel.
  14. 0:01:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Here.
  15. 0:01:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council member O'Connor?
  16. 0:01:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council member Holbeck?
  17. 0:01:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mayor Moore.
  18. 0:01:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mayor, you have a quarrel.
  19. 0:01:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  20. 0:01:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is there a motion to approve the agenda tonight?
  21. 0:01:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Somehow,
  22. 0:01:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Second, your motion second.
  23. 0:01:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All in favor say aye.
  24. 0:01:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All of those say milk.
  25. 0:01:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have an agenda.
  26. 0:01:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker First item on the agenda is public comment.
  27. 0:01:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Give anybody
  28. 0:01:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker signed up today
  29. 0:01:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then Ronda signed up with you on start with
  30. 0:02:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Ronda.
  31. 0:02:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, signed up.
  32. 0:02:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Getting room and start with Ronda while you're looking.
  33. 0:02:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's fine.
  34. 0:02:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  35. 0:02:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, if you want to join us.
  36. 0:02:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, there's a break.
  37. 0:02:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm Ron DeGrossi.
  38. 0:02:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I'm with the we love Erie business collective.
  39. 0:02:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm here today to ask you to consider postponing the Bridge Street Alley project.
  40. 0:02:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I attended the town open house last week that provided more information about the plan and it became
  41. 0:02:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker clear that the project in its current state will not meet the needs that start of the whole idea in the first place.
  42. 0:02:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know none of you were serving as much as staff has changed as well, so let me provide some context.
  43. 0:02:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Back in 2020, ideas had moved from discussion of actual plans for downtown infrastructure projects.
  44. 0:02:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And specifically, to bury the overhead parallel lands and then pay the out.
  45. 0:02:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The town
  46. 0:02:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker paid rocks all to do the audit.
  47. 0:02:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have the audit here with me in some follow-up emails.
  48. 0:03:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there was extensive community engagement at the time, the project
  49. 0:03:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker management team met every six weeks as well as the stakeholders group meeting every six weeks.
  50. 0:03:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A lot of money was spent going through this whole process.
  51. 0:03:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker At the time of the report, 1% of the funding was available,
  52. 0:03:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which at the time was $1.35 million.
  53. 0:03:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We needed to coordinate with all the overhead utilities.
  54. 0:03:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The total alley cost was listed as $1,822,000,
  55. 0:03:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So about a half a million dollar difference.
  56. 0:03:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The bigger vision was the beauty of the allies.
  57. 0:03:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We currently have only about two blocks we work with for the restaurants and special events.
  58. 0:03:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If the Allie project moves forward in a meaningful way,
  59. 0:03:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We can have nice patios, lighting and arteemen, art displays, general improvements that connect the alley to Break Street.
  60. 0:03:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The power lines were listed as part of the plate we addressed with the Urban Manuel
  61. 0:03:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Authority for downtown and that money was supposed to help the secondary connections to all the businesses once we buried the parallel lamps.
  62. 0:03:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Engagement started in 2022 years worth of meetings and staff time
  63. 0:04:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker an RFP was issued in 22 a bond was issued.
  64. 0:04:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I followed up with economic development 2023 and reminded them that this project was still a priority for the downtown
  65. 0:04:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses.
  66. 0:04:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was emailing back that because though we're only looking at design types from Excel and all the utility coordination,
  67. 0:04:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we were looking at 2025.
  68. 0:04:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now we're heading into
  69. 0:04:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 2027, and it's not even part of the project.
  70. 0:04:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker None of the parallels so far has been coordinated.
  71. 0:04:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've reached out to the project manager.
  72. 0:04:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's reached out to this whole power
  73. 0:04:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker thing with Excel to find out if ERI has even got any project on their reader.
  74. 0:04:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I spoke with the engineer from ROCSOL, the project manager from HDR.
  75. 0:04:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know it's complicated to
  76. 0:04:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the power lines.
  77. 0:04:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're talking about a summer timeline.
  78. 0:04:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And just so you hear this directly, if this does move forward as is,
  79. 0:04:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you have a new Italian restaurant
  80. 0:04:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker opening up that will be affected by the alley.
  81. 0:04:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You have new construction going on by the post office with Scott's project,
  82. 0:05:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker closing the alley, storing the restaurant's busiest times along
  83. 0:05:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with the farmers market new construction this creates the worst possible impact with our warmer climates all of fall and even winner wouldn't be wouldn't it be better to do this
  84. 0:05:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker during late September?
  85. 0:05:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It takes about a month per anni and there's four of them.
  86. 0:05:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a very shallow dig if they have to do this.
  87. 0:05:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's time to get this on track for what really needs to happen.
  88. 0:05:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Storm drainage is not a critical at the moment.
  89. 0:05:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It'll be a total waste of taxpayers' money to go through all the easement process and closures,
  90. 0:05:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pay the alleys, and then go through it all again someday if we actually
  91. 0:05:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker get excel on board i'm i'm hoping to wait we can save this money that's already allocated go through the coordination and do it right before 20 seconds
  92. 0:05:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker please.
  93. 0:05:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have the history right here, emails.
  94. 0:05:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is the whole report that we did in 2020.
  95. 0:06:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like I said, we've spent the money doing
  96. 0:06:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it?
  97. 0:06:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So happy to share with you.
  98. 0:06:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You all have it too, I'm sure it's in your history.
  99. 0:06:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And thank you for your time.
  100. 0:06:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  101. 0:06:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  102. 0:06:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Perhaps on this one, we can look at a future meeting that will bring it
  103. 0:06:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker back before it actually starts.
  104. 0:06:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we don't have anybody else signed up, but Randa is,
  105. 0:06:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll sign up a second time, talk about,
  106. 0:06:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I lost this.
  107. 0:06:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That was for Adam's only agenda.
  108. 0:06:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can think both in the same time.
  109. 0:06:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's okay.
  110. 0:06:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You can address us.
  111. 0:06:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now, for Adam's only agenda?
  112. 0:06:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, so any of these I think
  113. 0:06:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that's okay.
  114. 0:06:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  115. 0:06:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  116. 0:06:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm still running around recording in progress.
  117. 0:06:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This time I'm just a local resident.
  118. 0:06:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm not representing that we love your business
  119. 0:06:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker collective.
  120. 0:06:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I did write about this is about the business license and I did write about this in your packet of my letter.
  121. 0:06:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was on vacation.
  122. 0:06:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was going quick.
  123. 0:06:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You guys had reached out to the business collective and I just responded fast, but I wanted to clarify my comments because I do understand the need for business license and hearing.
  124. 0:07:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that's really
  125. 0:07:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker important.
  126. 0:07:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My objection was with the $50 fee or $25 fee depending on what it was and not the license.
  127. 0:07:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's the animal fee that I had a problem with.
  128. 0:07:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know it's low hanging fruit.
  129. 0:07:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know it's just 50 bucks, but it just greets on my nerves.
  130. 0:07:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We love you.
  131. 0:07:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You responded as group to your email and the proposed changes, and I'll let that letter stand on its own.
  132. 0:07:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You were not asked specifically
  133. 0:07:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker about the annual fee, so they did not address that issue in the response.
  134. 0:07:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The proposed changes in clarity in the shift of financial penalties was supported by the business collective,
  135. 0:07:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and I support that as well.
  136. 0:07:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In addition, the fees impose on the calendar year.
  137. 0:07:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you pay this on October, you're going to pay the Geno January and I suggest you address that and make it maybe a whole
  138. 0:07:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker annual thing.
  139. 0:07:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I want you to understand how much our business is currently paid for the job.
  140. 0:07:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know if you recognize that the sales tax reporting is done by each business
  141. 0:08:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for free by all of our staffs right we do that and go through reporting process and then when the tax is collected and the credit card is swapped that credit card fee is also paid
  142. 0:08:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for by the business on behalf of the town.
  143. 0:08:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The budget says $227 sales tax expected for $45.8 million.
  144. 0:08:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 3% of that number is
  145. 0:08:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker $1,374,000 that your business is anywhere you're paying for you on your behalf to collect this money and get it to you.
  146. 0:08:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So imagine if
  147. 0:08:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker each of the businesses came back to the town to be reimbursed for that amount of money.
  148. 0:08:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Also, not sure you recognize, but property businesses that are properties paid more
  149. 0:08:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker than four times the amount that a residential property pays more than four times so businesses are already doing more than their fair share not counting the fact that we support
  150. 0:08:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker everything in Europe from special events to high school and cheerleaders and bans and art projects and whatever else you come up with.
  151. 0:09:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The presentation will say
  152. 0:09:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that it costs $45,000 a year to maintain the business database.
  153. 0:09:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's only $425 businesses, guys.
  154. 0:09:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The town has created this database four times that I remember when I approached
  155. 0:09:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker staff about it on the third time, they've never heard of it didn't know what happened to it.
  156. 0:09:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're not being efficient on how we do this.
  157. 0:09:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the 20 grad we collect, I think, could be taken off that $45,000
  158. 0:09:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we do just fine.
  159. 0:09:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know we can get more efficient in keeping this database.
  160. 0:09:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As I said in my letter, the town's goal was to increase business account.
  161. 0:09:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's get some traction around that
  162. 0:09:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker idea.
  163. 0:09:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Have some vision about why Europe is better.
  164. 0:09:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Consider making planning and building an easier and more efficient and even friendly process.
  165. 0:09:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How about giving staff an economic development the
  166. 0:09:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker charge that businesses are important and we are your customers and should be treated as valued people in the community make that a focus in the coming years please imagine how far it could go
  167. 0:10:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to get businesses talking positively about being in the area and what the town is doing to help bring more here.
  168. 0:10:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you very much.
  169. 0:10:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  170. 0:10:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  171. 0:10:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Anybody else in the audience if I want to address this?
  172. 0:10:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  173. 0:10:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then we will move on to our first item tonight.
  174. 0:10:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a resolution of the town council appointing
  175. 0:10:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Kelly Johnson as the town manager as of January 4th, 2027 and approving the associated employment agreement.
  176. 0:10:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll turn it over to our acting town
  177. 0:10:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker manager.
  178. 0:10:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You have before you a contract with Kelly Johnson following a national search and what I will call a rigorous two days the final has had to spend
  179. 0:10:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here in town with staff and residents.
  180. 0:10:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council asked staff to negotiate a agreement with Ms.
  181. 0:10:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Johnson.
  182. 0:10:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker She come to us from the city of Greeley, which is her indefinity
  183. 0:11:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker City Manager,
  184. 0:11:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and is now in New York Court.
  185. 0:11:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, sounds good.
  186. 0:11:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think I'll just start to my right if Council Member Hoback has any comments questions,
  187. 0:11:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so we're just going to work our way around this way nothing deep you okay yeah so same i looked it over on questions okay yeah i'm good with contractor right through
  188. 0:11:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it.
  189. 0:11:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  190. 0:11:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just a few brief words.
  191. 0:11:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker First off,
  192. 0:11:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I want to thank
  193. 0:11:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Heather or consultant for all the work through this process.
  194. 0:11:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I want to thank Maratha and Brianna for their work and negotiations.
  195. 0:11:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I want to thank
  196. 0:11:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Councillor Bear for Shane.
  197. 0:11:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've represented the kind of council representation on our group.
  198. 0:11:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Also,
  199. 0:11:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Alicia Melinda's RHREP and Melissa Wiley, our WWE town manager, were involved in this process.
  200. 0:12:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like it took forever and but I'm very happy to report this to the public and have this before us and very excited
  201. 0:12:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for what Kelly's going to bring coming the future.
  202. 0:12:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you to all the applicants.
  203. 0:12:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was very tough decision, I don't know, for all of us, but I'm glad to be here.
  204. 0:12:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And let's get ready for the next episode.
  205. 0:12:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  206. 0:12:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sounds good.
  207. 0:12:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I appreciate you pointing out everybody that was going to thank you and
  208. 0:12:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Member Bear because behind the scenes you represented us as council to narrow the field with staff and to bring back the three candidates and I think there were three great
  209. 0:12:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker candidates and I know we can't discuss everything discussed in the exact session in making this decision, but I'm happy and I know all of you are headlanded in a good place to bring
  210. 0:13:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Kelly in.
  211. 0:13:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So with that, I'll see you later from Kelsey Memorandum.
  212. 0:13:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, Kelsey Memorandum.
  213. 0:13:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, Kelsey Memorandum.
  214. 0:13:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, Kelsey Memorandum.
  215. 0:13:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So thank you.
  216. 0:13:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, I want to echo some of what Memorandum
  217. 0:13:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Bell said.
  218. 0:13:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you to the whole team.
  219. 0:13:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was an actually very smooth and enjoyable process and I hope that applicants felt that way as well going through the interview process.
  220. 0:13:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think our consultant really helped lead us through some really great questions and get to know candidates and just it was it was enlightening for me
  221. 0:13:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and so wonderful to learn about the different leadership styles and picking someone who I feel like is going to help take us into the future for Erie while
  222. 0:13:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker also appreciating our historic past and that was certainly something that was really important as we were going through the process.
  223. 0:13:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So thank you Meredith
  224. 0:13:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and Melissa, Brina, Andalisha, and Brandon.
  225. 0:13:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was a really enjoyable process and I'm very excited to prove this tonight.
  226. 0:14:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, with that,
  227. 0:14:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll see if there's a motion to approve Resolution No.
  228. 0:14:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 26-215.
  229. 0:14:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'll move.
  230. 0:14:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, give a motion second.
  231. 0:14:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any further discussion?
  232. 0:14:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hell in favor?
  233. 0:14:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Say I.
  234. 0:14:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hi.
  235. 0:14:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hi.
  236. 0:14:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All I'm going to say now.
  237. 0:14:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  238. 0:14:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have a contract and a Kelly Wolves start with us right after the first year.
  239. 0:14:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, we will go on to their second agenda item tonight, which is a study item.
  240. 0:14:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's an update
  241. 0:14:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on the impact study that has been going on and
  242. 0:14:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Alright, sorry, four years.
  243. 0:14:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sarah, see, I'm just a finite sector.
  244. 0:14:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm here at the point.
  245. 0:15:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There
  246. 0:15:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are consulting person who's working with a satishric ice to give us lots of information and kind of unravel our entire study.
  247. 0:15:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to preface this as we're
  248. 0:15:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker about to get kind of a beefy presentation with a lot of information but this is a very preliminary look at this these numbers are definitely not final there's
  249. 0:15:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a lot of continued staff development work with stakeholders and feedback we need from the council to kind of get to a final place.
  250. 0:15:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm just going to say take this all with a proverbial
  251. 0:15:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker grade of salt as we kind of work through it.
  252. 0:15:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to be typing through this so that I can capture questions that you ask in areas for clarification.
  253. 0:15:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just be aware of that.
  254. 0:15:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what I'm going to be doing while
  255. 0:15:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Karlson takes the wheel here.
  256. 0:15:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm going to see where our presentation is living right now.
  257. 0:15:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  258. 0:15:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Karlson, I'm going to hand it over
  259. 0:15:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to you.
  260. 0:15:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, you are absolutely welcome to do that.
  261. 0:16:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let me pick that button and you are.
  262. 0:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  263. 0:16:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Good evening, Mayor, members of council.
  264. 0:16:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just
  265. 0:16:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like to echo what Sarah said means numbers are very very preliminary staff is still reviewing the numbers one of the big things that will
  266. 0:16:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker be working on over the next few weeks is particularly to release the transportation is to what extent are there other revenues available that would then reduce the fees in other words
  267. 0:16:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker give credit as part of the methodology so again very very pulmonary i don't want anybody to i don't even know what the final number is off the top of my head but i don't want anybody to leave this number for this meeting
  268. 0:16:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and thinking that the town of Buri is proposing a fee of x and not a dollar because we are not there yet.
  269. 0:16:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the other thing, we do not have a draft yet of the stormwater fee at its
  270. 0:16:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker forthcoming oh yeah no it's it's a little chemical yeah yeah yeah that's exactly up in the situation because i have learned the story in the hard way
  271. 0:17:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So in terms of what we're going to go over today is the growth projection to the land use assumptions, so what we call it, we'll talk about the draft parks feed, the draft public facility feed, the
  272. 0:17:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker draft police fee, the draft transportation fee.
  273. 0:17:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, as I said,
  274. 0:17:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the scroll monitor fee is still a development right now, and we will have that for you shortly.
  275. 0:17:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the
  276. 0:17:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker base-year estimates and projections are founded on several sources.
  277. 0:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One of them includes the US Census Bureau, American Community Survey data, as well as the Dr.
  278. 0:17:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg growth
  279. 0:17:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rates, and so the residential projections are based on a 2.2% annual household growth rate, and the non-residential projections are based on a 1.4% annual employment growth
  280. 0:17:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rate.
  281. 0:17:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so if you look at the slide here, we are projecting over the next 10 years an increase in about 10,600 additional residents in
  282. 0:17:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker terms of housing units that acquainted about 3800 additional housing units.
  283. 0:18:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now in terms of the non-residential growth from a job or employment perspective
  284. 0:18:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that's about 770 new jobs and that equates to about 367,000 square feet of additional non-residential activity with the majority of that being
  285. 0:18:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the office and institutional categories.
  286. 0:18:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So for all of the fees, except one, we're, well, I can take that back.
  287. 0:18:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All the
  288. 0:18:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fees that we're going to show you are using an incremental expansion methodology.
  289. 0:18:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We do have one option that views from that.
  290. 0:18:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It does a plan-based approach, I believe.
  291. 0:18:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So to say criminal expansion approach, as we talked about at our last meeting is by far the most common method for looking at impact fees.
  292. 0:18:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you remember, we talked about, we can look to the past,
  293. 0:18:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the present, the future, the past is when we've oversized facilities, the future is when we haven't adopted master plan,
  294. 0:18:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker brought with that,
  295. 0:19:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or they weren't going to worry about with that.
  296. 0:19:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The most
  297. 0:19:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker master plans are enhancing or improving levels of service.
  298. 0:19:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And as we discussed at our last meeting, we can't use impact phase to correct existing deficiencies, right?
  299. 0:19:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So by far the most popular method
  300. 0:19:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is this incremental expansion approach.
  301. 0:19:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The math is quite simple.
  302. 0:19:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're looking at the cost factors and then we look at the demand factors and by demand factors we mean,
  303. 0:19:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for instance for parks which is attributable to residential development how many people do we have perhaps in you from transportation perspective whether we're using trips our
  304. 0:19:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker vehicle trips person trips vehicle mouse travel those are examples of demand units if we were talking about schools we'd be talking about public school student generation by a type of housing
  305. 0:19:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we get those demand factors and then we look at what does it cost to replicate this infrastructure system in terms of where does it cost us to develop an acre parkland, whereas it costs us per lay mile to
  306. 0:19:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker build new streets, and that's how we come up with that maximum supportable fee.
  307. 0:20:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now, in terms of the park impact, the analysis, we do use that incremental
  308. 0:20:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker expansion approach.
  309. 0:20:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The current level service is based on your existing development part, your inventory.
  310. 0:20:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Land is not included, and if you remember from the last impact we study
  311. 0:20:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in our previous discussion two months ago, you have a park dedication formula from which the town derives its land.
  312. 0:20:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The impact fee is then used to
  313. 0:20:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker develop that land.
  314. 0:20:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As I mentioned earlier,
  315. 0:20:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it is assessed only on a non-resident, or specific residential land uses.
  316. 0:20:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is how
  317. 0:20:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we define our levels of service.
  318. 0:20:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've got community parks.
  319. 0:20:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've got neighborhood parks.
  320. 0:20:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we compare that to your existing population base to get these different levels of service in terms of
  321. 0:20:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker developed anchor is $3,000.
  322. 0:20:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we look at what does it cost us to develop ERI parks on a paracro basis
  323. 0:21:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and that includes a development cost peracar, which is the grading, the installation of utilities, paving of roads, et cetera, and then also water rights.
  324. 0:21:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so the previous calculated cost of water rights per acre foot is 15,300.
  325. 0:21:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then we look at the
  326. 0:21:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker acre feed of water per acre of seated area and cost of water rights has been inflated at rate of 3% annually since the last impact we study.
  327. 0:21:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so that's how we get these development
  328. 0:21:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker costs per person for community parks and neighborhood parks.
  329. 0:21:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then in order to sort of quantify this in terms of what does this mean
  330. 0:21:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in terms of what is growth going to demand, we apply these levels of service standards to the development projections we showed you in a previous slide.
  331. 0:21:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're projecting
  332. 0:21:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker demand from new growth over the next 10 years is about 21 million in development cost and the amount of developed acres
  333. 0:22:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would increase to about 9.98 candid parks in 1372
  334. 0:22:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker memorate parks, bankers.
  335. 0:22:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so this shows the draft maximum supportable development fees.
  336. 0:22:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at these infrastructure costs per person.
  337. 0:22:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll apply
  338. 0:22:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that by the person per housing unifactor and so we get a proposed fee of $50, $740 for a single family unit, $3408 for a multi-family unit.
  339. 0:22:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker These are substantially
  340. 0:22:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker increases over the current impact fee but again we are still vetting this internally with staff and we're also evaluating other revenues that may be available
  341. 0:22:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to offset these development costs.
  342. 0:22:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Revenue from grants, sales tax,
  343. 0:23:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker other funds,
  344. 0:23:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Exactly.
  345. 0:23:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cops, bullets.
  346. 0:23:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For instance, we already know that the Recreation Center, which is why you don't see that as part of this fee study, is we know that that's going to be part of a
  347. 0:23:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker referendum for bond issues and so you've identified a funding source for that right to that with i guess it's to to clear up deficiencies right part of
  348. 0:23:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it or part of it is yeah part of it is forward looking and you can't reclaim the forward looking well you can but but here's the caveat remember this from
  349. 0:23:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our meeting two months ago is we new development can't pay twice so if i've paid you a development fee but i'm also generating sales tax that's going to retire damp for the
  350. 0:23:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker same thing I paid the other.
  351. 0:23:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Impact before.
  352. 0:23:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It has a tendency to really reduce the fee where it begs the question, is the juice worth the squeeze if we're going to have to credit this much money
  353. 0:24:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to the rest of you.
  354. 0:24:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, right.
  355. 0:24:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at the projected revenue from when we compare the impact fees to the growth projections
  356. 0:24:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we showed you.
  357. 0:24:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When we use this consumption-based approach unless there's a credit,
  358. 0:24:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the revenue approximates the projected expenditures and that's the case here where
  359. 0:24:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're due to routing there's you know a $1500 difference there but that's fairly standard with a consumption based or an environmental expansion approach that revenues equal expenditures now
  360. 0:24:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker caveat is the town may choose to develop more acres.
  361. 0:24:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's just that impact fees wouldn't cover that.
  362. 0:24:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is a choice that you
  363. 0:24:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have made, a value proposition of we are going to elevate our levels of service.
  364. 0:24:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  365. 0:24:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I'm going to skip this because we have a summary in the back that
  366. 0:24:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker showed that they're very really interested in the urban assume is interested and what does it mean for the total full-fraid on a single family house so in terms of public facilities these
  367. 0:25:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fees also use that consumption-based approach, current level service based on your inventory,
  368. 0:25:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where collectively four facilities were footage, and it's assessed on both non-residential and
  369. 0:25:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker residential land uses.
  370. 0:25:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So how we determine residential versus non-residential demand is we use a measurement called functional population, which is a
  371. 0:25:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker measurement where we take a snapshot of what your current population today how many folks both live and work in Erie how many folks are leaving her Erie during
  372. 0:25:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the day to work elsewhere and then how many people are coming into eerie to work during the day so that's what we mean by functional population and so as you can see here we have an 88 to
  373. 0:25:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 12% split.
  374. 0:25:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's fairly, that's consistent with what I see in communities with the sort of the demographic makeup of ERI.
  375. 0:25:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's fairly common.
  376. 0:26:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
  377. 0:26:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so we look at your current level service in terms of the town hall and the leon rural service center.
  378. 0:26:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And you compare that to your existing demand base in terms of population jobs to get our levels
  379. 0:26:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of service factors and then we use a cost per square foot of $556.
  380. 0:26:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So similar to what I showed you with parks, we then compare those level of service standards and cost
  381. 0:26:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker factors to that growth projection and right now we are projecting an increase of let's see here about 22
  382. 0:26:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker square feet of additional square footage and that has a cost of $12.6 million and
  383. 0:26:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker does that include police facilities it does not totally separate totally separate yeah yeah and that's the one we have the option on okay okay
  384. 0:26:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the draft fees are 3165 for single family, which is actually a decrease over your current bee, 1879 for
  385. 0:27:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker multi-family, and then as we go through the non-residential fees, office institutional has the highest fee because it has the most employees per thousand square feet followed by commercial
  386. 0:27:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and industrial.
  387. 0:27:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then when we look at the projected revenue,
  388. 0:27:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the very similar situation exists here.
  389. 0:27:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We didn't add reparks where revenue approximates expenditures.
  390. 0:27:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's about $2.6 million.
  391. 0:27:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's $2.6 million and expenditures.
  392. 0:27:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll skip this as well.
  393. 0:27:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now, the
  394. 0:27:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker police fee, we're going to show you two options here.
  395. 0:27:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What is the consumption of base during the Middle Expansion approach, which assumes that we take your current level of service and you're going to build additional police
  396. 0:27:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker space which my assumption is that's not likely because you're going you're in the middle of expanding the facility right now which will open in a year or two so
  397. 0:28:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the real question that we have to deal with from a policy perspective is, is once this improvement is made, are we going to build additional or do we anticipate
  398. 0:28:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a building additional police space over the next 10 years or do we think that this is sufficient to get us through the next 10 years so we do a plan-based approach so I'm going to show you two options
  399. 0:28:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here and we're skipping costs recovery on a plan base.
  400. 0:28:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I say it's a plan base because it's in construction right now.
  401. 0:28:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But basically you would
  402. 0:28:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker cover new roads fair share that payment to order if you're dead assessed on the residential or non-residential and as i mentioned accounts for your facility expansion set to open next
  403. 0:28:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker year.
  404. 0:28:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if we go with the option one with which is this incremental expansion approach,
  405. 0:28:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker basically as I said earlier, this assumes that you,
  406. 0:28:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker when this opens in 2027, you would also open additional space between 20 to 27 and 2036.
  407. 0:29:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So here's our level of service standards.
  408. 0:29:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Superior, yes.
  409. 0:29:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Inquisition.
  410. 0:29:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well,
  411. 0:29:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so if I remember correctly the police facility that we're expanding now is supposed to handle a population up to 65,000.
  412. 0:29:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that might help the answer.
  413. 0:29:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What's option to go with?
  414. 0:29:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  415. 0:29:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You've summoned the chief.
  416. 0:29:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  417. 0:29:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So yeah, that's correct.
  418. 0:29:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, we can put up to probably a little bit over 100 officers in that domain.
  419. 0:29:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So only consideration you want to take into account is what our growth looks like,
  420. 0:29:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because it's not just the number of officers but where you can put them and so as we grow our geography is so large we will have to consider substations at some point but hope
  421. 0:29:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker hoping that's not in 20 or 2037.
  422. 0:29:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think this building should get us 10 years pretty easy.
  423. 0:30:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, so I was thinking satellites with
  424. 0:30:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the error substantial right the next.
  425. 0:30:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, as we developed more towards 52925, we'll have to look at the possibility on the substation of something that makes sense.
  426. 0:30:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just doing the math, right?
  427. 0:30:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We some of us struggled with funding the police station because not enough money had been accrued.
  428. 0:30:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we did COPs which then
  429. 0:30:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker come out of the general fund for sales tax property tax.
  430. 0:30:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're all paying for that.
  431. 0:30:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That'll take us to 60,000 people.
  432. 0:30:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So when argument
  433. 0:30:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker could be, hey, we already got to figure it out so we shouldn't charge the new residence from 42,000 to 60,000 anything.
  434. 0:30:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You followed me so far.
  435. 0:30:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But is
  436. 0:30:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that fair because we put the burden on the people that were here to fund the people that are not yet here to fund the expansion of the people that aren't here?
  437. 0:30:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
  438. 0:30:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so is there a way to account for that legally it's a good question so that's that's that's a most of that is a question for you all to answer because
  439. 0:31:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker always comes back to because i mean there's there's an argument to be made that what do you need impact fees you've found a funding source and that's
  440. 0:31:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the bot or the cops that's right right but it's also legal for you to ask new development to pay their fair share by into that right
  441. 0:31:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so that's that's a policy decision so we can put that in there and at least for my lens i would want that to happen because every dollar that we pull
  442. 0:31:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker out of the system through taxes is it dollar that's not even spent at the burnhouse or like looseels or you know you name it right it is going to
  443. 0:31:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a in this case police facility and so it seems to me that we should recoup every dollar that we can for those that are going to be moving
  444. 0:32:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here.
  445. 0:32:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know.
  446. 0:32:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe I'm thinking about it wrong.
  447. 0:32:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what I understand.
  448. 0:32:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's option two.
  449. 0:32:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's option two.
  450. 0:32:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  451. 0:32:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just got that.
  452. 0:32:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
  453. 0:32:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
  454. 0:32:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And my assumption was...
  455. 0:32:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was just
  456. 0:32:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ahead of me.
  457. 0:32:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My assumption was you would not opt to go with this consumption-based approach, but we wanted to show it to you anyway.
  458. 0:32:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  459. 0:32:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And what that means is
  460. 0:32:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that in addition to opening this new space in 2027, you would have enough money to build an additional basically 11,000
  461. 0:32:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker square feet on top of that as substations or add-ons to an existing facility but to the cheese point are you going to need that over the next 10 years and is
  462. 0:32:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that something that we revisit in the future?
  463. 0:32:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do you have to constrain it to the next 10 years?
  464. 0:32:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You don't have to, but you
  465. 0:33:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would be updating the fees prior to the 10 years we we would show like for instance if you were saying we were going to build a new police facility in 2030 and we were going to bond
  466. 0:33:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker financing etc etc we probably show a 20-year window to give you an idea of how much you're going to recoup right yeah so it's misleading because it's like we're up dealing with this in another
  467. 0:33:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker client right now where they can't wrap their head around over the next 10 years.
  468. 0:33:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're only going to get 6 million out of 25 million.
  469. 0:33:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You got to keep telling them, well, once you build it, it's
  470. 0:33:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker going to switch to a cost recovery and then people are going to buy into it, right?
  471. 0:33:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And you're going to recoup like 16 million of the 25 million.
  472. 0:33:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, it's just the burden is put on everybody here
  473. 0:33:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker until you get to that point.
  474. 0:33:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then I also think ahead, I don't know if this stole the plans, Luke's not here, right?
  475. 0:33:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think when there was some cafe commands and quarks, okay,
  476. 0:33:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 100%.
  477. 0:33:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're going to have to get really high here.
  478. 0:34:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think there was some discussion on do you build a substation into the second wreck
  479. 0:34:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker facility and so whenever the design or at least the the components of that are in play and so it would be nice to figure that out and then have enough money to
  480. 0:34:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker offset the police facility inside that.
  481. 0:34:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Am I getting that right or am I?
  482. 0:34:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't actually know about the police facility link to the record.
  483. 0:34:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so.
  484. 0:34:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do you wear this okay making definitely have to follow up with them but do you understand what i'm coming from i'm trying to protect things here pain for that future growth
  485. 0:34:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the future growth and some not paying yet because that's you know people get upset about that well i mean i've just added yeah we we see that all over the country where
  486. 0:34:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, as technology has evolved, the police car is the office.
  487. 0:34:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so it's worse about presence.
  488. 0:35:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we see it a lot
  489. 0:35:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of mixed use projects that space is donated where it's basically a shop or a storefront that one or two officers can live in so to speak and people can come in and ask
  490. 0:35:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker questions or it's co-located with fire stations or it's co-lake located with a like where I live in the government county maryland we've got a north county annex where you select a
  491. 0:35:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one-stop shop, and you can see everybody, right?
  492. 0:35:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's all sorts of animated solutions being considered.
  493. 0:35:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if we also have to give a credit,
  494. 0:35:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as I mentioned earlier, as well as two months ago, if we have the dedicated revenue source, like a sales tax or property tax, or we've got existing bonds or we're going to be
  495. 0:35:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker issuing future bonds with the guard against paying once to the impact fee and again through a future street revenue.
  496. 0:35:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we have included a credit here.
  497. 0:35:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so
  498. 0:35:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the draft fees under this option one would be $1572, which is an increase over your current fee.
  499. 0:36:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Multi-family B933, commercial would have the highest
  500. 0:36:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker be at 1789% square feet followed by office and industrial.
  501. 0:36:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All of these are increases over your current fees.
  502. 0:36:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And your
  503. 0:36:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker revenue, because of the credit, it would not equal the expenditures, right?
  504. 0:36:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you're going to generate 6.1 million in revenue against 10.6 million and expenditures so
  505. 0:36:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that that general funds share that 4.5 million is from your certificate of participation right then let's get back
  506. 0:36:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So option two,
  507. 0:36:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker your current police facilities are the police course building is 17,000 square feet.
  508. 0:36:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
  509. 0:36:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you're currently building a 32,000 square foot expansion that will serve development for the next 20 years.
  510. 0:36:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's not surprising that you don't have the impact
  511. 0:37:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the revenue in place now to pay for a large percentage of that because this represents a huge increase in your level of service right so this second option is probably the more realistic
  512. 0:37:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one, it's cost recovery, and it's based on a future level of service set to the year 246, which we typically do this to sort of peg
  513. 0:37:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it to the last year of the bond payment, right?
  514. 0:37:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So under this scenario,
  515. 0:37:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we look at from a residential perspective, it's the
  516. 0:37:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker coster allocated to population.
  517. 0:37:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For a non-residential perspective, it's allocated to vehicle trips instead of employment.
  518. 0:37:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the reason for that is if we allocated
  519. 0:37:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker public safety costs, whether it's police or fire DMS to jobs, office would have the highest fee because they have the most employee's per thousand.
  520. 0:37:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but police calls are based on the presence of people the majority of fire and EMS calls are EMS and that's based on the presence of people and trip rates model that because the trip
  521. 0:38:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rates include the people associated with employment, but it also has the people associated with the attraction, the people who either live in the area or come into the shopping center are folks who live in
  522. 0:38:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Louisville who are coming to Erie to trip rates or much more accurate demand indicator for police services.
  523. 0:38:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that was way too
  524. 0:38:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker much tactical form for you guys.
  525. 0:38:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sure in the same credit is applied here and here that fee is similar slightly less it's 1354 dollars per person
  526. 0:38:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker excuse me, $13.54 per single family unit, $804 for a multi-family unit, from a commercial perspective, it's $2,68 per
  527. 0:38:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker thousand square feet for retail,
  528. 0:38:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker office institutional, $674 per thousand industrial, $367.
  529. 0:38:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All of these are increases over your current fees.
  530. 0:39:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then under this situation,
  531. 0:39:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or this option, new growth will cover 5.3 million of the 11.5 million in principle
  532. 0:39:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker payments over the next 10 years.
  533. 0:39:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And similar to the example I gave you from another client, the town would continue to recover growth-related principle payments over years 11 through 20 that are
  534. 0:39:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here okay does it stop at your 20 because the bond is data 20 then we'd have to repass another feat at that point now you're just you've already got you've already passed that bond so if you've got the
  535. 0:39:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker revenue yeah this has basically found money yes for the existing facility but if we need another right at that point now maybe it's your
  536. 0:39:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 15 that the police chief says yeah we need a substation yeah right and you could always switch up the methodology yeah yeah we'll skip that till the end so
  537. 0:39:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker transportation is by far the most complicated one.
  538. 0:40:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're using this consumption-based approach.
  539. 0:40:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's based on your current level of service for materials,
  540. 0:40:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker multimodal type of infrastructure as
  541. 0:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker well.
  542. 0:40:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's assessed about residential non-residential uses because of the multimodal nature of the improvements.
  543. 0:40:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We think that person trips as the best
  544. 0:40:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker indicator of demand versus vehicle models of travel or average daily vehicle trips because you're moving to a system where you're moving people not only vehicles
  545. 0:40:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and includes roadways transit stocks and on street and off street paths and keeping with methodology we employ the previous
  546. 0:40:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker go-round is that we do, or we are recommending this, we call it trip exchange district in the town center and old town areas where the
  547. 0:40:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker argument is because of the density mix of use and the connectivity that there's a higher incidence of what we call eternal trip capture so it reduces your average
  548. 0:41:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker daily vehicle triparates and so and which then cycles down to the person trips because once you're there you can do two or three things versus having to drive or walk to another area
  549. 0:41:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so it's a way to incentivize that type of piratency development that you're looking for.
  550. 0:41:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In Carson, I'm going to jump in here, but here just because I know it's going to topic of conversation with the budget,
  551. 0:41:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This transportation is the impact fund fee.
  552. 0:41:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is the development fee.
  553. 0:41:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is not the fee that we were talking about.
  554. 0:41:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They wouldn't impact residential folks in terms of like what we were talking about on utility.
  555. 0:41:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker bill.
  556. 0:41:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just want to clarify the business.
  557. 0:41:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, that's not good.
  558. 0:41:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is for a new person.
  559. 0:41:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So yeah, I know.
  560. 0:41:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I said transformation made this guy.
  561. 0:41:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was like, oh, that might be a little confusing.
  562. 0:41:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So these are too sub-reg.
  563. 0:41:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah,
  564. 0:41:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker again on that.
  565. 0:41:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, you'll see him again on that.
  566. 0:41:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're like, I'm going to choose that.
  567. 0:41:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just want to make sure we were on the same page.
  568. 0:41:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm going to go away to the weeds here.
  569. 0:41:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So one of the things that we
  570. 0:41:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker look at is part of this is trip adjustment factors.
  571. 0:42:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that has to do with, you know, we look, it's a national household triple survey in terms of the number of people per trip.
  572. 0:42:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at things
  573. 0:42:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like to it from work and shopping personal errands social recreation etc we also another factor involved in this calculation is an adjustment for
  574. 0:42:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker triple lengths.
  575. 0:42:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So rather than use national averages, we calibrate our aggregate demand model specific to the ERI road network.
  576. 0:42:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But
  577. 0:42:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker regardless of that,
  578. 0:42:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one of the things, excuse me,
  579. 0:42:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's very complicated.
  580. 0:42:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at, so in simple terms, we look
  581. 0:42:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at, like, what is your vehicle mile of capacity versus the actual vehicle miles of travel to get a ratio?
  582. 0:42:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we can use that
  583. 0:42:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ratio where if the average tripling this is say 12 miles we can then calibrate that to Erie and but should I don't know what it is I'll tell my habit it may be seven miles right but another jurisdiction may be greater
  584. 0:43:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker than the 12 last.
  585. 0:43:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then we do a further reduction, our further calculation where on average residential triple links are greater than the average,
  586. 0:43:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the most recent surveys are 19%
  587. 0:43:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker greater than the average whereas the non-residential triparates are lower than the average so we tend to weight it that
  588. 0:43:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker way, but we can also show you an option where all trips will weight it equally.
  589. 0:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, so there's a lot of factors that go into this.
  590. 0:43:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Then we look at,
  591. 0:43:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and then there's the trip adjustment rate.
  592. 0:43:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So every trip, you have an outgoing trip and a return trip.
  593. 0:43:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so the trip rate adjustment rate and then doing a
  594. 0:43:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker simple 50-50 split for the single family and multi-family is when we look at your in-commuting and out-commuting to get a more appropriate trip adjustment rate.
  595. 0:43:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this takes into, like I said,
  596. 0:44:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker community matters.
  597. 0:44:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Also,
  598. 0:44:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for retail trips, if I work for the town of Erie, and I'm leaving the office to go home, but I stop to get gas,
  599. 0:44:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for I stopped to be the store to get milk.
  600. 0:44:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's not my primary destination.
  601. 0:44:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the retail related trips are reduced further because they're not primary trips.
  602. 0:44:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's what these
  603. 0:44:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker trip adjustment factors mean.
  604. 0:44:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we then convert that into the eco-miles travel.
  605. 0:44:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at vehicle trips times average tripling, times tripling
  606. 0:44:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the adjustment and then for person miles of travel we look at vehicle miles of travel times the occupancy rate times the modeshares and the modeshares are specific to
  607. 0:44:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ERI from your transportation mobility plan.
  608. 0:44:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, we're trying to get as tight a nexus as we can or as tight a proportionality as we can.
  609. 0:44:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we are modeled and projects for some miles travel in the next 10 years,
  610. 0:45:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which is an increase of 39,601% trips, which is a
  611. 0:45:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 23% increase from today and then our analysis looks at the roadways and transportation stops current
  612. 0:45:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker level service and 10 year ago related needs.
  613. 0:45:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at your current arterial lay miles current PMTs to get these levels of service in terms of lay miles
  614. 0:45:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker per thousand person miles travel and we look at what is a cost-constructive lane mile what is a cost-constructive bus stops and so we get these
  615. 0:45:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker different cost factors and levels of service standards.
  616. 0:45:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we look at the same thing for on-street and off-street paths because these paths are part of your transportation
  617. 0:45:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker network.
  618. 0:45:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we are able to convert this into the fees, which are substantially increased.
  619. 0:45:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, this is probably the
  620. 0:46:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fee that is most right for looking at other revenue sources to look at the better-term bydale in this fee or reduce this fee.
  621. 0:46:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker With fee is $11,000 or $31 for a single family in $6,795 per multi-family unit.
  622. 0:46:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does he expect commercial, which has the highest trip
  623. 0:46:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker generation rates, has the highest OSP 8382 per thousand, all of my office at 3712, industrial at 233.
  624. 0:46:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and then with this trip reduction or the trip exchange district I mentioned the species are reduced further for
  625. 0:46:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the town center in Old Town areas where the trip break goes from.
  626. 0:46:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think it was at 178 to 8405 for a single family house.
  627. 0:46:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It goes from
  628. 0:46:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 67, 95, 48, 19, for example, for a multi-family unit.
  629. 0:47:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It goes from 8,000 a change, for a commercial, 3,000 a change for off-se
  630. 0:47:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to 2 to 2 six and I'm just a 1.4 or it's going to be $1439 for industrial.
  631. 0:47:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So in terms of revenue
  632. 0:47:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we are projecting that the total expenditures would be about $45.2 million and revenue would approximate that at $45.2 million.
  633. 0:47:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, you could choose
  634. 0:47:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to build 60 million and transportation approved let's back, nuclear at the moment pay, 45 million of that.
  635. 0:47:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
  636. 0:47:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this looks at, those are, yeah, once we're skipping.
  637. 0:47:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So here's the FECOM.
  638. 0:47:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is where you add all the fees together.
  639. 0:47:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we look at a single family unit,
  640. 0:47:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker your currency compared to the region is already fairly high at $16,000.
  641. 0:48:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, the strap fees,
  642. 0:48:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 23.9 or 23,952 dollars, which would make it the highest, but again, these numbers are very, very pollinarians.
  643. 0:48:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In terms of multi-family units, the same thing.
  644. 0:48:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're already in the top 15%.
  645. 0:48:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Current fees, $9216.
  646. 0:48:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This would go to 1397.
  647. 0:48:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
  648. 0:48:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker then in terms of retail,
  649. 0:48:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you're sort of middle to pack at 10,788 per thousand, and this would go up to 14,717.
  650. 0:48:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again,
  651. 0:48:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker these are draft numbers.
  652. 0:48:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Other thing I don't, I should mention about these tables.
  653. 0:48:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't like these tables, but I know what we have to do is because it's
  654. 0:48:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker really not an apples to apples comparison you can see all these footnotes here in terms of for instance if we're talking about park impact fees some communities include land they include record centers they
  655. 0:48:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker include trails, they include open space.
  656. 0:49:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How long ago was it that they updated their fees, for instance?
  657. 0:49:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks to keep in mind right now, we are updating Lewisville's fees
  658. 0:49:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker right now, so they are likely to be increased.
  659. 0:49:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We are updating decodos, in fact fees.
  660. 0:49:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They are going to increase significantly.
  661. 0:49:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Boulder reached out to me today
  662. 0:49:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and said,
  663. 0:49:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're going to be updating the fees next year.
  664. 0:49:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they're going to increase.
  665. 0:49:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's all these things that you have to sort of explain and keep in the back of your mind as we
  666. 0:49:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker compare Uri to who we see as our peers or our competitors.
  667. 0:49:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, and this only is a combination of these that
  668. 0:49:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we just spoke about, not water storage or big, not all, not diasucties, not include water resources or sewer access.
  669. 0:49:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Exactly.
  670. 0:49:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And all of the water rates of fees and everything we evaluate will begin evaluating those next year.
  671. 0:49:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's a totally separate study that we're referring to the council.
  672. 0:49:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  673. 0:50:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm just going to push my math on what
  674. 0:50:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker an average, $2,700 square foot home is in Erie somewhere around $650,000.
  675. 0:50:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that turns out to be about a 3.7%.
  676. 0:50:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Does that sound higher low with the cross donation or can I not even ask that question?
  677. 0:50:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's a reasonable way.
  678. 0:50:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a difficult question.
  679. 0:50:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  680. 0:50:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because it
  681. 0:50:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker depends because because we work in communities where the where the average price of a house is greater but feaser less right and vice versa but i'm just
  682. 0:50:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know what most recently of $15,000 impact, the school impact B was in South Carolina on a mortgage.
  683. 0:50:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're talking maybe 150
  684. 0:50:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 50 bucks a month.
  685. 0:50:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you may assume it's a $23,000 fee, which you probably won't be.
  686. 0:50:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, and this doesn't go out of property taxes.
  687. 0:50:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, this is not for consuming the herbs.
  688. 0:50:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're rolling it in the mortgage.
  689. 0:51:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It different rates because it's diminuing the rates.
  690. 0:51:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's how much the VS, right?
  691. 0:51:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
  692. 0:51:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the doubt payment all of that.
  693. 0:51:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But, you know, worst case scenario, it's $23,000.
  694. 0:51:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's $50,
  695. 0:51:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but you're already paying probably $100 already in the mortgage because your
  696. 0:51:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker current fee is 16,000.
  697. 0:51:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll have all, when we get final numbers, that'll be a metric that we will show you.
  698. 0:51:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So do we put these into ranges or is that a person
  699. 0:51:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker square foot number?
  700. 0:51:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a flat for a single family fee, flat for a multi-family fee.
  701. 0:51:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know how it's currently structured in our fees.
  702. 0:51:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're incentivizing building bigger
  703. 0:51:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and bigger houses because that fee is spread over a bigger picture.
  704. 0:51:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, I'm not so sure you're incentivizing it because when we do fees by size of house,
  705. 0:51:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which is an option if you guys want to proceed at the builders build what the market is it's not like all the sudden builders start building smaller houses because the fees last they build what they can
  706. 0:52:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sell yes and no but i mean within a
  707. 0:52:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker certain scale, I mean,
  708. 0:52:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know,
  709. 0:52:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're going to charge the same for a 30-by-wire square, but all of this is moving to 27-by-wire square,
  710. 0:52:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's true with water taps and sewer taps as well.
  711. 0:52:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, because it's high.
  712. 0:52:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's high.
  713. 0:52:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's high.
  714. 0:52:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  715. 0:52:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But i don't justify it yeah i mean i think what are you going to find understanding it's kind of do you have a progressive uh fee structure where it gets more expensive or
  716. 0:52:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's done at the square footage so yeah with a minimum with a minimum yeah yeah a question about greedily the fee
  717. 0:52:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is the same for stangle family, multi-family,
  718. 0:53:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and price per square foot.
  719. 0:53:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, it's a flat fee, it looks like, and almost looks
  720. 0:53:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like a flat fee now i don't know see you know nine you know no they're we have another fee some 20 years now i'm just wondering if you do anything about it by the i'm gonna
  721. 0:53:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you of all sorts of research that's the only one that i came across that and it's a point if we don't have the last time it was reviewed so it could be that that's
  722. 0:53:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker something we've had for 15 years and so we can definitely find out yeah there should be we could get a town so that's okay so you can see maybe we should get in there yeah we should
  723. 0:53:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker She's already getting worked.
  724. 0:53:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker She's not even here yet.
  725. 0:53:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so in terms of next steps,
  726. 0:53:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as I mentioned earlier,
  727. 0:53:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and Sarah mentioned as well, staff is currently reviewing all of this information so we will be adjusting based on staff feedback and any feedback we receive here tonight.
  728. 0:54:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We'll talk about
  729. 0:54:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker different policy items to consider.
  730. 0:54:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We are already talking about next steps in terms of stakeholder engagement, HBA,
  731. 0:54:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker other bodies that we may want to talk to.
  732. 0:54:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I'm assuming at some point here, next month of April, we'll be back to you with more refined numbers and some of those metrics
  733. 0:54:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that I mentioned, like what's the impact on housing affordability in terms of, you know, we look at that typically in two ways.
  734. 0:54:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One is what does that mean on a mortgage at different interest rates,
  735. 0:54:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but also looking at it in terms of using metrics like you should be spending more than 33% of your income on housing,
  736. 0:54:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what is that what is the spent today versus under the new fee structure as well so um question on growth rate right use duck to god you check i get
  737. 0:54:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that, that's the standard that we use.
  738. 0:55:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, we have water restrictions, right?
  739. 0:55:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So our growth rates, not going to be, it's going to be restricted
  740. 0:55:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker out of that of faculty or calculations.
  741. 0:55:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I don't want to mischief yourself.
  742. 0:55:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Somebody's staff can correct me.
  743. 0:55:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If I get this wrong, we went
  744. 0:55:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker back and forth with staff on the,
  745. 0:55:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because at one point we were using projections from one of the studies that may have been the transportation master plan, and that was a
  746. 0:55:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker comment we got.
  747. 0:55:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Obviously that growth rate can't be realized because of the water constraints and I think David has that.
  748. 0:55:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, it's a damn passing public structure.
  749. 0:55:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We had talked with planning about a couple different options about taking into account the water restrictions.
  750. 0:55:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
  751. 0:55:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there is like a conservative amount of like a smaller growth rate that was contemplated with the water restriction.
  752. 0:56:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker model that we're using right now.
  753. 0:56:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then there was the other end of the spectrum with the TMP with regard to the growth rates that were assumed with
  754. 0:56:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that and then the complain.
  755. 0:56:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When we did some additional analysis with the TMP kind of refining our numbers, we used the Dr.
  756. 0:56:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg growth rate, which we
  757. 0:56:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker thought was a little more realistic because yes we're going to see some slowing of development kind of in those early years what we're experiencing now but over time
  758. 0:56:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as we get more CBT shares that we're purchasing as we identify more resources we're going to be able to identify additional ways to help
  759. 0:56:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker facilitate growth moving forward.
  760. 0:56:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Developers will find ways to bring their own water in different things like that.
  761. 0:56:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we didn't want to be too conservative with the lower growth rate, which would likely drive up the
  762. 0:57:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fee and then find out over time that hey we actually solved some of the issues or we got good news on one of our projects and they came online early not
  763. 0:57:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker likely but we wanted to leave room for options moving forward so the the growth rate that we have in place now is kind of that taking
  764. 0:57:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker into some slowing but not the full slowing that could happen if we keep up down the path that were currently on it does that make sense it does it i'm just do you say
  765. 0:57:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's still a little bit concerned because it's a big difference between, you know, I calculated over 350 homes per year, right?
  766. 0:57:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we're running that around
  767. 0:57:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 200,
  768. 0:57:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker based on the water, based on the economy, etc.
  769. 0:57:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And you get out six years.
  770. 0:57:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's almost, that's eight hundred and some at
  771. 0:57:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker homes that we won't build y'all for the next six years.
  772. 0:58:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I get that the dynamic is going to change.
  773. 0:58:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You need to pick a
  774. 0:58:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker standard and run with it, but you say, just let's be cognizant of that.
  775. 0:58:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah,
  776. 0:58:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if we did it to the lower number of the fees would increase.
  777. 0:58:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's one of the things that we were trying to balance is that we do anticipate we're going to have some additional resources identified with the water supply
  778. 0:58:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker issue that we're currently facing and we don't want to drive rates so high to kind of form a worst case scenario for that entire time period but
  779. 0:58:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we will ultimately come back in another five years and update these again so if we're continuing to see that we can make adjustments appropriately so and yeah i'm
  780. 0:58:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker definitely a very pro-growth piece for growth at the same time with the economy, with the water restrictions, or not.
  781. 0:58:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We are building permissive slowdown
  782. 0:59:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker significantly increasing the fees is going could slow that down further and that's just going to get passed on to the to the consumer um
  783. 0:59:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker making our homes even more expensive.
  784. 0:59:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But at the lower growth rate, we don't need as much for schools
  785. 0:59:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or please right and that's the thing with the conceptual base approach is that it's it's immune to the growth rate and if you're doing a plan base
  786. 0:59:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker approach, you are counting on a certain amount of revenue coming in based on that growth rate.
  787. 0:59:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if it's not there, you still have to build the plan, right?
  788. 0:59:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's just use parts as example.
  789. 0:59:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's just say
  790. 0:59:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're going to develop 20 acres part in a plan-based approach.
  791. 0:59:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You only get enough revenue for 10.
  792. 0:59:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You still got to build the 20, right?
  793. 0:59:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Where the consumption-based approach, you just have to build
  794. 0:59:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to the revenue that you collect so go to slow there's only demand for six acres of parks and you got the money there like if it's 16 you got the
  795. 1:00:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker money.
  796. 1:00:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if it's, and if it grows this faster, let's just say it's 26 acres, you've got the money,
  797. 1:00:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker right?
  798. 1:00:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's a way of hedging your bets.
  799. 1:00:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  800. 1:00:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  801. 1:00:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can I?
  802. 1:00:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  803. 1:00:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  804. 1:00:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was just going to mention that the Dr.
  805. 1:00:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg Growth Plan are numbers we've
  806. 1:00:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker been looking at those through part of the study for the I25 corridor, the, oh, David, I'm going to try to say it's the interchange study, right?
  807. 1:00:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker interchange analysis along I guess and so Dr.
  808. 1:00:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg is actually coming to NATO this week so we can get an update because through that process we kind of identified that
  809. 1:00:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the Dr.
  810. 1:00:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg numbers are lagging behind and so I just wanted to throw that in there that the numbers that from the Dr.
  811. 1:01:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg growth
  812. 1:01:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rejections are likely lower than what we're experiencing and that we had plans for.
  813. 1:01:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's more to come on that.
  814. 1:01:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm not sure what the solve will be on
  815. 1:01:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that, but the state demographer and Dr.
  816. 1:01:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg and a bunch of other communities were all looking at those to kind of get those more solid excuse me
  817. 1:01:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My question is, and I think you mentioned that we'll be looking at how this affects affordability and as the process goes on,
  818. 1:01:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll be interested to know more about that.
  819. 1:01:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And thank you, Council Member Hobeck, for pointing out the concern around incentivizing larger
  820. 1:01:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker houses how how what is an approach we could take to encourage and support multi-family homes some of those missing middle housing types that we
  821. 1:01:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are missing we know that our last housing needs its analysis showed that we have for sure like 5 000 rentals and we need some more of those the
  822. 1:02:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker higher densities in town how do we support that forward thinking a good good question two ways one is i mean one if council
  823. 1:02:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker wants us to direct us to redo the demographics, we can propose a fee schedule by size of house.
  824. 1:02:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I'm a big proponent of that.
  825. 1:02:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It helps me
  826. 1:02:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the proportionality is better helps with housing affordability housing equity i mean again my experience is the market's going to build to what the market demands it's not going
  827. 1:02:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to mean the current system isn't going to incentivize larger homes.
  828. 1:02:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And conversely, if we go by size, they're not going to build smaller homes.
  829. 1:02:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's the first option.
  830. 1:02:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker as we can do it by size, a progressive residential fee structure.
  831. 1:02:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The second option is more of a policy choice on behalf of the town where if you
  832. 1:03:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker want to subsidize workforce housing, missing middle, etc., all these different terms for you could have a
  833. 1:03:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker policy where you wave or reduce fees.
  834. 1:03:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The caveat would be you'd have to make up that money or find that money from another source in order to make the CIP whole.
  835. 1:03:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  836. 1:03:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think Councillor Barrett's questions could be brought back to the other
  837. 1:03:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker stakeholders too.
  838. 1:03:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And just to get a sense, did I have any of the other town cities that you put up there if they do it that way or they do it a lot by size of house?
  839. 1:03:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that clear yeah some of them do yeah okay yeah i've also worked in a municipality previously that did have a credit for um what you would call missing metal or affordable housing um they provided that incentive so there were
  840. 1:03:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker yeah yeah it's very often so the credit one is easy for you to get my head around just gonna find general fund money or whatever exactly it's more of charging a different rate by the house size do
  841. 1:04:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know if any of the cities have tells the person who is most local does that i've been doing it for years yeah yeah i think one one does too i'm not sure that because it changed the demographic is about
  842. 1:04:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what's being built.
  843. 1:04:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, it goes back to your point.
  844. 1:04:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're going to build up the market over there.
  845. 1:04:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So keep it simple as...
  846. 1:04:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker guess it's an argument in that case, right?
  847. 1:04:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not good.
  848. 1:04:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I like I said, I'm a big proponent of the size-based fees because of the housing equity and proportionality issues, but for an
  849. 1:04:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker administrative perspective it's much more difficult yeah and do do those manual like with that minimum amount cover those impact fees with
  850. 1:04:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a cover of a key for needs yeah because you're still the average you're still going to have an average size house it doesn't change the revenue projections it'll come out well it'll go down right you're not going to have a certain amount that
  851. 1:05:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a lot of folks you recovered immediately and a certain amount of fol lowed immediately.
  852. 1:05:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if you're still going to get same out revenue regarding the multi-family units here, that's an average or multi-family unit
  853. 1:05:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker square footage.
  854. 1:05:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's an average that is calculated here at 750 square feet.
  855. 1:05:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Where do you see that?
  856. 1:05:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker get it.
  857. 1:05:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh.
  858. 1:05:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, that must,
  859. 1:05:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for jurisdictions that have a size base, that's what we're using as the average.
  860. 1:05:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I don't think, like, for instance, if Lewisville has, let's say, 10 different tears, you know, we pick the average one to show as the V example.
  861. 1:05:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, i think that the average is probably higher than that merely i know that it has nothing to do with the ear because you don't do it by size that's what we're using is that i and i don't know which ones else to come i had to do with my size
  862. 1:06:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but it's, say, three of them handed my size.
  863. 1:06:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're choosing the 750 as the example to compare against.
  864. 1:06:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's go back to your comment.
  865. 1:06:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  866. 1:06:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not going out.
  867. 1:06:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  868. 1:06:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  869. 1:06:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  870. 1:06:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not Apple's stamp.
  871. 1:06:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's at first.
  872. 1:06:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the demographics, I mean, the difference we see from jurisdiction to jurisdiction is where the leveling off begins.
  873. 1:06:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we
  874. 1:06:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker unless you've got monkey demographics like a retirement community in Florida for instance, right?
  875. 1:06:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're going to see this progression of size or number of people per household, browsing unit, and then it's
  876. 1:06:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker going to level off at some point.
  877. 1:06:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that level at off point is where it varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.
  878. 1:06:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It may be 5500 square feet and 1 jurisdiction, but 3500.
  879. 1:06:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And now, right, we just don't know until we get into
  880. 1:06:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it and that also influences the bands that we use right some some communities want to get to you know every hundred square feet and then others that make sense to do 250
  881. 1:06:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker square feet or 500 square feet, right?
  882. 1:06:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we don't have to, because we do a linear regression analysis,
  883. 1:07:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we look at zero degrees as well.
  884. 1:07:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  885. 1:07:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So one
  886. 1:07:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of the things I was wondering about is when we look at these and I
  887. 1:07:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is a topic where it's very easy to do that.
  888. 1:07:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What's that?
  889. 1:07:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is a topic where it's easy to do that.
  890. 1:07:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But, uh,
  891. 1:07:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so when you're working with the stakeholders, I think it's really important to get them, learn from them, what they're seeing in other communities.
  892. 1:07:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker even maybe even more importantly what can we do to make their life a little bit easier to reduce their costs so that these impact
  893. 1:07:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fees don't hit them as hard, right?
  894. 1:07:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because we need developers, we need to partner with them to have a good strong community at the same time,
  895. 1:08:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know,
  896. 1:08:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the more we increase our fees and put impact on them, they could easily go to, you know, somewhere else down the road.
  897. 1:08:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And, you know, we're seeing our building
  898. 1:08:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker permanently.
  899. 1:08:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So look down, but I think that's across the board everywhere, right?
  900. 1:08:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, other comments, questions,
  901. 1:08:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The level of detail.
  902. 1:08:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Obviously, we are doing this in a 10-year frame time.
  903. 1:08:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Can we increase decreasing between somewhere?
  904. 1:08:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It doesn't affect the amount.
  905. 1:08:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's really just the 10-year time frame is basically done to show you what the demand and what the revenue would be.
  906. 1:08:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we have to do it every five years.
  907. 1:08:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  908. 1:08:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And part of the 10 years too in concourtney from Ronnie, I know from a financial modeling standpoint, 10 years is the most predictable kind of space we can live in, especially with all of our different
  909. 1:08:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker plans and strategic plans.
  910. 1:08:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it tends to be the most accurate and then that every five year with that update, we can really kind of get more.
  911. 1:09:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now, to your point about knowing that we have like a 20-year bond, if we go
  912. 1:09:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with that route with like with our coffee recovery on the COPs we could certainly like do a rough model out and what that was look like but it wouldn't add value unconscional we would still be kind of seeing the same
  913. 1:09:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker impact and we'd still be reevaluating that every five years.
  914. 1:09:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When you're building in the costs,
  915. 1:09:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're sort of an inflation factor
  916. 1:09:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here in the great question.
  917. 1:09:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, and I don't know all the top of my head whether you're ordinate, specifies this.
  918. 1:09:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But one way to keep pace is
  919. 1:09:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker each year your ordinance can inflate the fees based on the consumer or the engineering news and revenue pricing index, RS meets pricing
  920. 1:09:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker index.
  921. 1:09:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're keeping pace with inflation in those years between the feast of...
  922. 1:09:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  923. 1:09:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So to that point, I think exactly our unicode is written.
  924. 1:09:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was going to pull it off and then you said that nothing fells one off.
  925. 1:10:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So all of ours are eligible for us to do an inflationary increase based on that exact inflation.
  926. 1:10:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have not been doing that.
  927. 1:10:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That just hasn't been a policy direction
  928. 1:10:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we've received.
  929. 1:10:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know if the questions have been asked of you all either.
  930. 1:10:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's certainly something we can start examining on a yearly basis.
  931. 1:10:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You have the point that we're perfect, but I don't remember the last six years.
  932. 1:10:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker know, and I've only been here three and this is the first time we've done this since I've been here since making optional or at Council's direction.
  933. 1:10:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And pretty, yes, I think it's the way it's written and I don't have to double check, but
  934. 1:10:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's written like week we shower we can it's very abroad it's not and you can definitely double check man well it's different than can yes sorry yeah there's language that makes it more ambiguous
  935. 1:10:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not like required of us.
  936. 1:10:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's no requirement to increase inflation that we can make that choice.
  937. 1:10:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think I like that approach because for the, I think for the development community, I hear this quite a bit, especially looking
  938. 1:10:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at the parks fees, and I realized he said, with that jump, there's a way we can possibly buy that down.
  939. 1:11:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But we had this with our tappy fees a few years ago.
  940. 1:11:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We hadn't raised them certain amount of
  941. 1:11:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker time.
  942. 1:11:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We realized we were out of sink.
  943. 1:11:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so it was a big jump for them.
  944. 1:11:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So building that in where you have it over time and then when you do the next study in five years,
  945. 1:11:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker then you've
  946. 1:11:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker kind of got a linear curve that you can say, okay, we can build off this.
  947. 1:11:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now, other things I realize affect that because, you know, I don't know, price
  948. 1:11:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of concrete goes up.
  949. 1:11:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Price fastball goes up.
  950. 1:11:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You know, there's all those some predictables.
  951. 1:11:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But at least I think what I've heard at least for most of our developers is they just
  952. 1:11:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker want some assurance of what the path is for because a lot of times what they'll do and they've done this before if we have a big price job they just they'll buy
  953. 1:11:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a permit right before, right?
  954. 1:11:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The price increased.
  955. 1:11:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that doesn't do us any good because we're not seeing the revenue for it.
  956. 1:12:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we have this long, big draft, where we're not
  957. 1:12:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker collecting peripheries so yeah right so also i think it would be helpful that you know the fees that you're working on but also the fees like the water storage and
  958. 1:12:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker things like that, that you list them all so we can see the total or all the fees.
  959. 1:12:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we know exactly what increase of the house increased
  960. 1:12:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker boss bar and you know one of the timeline for coming back after you meet with the stakeholders etc good
  961. 1:12:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Good question.
  962. 1:12:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker My guess is the first stakeholder being would be early December, maybe late December.
  963. 1:12:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So my guess is coming back to you guys probably the
  964. 1:12:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker new year with all the day seasons and all that it's hard to take advantage of you know the thing with the new council manager right uh with their insight yeah they've got a deep insight of you know
  965. 1:12:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker greely um that that would also be sort of like before um just to jump in here a quick um kel address bar deputy planning uh director did message me and said that we have been doing the
  966. 1:13:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker inflationary increases and we've been using the engineering news record so we have been doing something so i was in direct so just a correction there it's an automatic escalator i'm guess council intervenes of the ones exactly
  967. 1:13:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  968. 1:13:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So sorry, I'm a spoke on that for a week.
  969. 1:13:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that's the good news as we've been doing that.
  970. 1:13:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Which is my strength to me as well.
  971. 1:13:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So for my perspective,
  972. 1:13:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for
  973. 1:13:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker clarification is a progressive residential fee structure or something you want us to bring back to you for consideration my dad says no
  974. 1:13:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're probably split on this one.
  975. 1:13:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I guess I wouldn't hurt to have information.
  976. 1:13:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I guess I just want to know what
  977. 1:13:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the end goal is.
  978. 1:13:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, I think part of the sincere it says, because I've heard this before,
  979. 1:14:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that a lot of times from the developer point of view,
  980. 1:14:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if we have a fee increase that makes their projects not pencil out or whatever they're they're going to be looking for you know how
  981. 1:14:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what can they build at a certain number of units to make them most profitable versus, you know,
  982. 1:14:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and that may or may not, I can see in different scenarios
  983. 1:14:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where that may not limit them from buying or building small units.
  984. 1:14:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But I think at some level,
  985. 1:14:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we could possibly
  986. 1:14:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker incentivize some of those things because I think with the demographics of Irri and just what's happening in the market in general,
  987. 1:14:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker things probably 10 years ago that
  988. 1:14:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was attractive about Eritrean families coming in here so they're looking for more the typical single family home that dynamic may be changing because younger single families
  989. 1:14:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the price is going to point where they can't for that or their other, and to your point, the market is going to make those determinations, but if
  990. 1:15:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's something we can incentivize, I'm not opposed to looking at it, but at the same time, I mean, the whole purposes is ensure we're collecting enough fees to, we don't
  991. 1:15:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker want to subside to the point where current residents are paying for you know another group of people to move here so is the cost of that i'm assuming
  992. 1:15:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  993. 1:15:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's really, I think.
  994. 1:15:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  995. 1:15:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do you need an estimate from us?
  996. 1:15:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm pretty
  997. 1:15:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm simple for us to do.
  998. 1:15:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But it's horrible again.
  999. 1:15:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1000. 1:15:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't have to see the animation enough.
  1001. 1:15:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It can also be good to get feedback from other stakeholders.
  1002. 1:15:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1003. 1:15:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You know, the advantages and disadvantages are going one way or the other.
  1004. 1:15:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, that's simple enough to do.
  1005. 1:16:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Council over there.
  1006. 1:16:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hopefully you heard all that.
  1007. 1:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1008. 1:16:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1009. 1:16:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, but
  1010. 1:16:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lot to hear more on the, like we have the term you just used, but I would love to learn more about it.
  1011. 1:16:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I've loved for that to be included.
  1012. 1:16:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1013. 1:16:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Whether for
  1014. 1:16:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the question, one other thing, and we knew this two months ago, the tree impact fee is pulled out.
  1015. 1:16:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If I remarked correctly, I was mentioning that that would be
  1016. 1:16:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker collected somewhere else so we can transition that to the fee schedule as you do just as a really qualified as an impact fee so i work with cars in the kind of figure out what we would actually need
  1017. 1:16:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to collect in that.
  1018. 1:16:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It may be the same thing.
  1019. 1:16:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It may be different, but it would just be something we'd put into the feed schedule because it would be more underneath that realm of fucking action.
  1020. 1:16:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Come on.
  1021. 1:16:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That sounds good.
  1022. 1:16:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks.
  1023. 1:16:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  1024. 1:16:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker See you now.
  1025. 1:16:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I forgot about this.
  1026. 1:16:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you
  1027. 1:17:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker going to our third item of the agenda discussion correction on the business licensing updates.
  1028. 1:17:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is my first study session, so
  1029. 1:17:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just want to make sure I get the controls, right?
  1030. 1:17:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, I got it.
  1031. 1:17:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Let's formal.
  1032. 1:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Anybody can sign in and let's take a look at each other.
  1033. 1:17:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, and to that point, please interrupt me.
  1034. 1:17:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Have any questions or comments or concerns?
  1035. 1:17:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So Julian and I are here to talk to you all about our business licensing updates
  1036. 1:17:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we've been working on with the Town Attorney's Office for several months now, actually predating Brina's arrival.
  1037. 1:17:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So these have been in the work survey a long time.
  1038. 1:17:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And to begin with, though, we want to give you a little bit of background on business licensing where we were, how we got to where we are today.
  1039. 1:18:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Mac and iting goes through the
  1040. 1:18:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker benefits of the process licensing program.
  1041. 1:18:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some of the cost and revenues will look at a few of our regional peers to see what
  1042. 1:18:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they're doing and then go through the actual updates that we are proposing.
  1043. 1:18:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But as I said,
  1044. 1:18:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker anybody wants to stop me in any time and ask additional questions you are most welcome to.
  1045. 1:18:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So prior to 2018, we did require that business licenses, that all businesses have a business license and we
  1046. 1:18:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker renewals and we were collecting fees.
  1047. 1:18:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But in October 2018, the Board of Trustees eliminated the annual renewal requirement and the associated fees.
  1048. 1:18:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
  1049. 1:18:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker everyone still had to have a business license, but you got it once and it didn't really expire.
  1050. 1:18:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now some of the people who still maybe have some of those old ones or did when I started at the town,
  1051. 1:19:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you could walk into their business, they could have their business license up.
  1052. 1:19:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They would have all different expiration dates on them.
  1053. 1:19:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was kind of weird to see some that were like 25 years, some were 50, some were forever.
  1054. 1:19:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it
  1055. 1:19:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker wasn't really done in a super standardized method in that period of time between 2018 and them being reinstated.
  1056. 1:19:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Obviously, we know what happened in March of 2020 in the subsequent years, so we don't need to belabor the point there,
  1057. 1:19:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but that will come up in the next slide as well.
  1058. 1:19:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker En April
  1059. 1:19:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 2022, my esteemed colleague Julian presented to the Board of Trustees about reinstating annual renewals and fees.
  1060. 1:19:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And today,
  1061. 1:19:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses operating in here are generally required to obtain and maintain an annual business license fees are $50 for commercial businesses and $25 for
  1062. 1:19:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker home occupation businesses.
  1063. 1:19:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I say generally because there are a few small exceptions to this, such as nonprofits, which still do engage in business,
  1064. 1:20:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but they are one of the things we don't require business licenses for so i'm not going to like read through this entire slide but sort of tell the story that of covid and
  1065. 1:20:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker business licenses and all of these things are sort of touched on.
  1066. 1:20:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is all before my time in Erie but COVID happened and suddenly the town had a great
  1067. 1:20:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker need to communicate with businesses.
  1068. 1:20:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Only to shock horror, discover that a lot of the information we had collected over the preceding two years was out of date
  1069. 1:20:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and correct managers had left you might own a business but you don't run it every day you have a manager who does those positions can be higher turnover so now suddenly there was a
  1070. 1:20:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker great need to communicate all sorts of opportunities with businesses and we did not have a robust or current list of businesses in Erie
  1071. 1:21:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we communicate with.
  1072. 1:21:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Now this goes, you know, even further than that when we're talking about licensing and permitting and other requirements of the
  1073. 1:21:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker town the first touch point is often business licensing for a lot of business owners and if you do not start with the business license you may not even know that there are
  1074. 1:21:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker certain requirements for, you know, especially permits, building permits and whatnot or working potentially through the planning department.
  1075. 1:21:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We often are that first touch point
  1076. 1:21:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that then we can connect people with the other developments.
  1077. 1:21:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's a lot of other things we need to very badly communicate with our business owners
  1078. 1:21:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and some of those are just the things that our department offers including things like oh gosh we'll be vow prone our space where do we go well
  1079. 1:21:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we maintain a database to help people cite themselves in a larger better building something more suited to them so we have those kinds of offerings um
  1080. 1:22:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We also like to check in.
  1081. 1:22:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How are things going?
  1082. 1:22:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How are you doing?
  1083. 1:22:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker How is business in Erie?
  1084. 1:22:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if we don't have a good relationship and we just
  1085. 1:22:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker walk in the front door and say, hey,
  1086. 1:22:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sometimes people are a little confused about what people dressed in Erie gear are doing in their business.
  1087. 1:22:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or as if they've already been
  1088. 1:22:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker given some kind of intro to our department through our newsletter, through emails,
  1089. 1:22:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker phone calls, whatever happens to be, there's more a little bit more of a friendly face.
  1090. 1:22:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we do, obviously, do things in town that have nothing to do with business at all,
  1091. 1:22:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like fix water mains and update roundabouts
  1092. 1:22:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and pay valley ways and things like that.
  1093. 1:22:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And a lot of those activities do have significant impacts to business owners as you've heard in fact
  1094. 1:23:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker here today.
  1095. 1:23:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the ability to communicate with folks quickly about things that might be coming up with those projects is really, really
  1096. 1:23:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pivotal for our department and it's pivotal for the business owners as well so a lot of that information that we share out we get that through business licensing
  1097. 1:23:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because every year you need to update your contact information.
  1098. 1:23:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If your manager changes, we need new information for that before it closed.
  1099. 1:23:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The
  1100. 1:23:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker AT&T at 9 mile switched ownership five times.
  1101. 1:23:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we had consistent information about how to contact those owners all across that process.
  1102. 1:23:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
  1103. 1:23:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that is owed only to business licensing so i'm going to go to the next slide unless someone has a question okay i do i do a question much
  1104. 1:23:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Rard to the state requires fees for registering your LLC or your business.
  1105. 1:24:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that data available to us?
  1106. 1:24:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It is, but one of the super awesome things that's happening right now is that China is incentivizing people to set up companies in Colorado with Colorado mailing
  1107. 1:24:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker addresses, business addresses,
  1108. 1:24:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they're not actually doing business in Colorado.
  1109. 1:24:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we actually had an intern here, the summer who pulled data on all eerie-based
  1110. 1:24:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses that the Secretary of State had listed since like 1900 and it was a computer crashingly large file which did
  1111. 1:24:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker happen to his computer but when he looked through just the past few years it was like crazy high insane numbers and those businesses are not in Erie so that data
  1112. 1:24:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is available, but sifting through all of that to say, like, what is a real eerie business?
  1113. 1:24:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What isn't a real eerie business?
  1114. 1:24:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's like very challenging.
  1115. 1:25:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Universities.
  1116. 1:25:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, yeah.
  1117. 1:25:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
  1118. 1:25:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like every company in the Sultan Valley goes to Rhode Islanda.
  1119. 1:25:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, Delaware.
  1120. 1:25:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1121. 1:25:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You also have a lot of LLCs that registered on your internity or some
  1122. 1:25:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker separate agent that has a different attorney address in Denver or somewhere else, but they're based in Erie.
  1123. 1:25:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, the information is just not truly accurate.
  1124. 1:25:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there's no contact information with those.
  1125. 1:25:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we
  1126. 1:25:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have like a mailing address, but no phone number.
  1127. 1:25:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe not even it's a Julian's point about the registered agent.
  1128. 1:25:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe not even the correct first name, last name for the person who owns the business.
  1129. 1:25:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then we don't have like any mail
  1130. 1:25:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker address or any way to actually like reach them and male is so much more expensive than just like a phone call.
  1131. 1:25:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I know everyone loves getting male and male's awesome.
  1132. 1:25:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker respect to USBS.
  1133. 1:25:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do great job.
  1134. 1:25:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So some of the stuff is redundant about what I just said, but just to go through it, to be very, very
  1135. 1:25:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker clear.
  1136. 1:26:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We do not collect our own sales tax to do so would require more staff, which my understanding is that's not a
  1137. 1:26:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker thing we're doing.
  1138. 1:26:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So for the time being, the state will continue to collect our sale tax.
  1139. 1:26:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And in the meantime, business licensing provides us with a cheap and easy
  1140. 1:26:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker way to be able to do all of this, know which businesses are in here, maintain that accurate information that I was just talking about, collect current contact information,
  1141. 1:26:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker coordinate with building and planning and other potential departments to coordinate around required permits, inspections, and regulatory compliance,
  1142. 1:26:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and support public safety some of the sufferers talking about with construction projects our economic development work and data data town operations
  1143. 1:26:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and these are some more specific examples again i feel like i'm kind of repeating myself
  1144. 1:27:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But I think another very cool thing that we do with our business licensing is we actually ask people how many people work for you.
  1145. 1:27:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we can quantify who are the top employers
  1146. 1:27:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in Giri by going through that process of the nonprofit sector and non-government sectors.
  1147. 1:27:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we can use it in that act for this area.
  1148. 1:27:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1149. 1:27:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so knowing how many people are employed in Erie is actually like a pretty great thing to know.
  1150. 1:27:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's not something that a lot of people necessarily know, a lot of other universalities,
  1151. 1:27:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker necessarily know so that was our local business administrator smiley as she put that question there so big props to her um obviously we have
  1152. 1:27:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a lot of amazing opportunities through our department that we can offer people and we can communicate those with them.
  1153. 1:27:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Our business assistance programs, we can connect people with
  1154. 1:28:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker low cost loans we have grants we have our incentive i don't want to know spoilers that's next so i won't say anything more about our incentive program but um more to come
  1155. 1:28:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on that.
  1156. 1:28:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we also have, of course, like I mentioned, our real estate opportunities so we can help move people around if they've outgrown their space.
  1157. 1:28:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The construction coordination always
  1158. 1:28:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a big part of what we do um the awesome avenue around about is a great example because not only did that commit i think we handled that communication with our
  1159. 1:28:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses quite well.
  1160. 1:28:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We got really good feedback on that.
  1161. 1:28:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We had some folks who were very against the roundabout, who by the end of the project were, I would say, at least satisfied with the work that we
  1162. 1:28:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker did and for anybody who could quantify an actual impact on their business based on foot traffic being decreased we had our construction impact mitigation grant that we were also able
  1163. 1:28:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to communicate out to people through the email addresses we collect through business licensing.
  1164. 1:29:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do you need to take advantage of that?
  1165. 1:29:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Said it downtown for the Breach Street project and an awesome avenue as well so we we were pretty happy with that public safety and compliance
  1166. 1:29:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we are not
  1167. 1:29:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker going to name any names, but there have been a few business owners that through the business licensing process we did discover that there
  1168. 1:29:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker were some larger issues with building permits and whatnot that people were not following per se.
  1169. 1:29:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we were able to quickly get
  1170. 1:29:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker them in front of the right people to have conversations to make sure that those permits were put in place and we were able to kind of rectify those situations.
  1171. 1:29:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We do not want safety issues
  1172. 1:29:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like drop ceilings being put over sprinklers, which did happen.
  1173. 1:29:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then another really good example of that is our kind of last one is
  1174. 1:30:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker regulatory communications,
  1175. 1:30:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the RTD Sales Tax increase that went forward and impacted old town,
  1176. 1:30:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we found out only afterwards that RTD was like, well, that was your ballot
  1177. 1:30:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker item, and so we're not actually going to do any of the communications to let businesses know they need to charge one more percent not to point anything else, but I guess it just did.
  1178. 1:30:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Anyway,
  1179. 1:30:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so that
  1180. 1:30:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ended up falling on our department to reach out and educate everybody that like as of this date you need to increase your sales tax that you're charging at your point of sales sheets by 1% and if we didn't
  1181. 1:30:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker communicate that out,
  1182. 1:30:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they were never going to know.
  1183. 1:30:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There was no other way that that was getting pushed out.
  1184. 1:30:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So like our ability to know who is doing business in that like geographical area and we
  1185. 1:30:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like we worked with gis to map it so we knew who was affected where i will to get out there and get that information out very quickly um so that was that was like we were really under the gun because
  1186. 1:30:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it had already gone into effect and only then was it discovered that it was now on us to communicate that out.
  1187. 1:31:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's odd because it's not our tax.
  1188. 1:31:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's our TP.
  1189. 1:31:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was
  1190. 1:31:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the state collection.
  1191. 1:31:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we really never touched the money or never...
  1192. 1:31:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We were left holding the communications bag.
  1193. 1:31:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we did what
  1194. 1:31:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we had to do to help our businesses because that's what our department does so that was a good example of like we were like oh gosh we need to get to work so that was like the
  1195. 1:31:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker machinery went into motion and we got everybody up and running with the new and we actually had to communicate it out before that one website that tells you what your sales taxes had even been updated
  1196. 1:31:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so people were looking at that saying oh well it still says it's whenever percent it well as and we're like we can answer one percent more now unfortunately it just doesn't say that on this website yet so like we are actually before
  1197. 1:31:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the website itself had fully been updated to tell everybody what their sales tax was.
  1198. 1:31:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So anyway, that was a putting supplement to motion
  1199. 1:32:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker really quick to try and make sure our businesses were not negatively impacted and we were able to do that through business licensing questions
  1200. 1:32:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker excellent
  1201. 1:32:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just a picture of what's going on right now.
  1202. 1:32:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A commercial business license, as I mentioned before, is $50.
  1203. 1:32:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's if you have a brick and mortar
  1204. 1:32:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and you are a four-profit business.
  1205. 1:32:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A home occupation business is $25 a new leaf.
  1206. 1:32:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The fees have been in place since 2022 and they do
  1207. 1:32:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker partially offset program administration costs that was around the time that our department grew added the local business administrator position she
  1208. 1:32:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker spends about 50 of her time if you take the amount of time she spends around renewal the renewal period which usually starts you know
  1209. 1:32:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker December through and March that's like she's really doing a lot of work then and then through the rest of the year it's like a little bit less but you know even this year with
  1210. 1:33:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our code inspection team growing, she's been doing a little bit more working with them as well because they're occasionally
  1211. 1:33:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some odd things that occur.
  1212. 1:33:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, no names.
  1213. 1:33:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Not going to point any fingers, but some strange homocks,
  1214. 1:33:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some brick and mortars who don't
  1215. 1:33:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker get quite the right,
  1216. 1:33:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, code, they don't go through the right processes.
  1217. 1:33:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so Shamana is very folded in with that team in order to help get all of that done.
  1218. 1:33:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think
  1219. 1:33:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're kind of counting that as business licensing even though that's not like she's not just sitting there like putting a button of proving business licenses she's like working with people we're going out and educating people
  1220. 1:33:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're actually having conversations with people doing office hours so yes about 50 for a time annual licensing revenue approximately 20 000 the
  1221. 1:34:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker number of active businesses with licenses in Erie 425 between both Brickham Order and Home Occupation and we have had an annual renewal rate
  1222. 1:34:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of 87.5%, which is up from 70% last year.
  1223. 1:34:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think of kind of probably beach over the head with this a
  1224. 1:34:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker little bit, but we have that annually updated business databases of major thing that we get out of the program.
  1225. 1:34:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We are able to support lots of different town
  1226. 1:34:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker departments.
  1227. 1:34:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, it's not just planning and building public works when they're doing their construction projects,
  1228. 1:34:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the communications team.
  1229. 1:34:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's like a lot of different divisions
  1230. 1:34:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker across the whole town that get information from us through business licensing.
  1231. 1:34:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I think in order to do what we would need
  1232. 1:34:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to do to get all of this information through different means means does save us quite a bit of time then i don't know whatever else we would be doing go and door the
  1233. 1:35:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker door beggift for business cards I guess so sorry this might be a little hard for everybody to see I hope you have
  1234. 1:35:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some stuff in front of you.
  1235. 1:35:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I really don't want to go through each all of this.
  1236. 1:35:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm just going to give a very high level overview.
  1237. 1:35:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are, we got two folks on this list that
  1238. 1:35:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are like us and don't collect their own set.
  1239. 1:35:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They don't have the Sales Tax license.
  1240. 1:35:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They've got the business license instead.
  1241. 1:35:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Superior notable for being the one strange place
  1242. 1:35:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that collects their own sales tax and has a sales tax license and also requires a business license.
  1243. 1:35:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I could not tell you why they decided to do that, but that's an
  1244. 1:35:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker interesting little place.
  1245. 1:35:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Everywhere else that's home rule has the self-collection thing.
  1246. 1:36:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it is a little bit apples to oranges when we compare what
  1247. 1:36:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they're doing with what we're doing because the sales and use tax license just functions very differently from how our business licensing functions.
  1248. 1:36:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some people do
  1249. 1:36:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have to keep,
  1250. 1:36:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there is like a renewal fee, sometimes there's not, you can see a little bit of variation in there.
  1251. 1:36:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some people have, like
  1252. 1:36:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the enforcement notes are a little all over place, but a lot of people have this like penalties interest and audit risk.
  1253. 1:36:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's for the generally goes alongside with the
  1254. 1:36:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker self-collect homeral and then for our friends who collect their or who the state collects it for them there's a lot of different ways that they're
  1255. 1:36:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker doing that fire zone does have some late fees.
  1256. 1:36:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's some stuff there.
  1257. 1:36:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just wanted to like not go through it too much, but if anyone has questions about
  1258. 1:36:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this, this is a good time for us to be able to see if we can answer them.
  1259. 1:37:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So real quickly,
  1260. 1:37:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker if the separate business license isn't known, what's up with a fee?
  1261. 1:37:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that considered a
  1262. 1:37:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sales tax fluctuate?
  1263. 1:37:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or what is that?
  1264. 1:37:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's like a sales tax license renewal fee.
  1265. 1:37:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's $16.
  1266. 1:37:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The $16 is the state fee to renew your
  1267. 1:37:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker state sales tax license or these so our
  1268. 1:37:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker comparison is $50, which is the commercial, not the home occupation, right?
  1269. 1:37:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Our home office is comparing as, I know it's not an obstacle, but all of these
  1270. 1:37:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker commercial licenses or my understanding is that there is not a separate for the people who are home rules self-collect there isn't
  1271. 1:37:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker really a differentiation in what you pay to get your sales and use tax license, whether you have a curriculum order or you work from home.
  1272. 1:38:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like, I think it's just you get sales and use tax
  1273. 1:38:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker license that done um i know that even if you are a nonprofit but you do sales
  1274. 1:38:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you still have to get sales and use tax license and like a place like Longmont, for example,
  1275. 1:38:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker whereas not profits are exempt for inherit.
  1276. 1:38:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So
  1277. 1:38:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm hoping that that's not like the, I don't know as much about homeox and other places, but I do know for the home roll self collect, it kind of
  1278. 1:38:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker doesn't really matter as is minor standing yeah if you know tell the self-collect they really the sills tax apply elite with their whole offer
  1279. 1:38:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so to them it doesn't matter for us it's more a matter of who do we need to reach out to more who do we need more information about for the self-collecting it's everybody paying the same things that we're talking about the same
  1280. 1:39:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A additional questions.
  1281. 1:39:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just in general or the slide.
  1282. 1:39:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Either.
  1283. 1:39:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But there's
  1284. 1:39:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker there are like a couple more slides.
  1285. 1:39:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No spoilers.
  1286. 1:39:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1287. 1:39:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is sort of the mean potatoes on the whole thing.
  1288. 1:39:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The
  1289. 1:39:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker updated, the code updates that we're talking about here.
  1290. 1:39:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we have some definitional updates because we do have some things that are out of step with
  1291. 1:39:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the state at the moment in our current requirements.
  1292. 1:39:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The key example about is child care businesses.
  1293. 1:39:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We as a town are not allowed to have,
  1294. 1:39:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you've gotten certified to have a home-based daycare from the state, we can't come in until you know.
  1295. 1:39:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's more or less.
  1296. 1:39:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they are exempted from having a business license.
  1297. 1:39:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is not
  1298. 1:39:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker currently written in the code that is one of the updates that under clarify who needs a license that's in there we do need to add short-term rentals not currently
  1299. 1:40:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker reflected in that document, but leads now that that's approved, we are going to exempt short-term rentals from needing a business license as well.
  1300. 1:40:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The short-term rental license will be enough.
  1301. 1:40:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Standardized renewals, there's some changes to the language around how we're going to be renewing
  1302. 1:40:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker by deadlines.
  1303. 1:40:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There is a late renewal process to encourage everybody.
  1304. 1:40:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think, you know, around it was here earlier tonight.
  1305. 1:40:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker She was talking about, you know, you get your business license in October, and then you got to go
  1306. 1:40:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ahead and get another one in January.
  1307. 1:40:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, I agree.
  1308. 1:40:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That is a pain.
  1309. 1:40:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you're already renewed by,
  1310. 1:40:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, end of
  1311. 1:40:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker January,
  1312. 1:40:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you're not getting your business license in October.
  1313. 1:40:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there is some standardization around the window for renewals, which also puts less of
  1314. 1:41:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a burden on staff.
  1315. 1:41:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think moving to that,
  1316. 1:41:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like it's annual based on when you started your business license, puts a lot more burden on our system
  1317. 1:41:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because you might be like June to June, August to August, December to December,
  1318. 1:41:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it works a lot better if we just have this.
  1319. 1:41:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is the window,
  1320. 1:41:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but that's just you know I'm speaking for staff here clarify application requirements that's in there as well
  1321. 1:41:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Establish enforcement procedures.
  1322. 1:41:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think one of the things that we love Erie mentioned was that some of their frustrations, and I've said this to me, is that
  1323. 1:41:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker like, well, I have a business license and I renew it every year.
  1324. 1:41:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Somebody else doesn't.
  1325. 1:41:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nothing happens.
  1326. 1:41:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because right now, we do not have a good process by
  1327. 1:41:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which to do any kind of let's call it incremental enforcement like the option as is my understanding what you're here um
  1328. 1:42:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So my understanding is that at the moment the only way that we can really enforce it is to go through this, like we basically would have to find people over $2,000.
  1329. 1:42:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's like
  1330. 1:42:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the way that that's what's written in the code right now for people who don't like follow this stuff.
  1331. 1:42:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we don't have a method for enforcement is just
  1332. 1:42:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the truth unfortunately.
  1333. 1:42:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we are looking for ways that we can encourage people to renew their license with
  1334. 1:42:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker more of a slap on the risk than OUOS $2,000.
  1335. 1:42:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think that is, that's one of the things we want to
  1336. 1:42:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker talk about because it is really important that people get business licenses because like a lot of the people who don't it's infrequent that we have someone who opens a business doesn't get
  1337. 1:43:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a business license and then also they are going through building department getting all the like sign permits building permits and all the things these things tend to go hand in hand where if you don't have a building permit
  1338. 1:43:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you don't have a business license, you're, you know, you've got 50 things all plugged into one outlined in the wall and you're plastering over your sprinkler system.
  1339. 1:43:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All of those things have happened.
  1340. 1:43:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think from our perspective, we want to encourage people to get business licenses.
  1341. 1:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're doing the best we can with
  1342. 1:43:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker carrots and we just want a real little stick.
  1343. 1:43:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that's where we're at there.
  1344. 1:43:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Same with the revocation procedure instead of just being like Red Tag, your
  1345. 1:43:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker door,
  1346. 1:43:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we can have a little bit of a warning before we get to that point.
  1347. 1:43:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do you have recommendations for those?
  1348. 1:43:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Season to sist.
  1349. 1:43:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes,
  1350. 1:43:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a season to sister no i mean having a small stick if you will or a carrot right are you asking us to make a decision that's important today the stick
  1351. 1:44:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker stick and carrots are already written in there.
  1352. 1:44:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Little sticks, bigger sticks that kind of thing.
  1353. 1:44:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're hoping little will then update the need for the larger
  1354. 1:44:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sticks, but yes, that's what the late renewal period is more of the little stick approach before we get to this season-to-sis business.
  1355. 1:44:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we have some
  1356. 1:44:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker proposed details behind these.
  1357. 1:44:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, so if you guys are okay with all these changes, you'll get back an ordinance that will listen to houses.
  1358. 1:44:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, everybody, I'm the same page before I've got
  1359. 1:44:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to have this this is what the draft is that's the season desist part of it so i mean i should bring a banish
  1360. 1:44:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of having yearly business licenses, right?
  1361. 1:44:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Not only all the benefits that you showed up there, but also turn over, right?
  1362. 1:45:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker People drop off the list, people,
  1363. 1:45:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker new businesses are adding, you can keep the list current if you do it a one-time thing,
  1364. 1:45:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker where if a place went on a business, it would necessarily notify you the enough things to worry about, right?
  1365. 1:45:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you wouldn't even know, but when their renewal comes up and they don't renew, then you know.
  1366. 1:45:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And, you know, especially from a communication standpoint,
  1367. 1:45:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker yeah,
  1368. 1:45:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I see all the advantages there one of the things maybe is maybe the businesses don't understand all the advantages that you guys
  1369. 1:45:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are providing and all the opportunities and information that it provides to you and the town.
  1370. 1:45:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then one of the other things
  1371. 1:45:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was thinking about is like, you know, maybe hire an intern to update the website and put it.
  1372. 1:45:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So when I'm sitting
  1373. 1:45:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker up a happy hour and I'm going to invite people in the area, I go to Yelp or to Google to find, okay, what's a cool place to go to this time?
  1374. 1:46:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if I could go to the Erie website right in head something like that I know it's not a simple thing but in terms of really smartness guess what
  1375. 1:46:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm so happy you mentioned that because three years ago we did have an intern set up exactly what you're saying and we have an Erie business map of all of our license businesses
  1376. 1:46:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and we can actually filter by like professional services, personal services, food and bad bridge, retail.
  1377. 1:46:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we do have that.
  1378. 1:46:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We do haven't linked on our
  1379. 1:46:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker website.
  1380. 1:46:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I can follow up with that.
  1381. 1:46:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker A link to that.
  1382. 1:46:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker If you'd like to take a look at it, we work with GIS.
  1383. 1:46:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we do have that.
  1384. 1:46:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's never going to supersede Google, obviously, but I think it is one of the things that
  1385. 1:46:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're trying to offer as a benefit to our business owners where like you've got this, right?
  1386. 1:46:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker More incentive to get a business license because now, and if you put that on
  1387. 1:47:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our front page, right, as one of the links, you know, local businesses check them out and click them there and they said, I would much rather do that because I want to bring them to Erie, but
  1388. 1:47:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker then just do a Google search.
  1389. 1:47:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's going to give me all this around an area.
  1390. 1:47:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And there has been some discussion in the past of maybe like creating secure codes.
  1391. 1:47:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if you're like on a trail and you could like
  1392. 1:47:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker scan it it would bring it up so now I'm with my family and I'm walking and I don't normally go to Erie but oh look I have the business map and I can filter by these things so we've talked about some of those things for
  1393. 1:47:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sure to put the business map out there a little bit more, but I'm happy to follow up with some information about that in your staff council communications.
  1394. 1:47:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'd like to see that because
  1395. 1:47:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for two years ago I've mentioned putting a QR code on that open space.
  1396. 1:47:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There are the single track board there because a lot of people end the springtime.
  1397. 1:47:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, Blake Ball will come up to Erie from Denver in other areas, ride our trails, and not know anything about our businesses.
  1398. 1:48:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, if people go to tournaments
  1399. 1:48:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at the Irish Community Center and the fields and they want to stay eight afterwards, yeah.
  1400. 1:48:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So they think there's some good opportunities for us to keep growing awareness of that, but we do maintain something like that.
  1401. 1:48:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But
  1402. 1:48:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker yes, I'm happy to follow up.
  1403. 1:48:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that was something when I met with three members of the New Long Spirit that, you know,
  1404. 1:48:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You know, they mentioned their ability just to look up, you know, local businesses.
  1405. 1:48:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think, you know, having the tool like that would be very useful in them.
  1406. 1:48:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think also,
  1407. 1:48:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, and I did get a chance to talk to Ronna, but, you
  1408. 1:48:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've kind of heard that before with the fee and things like that, but I think I remember when we first brought this up and we were trying to make something that wasn't arguous.
  1409. 1:49:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and it's one of these things that I think you know when you get into a profession I think having something where you
  1410. 1:49:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker want it to be meaningful, but you don't want to, I think having it free is probably not the correct thing.
  1411. 1:49:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And I do realize to her point that, yeah, they have a lot of other revenue that they provide the town and we're certainly appreciative of
  1412. 1:49:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that and as you can see early in the presentation we're not collecting a lot of money off this we're not doing this for revenues so yeah but you know
  1413. 1:49:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I like the proposed changes and I think it's probably good to think about four of us.
  1414. 1:49:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One, I just have a flat 25-hour fee.
  1415. 1:49:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, why hit
  1416. 1:49:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the commercial was more,
  1417. 1:50:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker even they're probably generating more sales tax than the homoccupation businesses.
  1418. 1:50:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That was the view that
  1419. 1:50:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker was in place before we reinstated.
  1420. 1:50:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was always prior to 2022 where the fee previously was the $50 flat rate.
  1421. 1:50:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we just reinstated the fee that already been in place.
  1422. 1:50:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it had
  1423. 1:50:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker been a 50 for commercial and 25 for OMOC, but I think as you saw from that Pierre's table, it's a moving target.
  1424. 1:50:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Everybody has a different fee.
  1425. 1:50:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is the number that was established by the trustees previously.
  1426. 1:50:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I agree with Mary and Brotown that, you know,
  1427. 1:50:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker minimize the pain to the business community, but it's very valuable information to have and
  1428. 1:50:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have to be able to get leave the details of the cube but it's popping to my mind first of our second while the renewed by a certain date we'll wait the fee what
  1429. 1:50:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you can use the care of the stick and say we'll wave the vid you've renewed within the first 90 days of the year and otherwise it's 100 dollars that's something i don't have to come back to you but i
  1430. 1:51:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker think it's a full explorer while this is an interesting approach.
  1431. 1:51:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Somehow having a few makes people want to renew more than they should want free.
  1432. 1:51:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that there can be value in here
  1433. 1:51:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because I'd like that there's a home occupation database there and that residents can go and see, hey, look, this business cared enough to get
  1434. 1:51:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the business license and you know that helps legitimize businesses these small businesses where maybe it's
  1435. 1:51:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker not as much on yelp because that can be satellition.
  1436. 1:51:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, that once can be satellite.
  1437. 1:51:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Anyway, but you're spelling there and actually like to see that database expanded upon instead of
  1438. 1:51:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a contact email maybe it's the the business uh website i just mentioned so everyone knows what you're talking about because i didn't mention that so there is a separate we didn't want one of our
  1439. 1:52:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rules in the code is that you can't your homework can't be like yo there's a business here if there can't be anything that's like welcome to my business and we kind of thought putting a
  1440. 1:52:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker pin on the, so we were talking about the map, there is no pins on anyone's home box because we thought that kind of went against the spirit of, you know,
  1441. 1:52:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what we're trying to do with the code of the advertising here is a business in this home.
  1442. 1:52:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we do have separate database for home-based businesses that is
  1443. 1:52:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker your contact information website stuff like that so we do to try to bring some awareness to the homework businesses as well so just so everyone knows that and we
  1444. 1:52:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have the same for our mobile vendors.
  1445. 1:52:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you are a licensed mobile vendor in Erie, some of your food truck and boulder you come here, there is a list of those as well.
  1446. 1:52:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because those
  1447. 1:52:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are businesses that also do business scenarios but yes so just so everyone knows what you're talking about just want to make sure everyone knows that i think it's great i just i think instead of contact information maybe
  1448. 1:53:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker business name website slash phone number and some don't have a website and then maybe like five words or less to describe your business okay
  1449. 1:53:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker yeah we can we can look into that some people are notoriously not good at describing what their business is we've noticed in some of the things i get submitted but we can we can evaluate that
  1450. 1:53:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for sure okay just let me add value to this check because i don't have a problem hang my 25 dollars because now my business is in a database that's on the town's website
  1451. 1:53:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that i don't know if it's a license but it would add value to them they could click on your website and go right to your yeah yeah we can
  1452. 1:53:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker take that underadvisement for sure.
  1453. 1:53:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So speaking of sticks,
  1454. 1:53:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker how big of a stick is a season desist with a
  1455. 1:54:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker five-day window.
  1456. 1:54:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just simply tells them that they're not authorized to business in the town at that point.
  1457. 1:54:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then what happens after that?
  1458. 1:54:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We would then draft
  1459. 1:54:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker complaint and induce an enforcement, so some one would read a ticket and it gets cited where they get cited or having an internal conversation about whether that would be appropriate for a hearing
  1460. 1:54:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker officer or for a municipal judge.
  1461. 1:54:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the five days is to me is kind of short, which is someone's out of town.
  1462. 1:54:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What if, you know, I don't know.
  1463. 1:54:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know.
  1464. 1:54:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know.
  1465. 1:54:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker conversation.
  1466. 1:54:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's a, you know, I know the local business owner who's gone away for 30 days.
  1467. 1:54:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, you know,
  1468. 1:54:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that seems to be a really short window.
  1469. 1:54:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not based on anything.
  1470. 1:54:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, is that like a standard in these values or more understanding as the language was as
  1471. 1:54:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker drafted was pretty standard and we did do it in conversation with our code officers.
  1472. 1:55:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think should
  1473. 1:55:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker be clear.
  1474. 1:55:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's pretty rare that we have a brick and mortar business open without a business license.
  1475. 1:55:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not unheard
  1476. 1:55:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of, but it's not very common.
  1477. 1:55:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then most people, once that does happen, and we go to them, they're like, oops, and then it right away.
  1478. 1:55:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But this year we did have someone who said oops, but then things
  1479. 1:55:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker did not progress in a meaningful way and there were additional issues from a building permit situation and you
  1480. 1:55:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and you know some of these businesses you can go at any time of the day like we could go and make a visit and it's like it's closed like almost the entire time that we're at work and so like we can't really come here at
  1481. 1:56:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nice.
  1482. 1:56:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Six, I haven't been like, yo.
  1483. 1:56:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, like, we were having a really tough time reaching out to this person.
  1484. 1:56:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was phone calls.
  1485. 1:56:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was emails.
  1486. 1:56:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was, like, I know somebody who knows this
  1487. 1:56:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker person, so I could talk to them to talk to this person to try to get connected.
  1488. 1:56:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it's just like, it was not working.
  1489. 1:56:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think we were at a spot where there was a lot
  1490. 1:56:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of internal anxiety around like there are people this is an business that's open for business and they don't have a business license but they're aware they need one um
  1491. 1:56:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think it's so rare that this even come.
  1492. 1:56:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is the first time it's happened.
  1493. 1:56:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The entire time that I've been here that we have somebody who opens for business discovers they
  1494. 1:56:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker need a business license and then the steps just are not happening so i mean you can have conversation about the five days but i think from our perspective
  1495. 1:56:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's like it's such a it's so rare that this would be implemented that I think for us we don't think it's too crazy but yeah so
  1496. 1:57:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just want to make it clear that this isn't, we're not like, oh, here's our hit list of like 50 ERI businesses and we're going to go like with our sticks and smash up the windows or something.
  1497. 1:57:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know.
  1498. 1:57:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's like, it's not how we do things.
  1499. 1:57:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So here's what a friend told me with right now.
  1500. 1:57:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Across Colorado's front range, a business license or registration typically inters full administrator
  1501. 1:57:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker default, the link would see or permanent revocation within 30 to 90 days, averaging 60 days after failing to pay the renewal fee as of the expiration date.
  1502. 1:57:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then it goes in to share some of the municipalities, Denver,
  1503. 1:57:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker 1 to 30 days, 20% panel BP, Days 31 to 90, 50%.
  1504. 1:57:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's definitely stuff out there that appears to be less stringent than the five things that maybe it would be good for you guys to look at.
  1505. 1:58:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are the what are the penalties leading up to that is it double the fees so we have okay we have that we don't have a fee schedule that dictates the
  1506. 1:58:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker fee yet so we don't have that information but i think the way it's currently written you have from December until end of February
  1507. 1:58:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to renew at $50.
  1508. 1:58:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then after that, there is an incremental, like you can ding with a little bit of a fine.
  1509. 1:58:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then after that,
  1510. 1:58:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because to my mind the thing that you've got highlighted there is a little bit more about having no
  1511. 1:58:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker business license at all do not so much renewal that fails to go through but i think those are things that would come out in the wash a little bit without we do enforcement but
  1512. 1:58:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our major concerns people who never get a business license they open to the public they have no business license we have no means of real communication with them in terms of renewals
  1513. 1:59:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a lane fee,
  1514. 1:59:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that's pretty much the, but obviously we don't want the lane fees to get so big that then it's like, I don't want to, I'm not going to pay it.
  1515. 1:59:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like, I'll just wait in
  1516. 1:59:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker another year and then because I think the idea that we had originally considered was like the largest the fee ever gets is another 50
  1517. 1:59:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker so you owe 100 and if you don't renew for the whole year then you renew against that again the next year you're paying like 150 for the coming year
  1518. 1:59:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and the past year so that was like that that i think we felt like that was the most we wanted it to ever be um and not have it be like
  1519. 1:59:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I used to work in a library and we had a thing about ladies.
  1520. 1:59:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You never want your ladies to get so high that people stuff using libraries.
  1521. 2:00:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So that is like the same, I want to take that same approach
  1522. 2:00:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with this.
  1523. 2:00:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We don't want the ladies to ever get so much that people are like, forget it.
  1524. 2:00:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So like that over $2,000 thing.
  1525. 2:00:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's generated anywhere else.
  1526. 2:00:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, that's not really.
  1527. 2:00:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, exactly.
  1528. 2:00:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, exactly.
  1529. 2:00:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think to our mind, it was like the most the lace he would ever be was another $50, but that would come back to you all because we don't have
  1530. 2:00:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it in the fee schedule at this point.
  1531. 2:00:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we were sort of trying to set the pins up so that we could bring something to you in a fee schedule that we could all agree on.
  1532. 2:00:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We took comfortable with.
  1533. 2:00:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But that was like, again, more of the little stick approach of like, there's a little bit of a thing.
  1534. 2:00:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's some incentive for you to move forward
  1535. 2:00:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with renewing your business license sooner rather than later so that you don't end up in a situation where you're like, so like, for example, if you want a grant or an incentive from us and your business license is out of date, you
  1536. 2:01:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have to renew your business license so it seems reasonable so they let's say i'm applying for i'm doing a major renovation project in my business and
  1537. 2:01:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's starting in September.
  1538. 2:01:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So then I apply to Julian and myself and say I want an incentive to cover part of what this investment I'm making in my business.
  1539. 2:01:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We say,
  1540. 2:01:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker great now you need a business license okay so now it's like almost October and I'm applying for my business license that's going to cover me for a few months to run this point earlier and then I'm
  1541. 2:01:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker gonna have to apply again in January like I think we want to avoid that because yeah I get the frustration of like I just renewed this and I have to renew it again so if there was
  1542. 2:01:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker something in place that i've already got my business license now i can go ahead and apply for this there's no my grant process is much more seamless because
  1543. 2:01:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that goes for all of our grants our destruction mitigation grant all that stuff you have to have your business license for any of those opportunities and it is frustrating to be like okay when you renew first thank you
  1544. 2:02:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Same with anybody who wants to do a revocable license agreement.
  1545. 2:02:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They've got seating out front.
  1546. 2:02:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They need a revisense for that too.
  1547. 2:02:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Any agreement we have dreamed to with a business, those people have to
  1548. 2:02:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have a business license.
  1549. 2:02:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you just have it all nice and renewed right at the beginning of the year, it just makes it just a much more frictionless
  1550. 2:02:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker process for anything you might want to do with the town going forward at that point for people that have already registered for the first time and they just
  1551. 2:02:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker need a renewal do we have like an auto pay thing or something where it would just it goes out and yeah it provides you with an uh like hey can you it's time to renew we have instructions
  1552. 2:02:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker um it's but there is a manual there crosses there yeah it's because of the specific software okay it's not too hard
  1553. 2:03:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, I mean, it's more, it's more being the notice of making sure because I think one year I didn't get noticed.
  1554. 2:03:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, yeah, yeah, it's like, oh, this thing's expired.
  1555. 2:03:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, yeah.
  1556. 2:03:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and some people have more trouble than others computer literacy varies wildly from person a person so smiley does offer a lot of support services she has office hours
  1557. 2:03:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker two days a week every week all the time so you can come to town hall if you're just like i can't and sometimes she will do um she's sometimes done it almost all
  1558. 2:03:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker herself and printed it and given it to the person and everything sometimes you know it's a phone call sometimes she's doing it over email but like she's always available she's very
  1559. 2:03:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker helpful and she's worked tirelessly to try to make the instructions as simple and comprehensible as they possibly can be and if they're still not she's there you
  1560. 2:03:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker can just walk in the town hall during her office hours and she'll help you.
  1561. 2:04:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to pull this back around just so much in the time we have one more.
  1562. 2:04:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sorry.
  1563. 2:04:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No, no
  1564. 2:04:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker good information.
  1565. 2:04:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just want to see if there's any last urgent questions.
  1566. 2:04:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Councilmember Bear, make sure you have a chance to chime in.
  1567. 2:04:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  1568. 2:04:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just listening to the conversation, I just
  1569. 2:04:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker kind of was curious that there's a reason that you've identified maybe there's a barrier that's keeping people from renewing.
  1570. 2:04:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I actually happened to be at Town Hall one time when
  1571. 2:04:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Shamayo was helping someone and yeah she's amazing she does everything short of pushing the buttons but i mean i just i'm wondering if there's a
  1572. 2:04:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker problem to solve or if it really was just a matter of people just need to like read an email and you're like, oh yeah, I need to do that thing later and you just forget and forget and forget or is
  1573. 2:04:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they're barrier i mean i think to remind everyone it is an 87.5 percent renewal rate so i think we're doing pretty good like we're talking about
  1574. 2:05:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a very small number of people who aren't renewing and we're up 17.5% from last year i was just looking at those numbers earlier before i came into this meeting so i think
  1575. 2:05:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker one of the issues is that we did just make a switch to this new, I mean that was only what 2024, halfway through 2024, we made a switch to this new system.
  1576. 2:05:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I
  1577. 2:05:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker think that frustrate people don't want new things with this kind of stuff they want to get used to clicking about and doing things the way that they've always done them and now we've got this system
  1578. 2:05:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not changing for the foreseeable future, hopefully, that we can see.
  1579. 2:05:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I honestly think Council Person Bear, I think we're in a spot where it's like every year I think we're going to see
  1580. 2:05:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker incremental improvement.
  1581. 2:05:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think there's always going to be a few Mavericks who are like, I don't need to renew.
  1582. 2:05:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But I think for the most part, I actually think we're doing really well.
  1583. 2:05:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Without
  1584. 2:05:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker renewal, it's not a big deal.
  1585. 2:05:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's what I'm here and you're saying.
  1586. 2:05:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Your renewal rate is high and I feel good.
  1587. 2:06:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You deal with the exceptions as you need to.
  1588. 2:06:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1589. 2:06:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And our goal
  1590. 2:06:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with code amendments, it's on the slide, is to kind of modernize and streamline the administrative process, but the renewal process as well, just some updates that are needed to occur.
  1591. 2:06:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I had a couple of those thoughts.
  1592. 2:06:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So contractors,
  1593. 2:06:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker daycare and STRs don't need a business license.
  1594. 2:06:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Would it be helpful if
  1595. 2:06:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they were automatically issued a business license based on on the fees they already take like a gentle contract general contractor
  1596. 2:06:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ABC, they all paid $107500,
  1597. 2:06:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker would it be helpful to automatically issue them a business license so that all that information is put in the same database?
  1598. 2:06:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know I think I'm not sure the answer on this one I know that some of it is like they're they fall into this weird place where like some of them are like I'm based in Lafayette
  1599. 2:07:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So then, like, if you have a Lafayette base business, you don't need a nearly business license right.
  1600. 2:07:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So then, there's this weird, like, okay, but then they do, but then these guys don't.
  1601. 2:07:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Like,
  1602. 2:07:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just as a pain, that's very complicated.
  1603. 2:07:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thanks.
  1604. 2:07:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're kind of like,
  1605. 2:07:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the building department handles that with the contractors licenses.
  1606. 2:07:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cool.
  1607. 2:07:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I think we feel good about that being like, they got that.
  1608. 2:07:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the child care businesses is a little bit of a we talked about doing a similar thing where we just have a list on a website they go through the town clerk's office just like hey we
  1609. 2:07:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker exist this is real so that people can double check so they're not sending it a kid somewhere crazy um so we have that same as mobile fending um and
  1610. 2:07:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker then we kind of did for that one i feel like we're just kind of like the states got it because we don't want to issue a business license in violation of our own homoc
  1611. 2:07:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker homeock rules if that makes sense.
  1612. 2:08:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just was thinking back to reaping it or reach out to these businesses that a lot of them like a lot of the contractors
  1613. 2:08:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are in Erie,
  1614. 2:08:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker live in Erie, have homes in Erie.
  1615. 2:08:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But, okay, Marney, sorry.
  1616. 2:08:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No, we've got.
  1617. 2:08:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I was just going to say they're exempted from requiring license.
  1618. 2:08:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're not prohibited from
  1619. 2:08:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker having one.
  1620. 2:08:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we've experienced it with like credit unions.
  1621. 2:08:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We learned this year credit unions are not profit.
  1622. 2:08:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're bank, but as a credit union, they are not profit.
  1623. 2:08:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They are not required to have a business
  1624. 2:08:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker license we still think there's value to credit news to having one so that we know who they are who runs the business we can interact with them they can be at our newsletter etc so we still make it available to them when they
  1625. 2:08:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker do open to have one, but our code says they're not required to.
  1626. 2:08:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there is value, but it's nothing we can just saw in Mackley say, and here's your license.
  1627. 2:08:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They have to apply for it.
  1628. 2:08:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1629. 2:08:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think we'd have to have a larger conversation about the childcare businesses, but I can also, we can also follow up on those ideas with you.
  1630. 2:09:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sure.
  1631. 2:09:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's just if
  1632. 2:09:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you're creating this database yeah try to make it as repository possible it's not as possible um and one other thought this is a council consideration is do we just go to a flat
  1633. 2:09:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker $25 fee for everybody?
  1634. 2:09:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Be more in alignment with the other surrounding communities than us to that currently.
  1635. 2:09:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know the problem with
  1636. 2:09:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker do the $25 a few across, but it's not like we're generating enough money to even pay for the program.
  1637. 2:09:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know there hasn't been behind where how it got to Phyllis
  1638. 2:09:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the first Julian said it was that way before we just reinstated it.
  1639. 2:09:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it wasn't like we didn't put it to make it a flash scene.
  1640. 2:09:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm going to have a problem with that.
  1641. 2:09:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, I mean, like I said,
  1642. 2:09:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the purpose is to get people registered and it's not to generate row new or make it burdensome.
  1643. 2:09:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And if you make it zero dollars, somebody said
  1644. 2:09:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it earlier yeah some people won't actually do it right yeah it doesn't be serious yeah it's a zero dollar she must be no value that's right we intended to show that it does have value yeah it's something that
  1645. 2:10:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you have to pay for to obtain and it does partially compensate us for the administrative costs okay that's it well so i guess on that point would going down to 25 with
  1646. 2:10:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that maybe if they're not so stationed you would reduce the revenue okay um it's nothing that goes to our budget it's just to the general fund but it would reduce the income the town
  1647. 2:10:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker receives okay and there's no writer in there to increase it with cost to living or anything i don't know i'm okay leaving it a 50 as well
  1648. 2:10:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have a look to your guys' recommendation.
  1649. 2:10:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Currently it's in the fee schedule, so it's nothing that's cautified.
  1650. 2:10:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The fee schedule establishes $50 for commercial and $25
  1651. 2:10:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for homeaux.
  1652. 2:10:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So every year you all reset that, whatever that number might be.
  1653. 2:10:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So in next month, you'll see whatever this year's number will be.
  1654. 2:11:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if there's a desire to change it, that's the time to do it as Adria Fee
  1655. 2:11:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker schedule up here all right thank you thank you yeah a lot of good information all right you got to ask if
  1656. 2:11:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You could spend on my mind.
  1657. 2:11:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I have three rentals encountered all in an LLC.
  1658. 2:11:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Should I have a business license for that?
  1659. 2:11:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, great.
  1660. 2:11:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay,
  1661. 2:11:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll slide that.
  1662. 2:11:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Here's violating a lot.
  1663. 2:11:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We need a recall.
  1664. 2:11:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We need a recall.
  1665. 2:11:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker some meaning they're generating a profit for some service.
  1666. 2:11:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, that's the trader for a business license because you're engaged in business.
  1667. 2:11:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1668. 2:11:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And based off the code definition, engagement business is long-term
  1669. 2:12:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rental.
  1670. 2:12:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You are receiving payment for your rental.
  1671. 2:12:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So you're engaged in business.
  1672. 2:12:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure.
  1673. 2:12:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That triggers a license.
  1674. 2:12:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure.
  1675. 2:12:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure-term rental.
  1676. 2:12:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Those are now receiving revenue in return for offering
  1677. 2:12:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker your own for short-term accommodations and supplies so our intent is to in the code amendment exempt rentals you're not a business operator you're receiving rental income in return
  1678. 2:12:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for providing a service but it's not a business so you can exempt all rentals you're just short term rentals we'll work with Ellie and bring it on that one the intent to short term rentals
  1679. 2:12:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but I know there's a file on between long term and short term.
  1680. 2:12:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Still in discussion.
  1681. 2:12:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1682. 2:12:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Rob, do it.
  1683. 2:12:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It just never thought about it.
  1684. 2:12:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Same.
  1685. 2:12:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have one, and I don't want to have one.
  1686. 2:12:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh, there you go.
  1687. 2:12:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1688. 2:12:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's a path or two.
  1689. 2:12:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You know what I mean?
  1690. 2:12:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, I mean, I mean, it's just now confession.
  1691. 2:12:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we run the town.
  1692. 2:12:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is the cheapest and listening area for a little.
  1693. 2:13:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, we're moving over our next topic, which is a discussion direction on the visions to the
  1694. 2:13:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker economic incentives policy.
  1695. 2:13:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Jay, thank you, Emily.
  1696. 2:13:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You're taking this one.
  1697. 2:13:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just by way of introduction, my name is Ellie Fam, the new business development manager on the acronym
  1698. 2:13:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker economic development team charged with all things, business subtraction.
  1699. 2:13:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Our incentive policy is one of the tools that we use in order to realize that goal.
  1700. 2:13:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some of
  1701. 2:13:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker those subsidiary goals are also increased commercial inventory we know we have shortage in town and also generate more sales tax revenue here to talk to you today about
  1702. 2:13:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the revisions in order to accomplish all of those goals.
  1703. 2:13:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we wanted to first cover the background and the incentive policy history go over a proposed incentive
  1704. 2:13:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for policy revisions,
  1705. 2:13:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker underlying the incentive programs and examples of what good prospects and applicants would be going to
  1706. 2:14:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker discussion my steps so we are aware that we recently came to you to a prumer incentives policy and we are coming back to you in a fairly short order with
  1707. 2:14:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker revisions.
  1708. 2:14:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's paralyzed with the year and a half of experience for that sort of applications we've received.
  1709. 2:14:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've noticed some limitations in our existing policy, partly that it's
  1710. 2:14:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lack of clarity from all the health staff about what a good referral for program would be and for developers and business owners.
  1711. 2:14:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's a lack of clarity about what the benefit could be
  1712. 2:14:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for them.
  1713. 2:14:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's not clear enough time to engage in this process.
  1714. 2:14:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But our initial policy that we brought forward to you was intentionally flexible
  1715. 2:14:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker because we wanted to see and have a really progress specific non-formulic approach to our business incentives.
  1716. 2:14:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Another helpful
  1717. 2:14:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker context for you all is that a lot of the businesses and developers we work with are major state level programs to of which are geographic boundary programs that are present in an opportunity
  1718. 2:15:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker zone that are based on economic distress, that ERI does not meet the criteria for.
  1719. 2:15:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we automatically do not have any programs to offer to them when they come to us seeking interest
  1720. 2:15:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the town and also are going to the down selection process of choosing us versus one of our surrounding lookouts.
  1721. 2:15:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we also have not know what limited near terminology
  1722. 2:15:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to qualify for another state level program that's not based on distrust but it's primarily centered on primary job creation we're predominantly staying a lot of retail businesses operating in
  1723. 2:15:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker our town so they do not qualify for that program and that's the job growth incentive tax credits so with our proposed incentive policy revision we want to
  1724. 2:15:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker update from more distinct categories to for specific programs and what we see those as enabling is giving transparency to both the applicant
  1725. 2:16:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the town staff, and also council for whatever we would bring forward an agreement that they've met these certain eligibility criteria.
  1726. 2:16:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker they've been evaluated on the criteria we have established.
  1727. 2:16:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Literally, and our values are criteria,
  1728. 2:16:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what kind of incentive they would be eligible
  1729. 2:16:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for or they would receive and it is to see the performance requirements that we would have in their agreement.
  1730. 2:16:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we wanted to do a side-by-side of
  1731. 2:16:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what the current policy is, what the proposed policy is, it's used in the red line that we've attached to this study session, red line document that we've attached to this study session as well, and it goes over a lot
  1732. 2:16:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of what I've covered already.
  1733. 2:16:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And this page is really cheat sheet for those four programs.
  1734. 2:16:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's the retail attraction sales tax rebate, the business investment
  1735. 2:16:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker cash grant, the first location permit fee rebate and the gap financing incentive.
  1736. 2:17:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This outlines what the projected cash benefit of each program would be and what the purpose of
  1737. 2:17:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker each program would be and that's what we're going to get into more detail and on the following slides so for the retail attraction sales tax debate we wanted to have a program that was going
  1738. 2:17:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to be automatically digestible for the businesses that we were going out trying to recruit.
  1739. 2:17:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we've seen this with some of our surrounding pierces as well.
  1740. 2:17:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it would be a 50%
  1741. 2:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sales tax rate for the first five years of operation up to an agreed-upon threshold.
  1742. 2:17:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that would be the project and sales tax to the anticipate generating based on their other location and based on the costs that
  1743. 2:17:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're able to pull from existing business designering.
  1744. 2:17:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That would be sort of reasonable establish what we expect them to be able to collect.
  1745. 2:17:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The eligibility for this
  1746. 2:17:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker program would be new, retail or food business, food and beverage establishments.
  1747. 2:17:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But that is new to ERI or new location in ERI.
  1748. 2:18:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We want to see business operators with
  1749. 2:18:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a proof of business concept and business operating track record.
  1750. 2:18:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We also wanted to bring in some thresholds so
  1751. 2:18:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we want to have a high administration administrator burden of entering into agreements for relatively smaller sales tax generating opportunities so
  1752. 2:18:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that's where we have a $10,000 annual sales tax generation to the town as an eligibility criteria and it also that it's a competitive site selection process in that they're
  1753. 2:18:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker considering other municipalities for this for their next store um so that's all to say for any application you receive should these
  1754. 2:18:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker revisions be accepted and we would be coming to you for agreement you should rest assured knowing we've already screened them for these solidarity critiques we're just trying to make this very
  1755. 2:18:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker very clear and get more comfort from both parties moving forward.
  1756. 2:19:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker However, moving forward to the evaluation criteria, this is where you have a little
  1757. 2:19:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker bit more discernment.
  1758. 2:19:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So for us, we really want to see businesses that are activating priority retail node.
  1759. 2:19:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're defining that as old-touniering, eerie town center, eerie comments,
  1760. 2:19:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker talents, and the storage.
  1761. 2:19:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm generating significant sales tax,
  1762. 2:19:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which we've even established at 2% for purposes of this revision.
  1763. 2:19:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'd just speak to our finance development.
  1764. 2:19:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We had an estimated 15.5 million annual non-vitical non-internet sales tax generation for 2025, so that would be any
  1765. 2:19:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker singular business generating over 300,000 in sales tax for the town at an annual basis so that would be something that we would like to see but it we do have the flexibility
  1766. 2:19:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to give this program to old-owned restaurant opportunities that are not generating as much as long as they're above $10,000.
  1767. 2:20:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're trying to be creative and flexible,
  1768. 2:20:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker even within a more programmatic framework.
  1769. 2:20:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that 2% at odds with the $10,000.
  1770. 2:20:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Well, the $10,000 is just that you
  1771. 2:20:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are not eligible if you are only generating $5,000.
  1772. 2:20:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But if you are generating more than $300,000, that's a really strong positive evaluation
  1773. 2:20:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker criteria for us to consider.
  1774. 2:20:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Why is safely conflicts not included in this?
  1775. 2:20:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because
  1776. 2:20:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker mostly because that's built out one thing that we're trying to do here is have net new sales tax generation so a lot of these
  1777. 2:20:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker commercial destinations haven't been developed for state four other counties that do
  1778. 2:20:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker have sales tax rebates for established locations, they have to set a threshold.
  1779. 2:21:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So for,
  1780. 2:21:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm just going to have the most syndic sample vostle.
  1781. 2:21:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it'd be like, okay, safer if to leave, the new business that would have to come in, they would have to have net new sales tax
  1782. 2:21:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker generated above what sales safeguard has already been generating for the tax and that's just sort of like in established threshold for a lot of these programs.
  1783. 2:21:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It varies a little different because
  1784. 2:21:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we want to bring this new inventory online.
  1785. 2:21:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it would all be nettled.
  1786. 2:21:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And Julie might know this answer.
  1787. 2:21:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's available pads there.
  1788. 2:21:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's one.
  1789. 2:21:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're flying.
  1790. 2:21:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it's currently going through life.
  1791. 2:21:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that true?
  1792. 2:21:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Oh.
  1793. 2:21:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is that for a car wash?
  1794. 2:21:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's not good.
  1795. 2:21:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I can confirm what do I do.
  1796. 2:21:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  1797. 2:21:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, there's not fireworks, right?
  1798. 2:21:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And this is still part of the evaluation criteria, it's not eligibility, so we evaluated when applications come in.
  1799. 2:22:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1800. 2:22:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, sorry, just falling up on that point there, I guess.
  1801. 2:22:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Because we have such a low vacancy rate.
  1802. 2:22:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's something does open up.
  1803. 2:22:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we're not counting that as net new.
  1804. 2:22:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean,
  1805. 2:22:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think at least
  1806. 2:22:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker point, retreating it as enhanced sales tax.
  1807. 2:22:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So good.
  1808. 2:22:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Quantum, how much in sales tax rebate is available is using the amount above the base level.
  1809. 2:22:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if there was already an existing operator in their generous
  1810. 2:22:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a certain amount of sales tax.
  1811. 2:22:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We're only considering the amount eligible for rebate above that base level.
  1812. 2:22:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1813. 2:22:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So ideally, sure, whoever comes in is generating more in sales tax and we can use that percentage for the
  1814. 2:22:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker rebate, reflecting whomever might not be in that space anymore.
  1815. 2:22:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, okay.
  1816. 2:22:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So it's a program one.
  1817. 2:22:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Our second program
  1818. 2:23:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is a stepping-given ice little preview is our way of supporting local business growth, sort of two different more discretionary programs,
  1819. 2:23:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The Business Investment Cash Grant is an opportunity to reimburse brick and mortar, airy, locally owned, airy-based stores that want to
  1820. 2:23:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker generate new sales tax revenue and are making a qualifying business investment in order to do so.
  1821. 2:23:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So whether that's to improve their product, increase their foot
  1822. 2:23:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker traffic or may realize efficiencies this is some of the evaluation criteria that we're looking for we see that being a reimbursement up to $20,000 for
  1823. 2:23:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker business.
  1824. 2:23:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That would also be up to $20,000 along with whatever the business investment total is and capping that at $60,000 annually and
  1825. 2:23:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker what we're looking at in terms of an evaluation standpoint is it has been revenue growth their business performance in years of operation okay
  1826. 2:24:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I can't say one thing on that quickly.
  1827. 2:24:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One thing we've heard from some businesses and stuff will mention this as well.
  1828. 2:24:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have very localized programs and certain parts of town.
  1829. 2:24:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Some incentive partners we have are only offered through the URA and are not available townwide.
  1830. 2:24:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is one example of those.
  1831. 2:24:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In downtown where we sit today, we have the historical town URA that funds
  1832. 2:24:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the downtown revitalization incentive grant program,
  1833. 2:24:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which we fund every year through the URA's budget.
  1834. 2:24:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker There's $100,000 available annually to businesses that want to invest in their exterior
  1835. 2:24:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker facade improvements, invest in expanding their business or adding new business and new available space downtown.
  1836. 2:24:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It has very set criteria for eligibility based off the budget
  1837. 2:24:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that we review annually, but it's only available in Old Town.
  1838. 2:24:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we've heard from businesses elsewhere throughout the rest of town.
  1839. 2:24:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hey, that sounds great.
  1840. 2:24:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I would like that too.
  1841. 2:24:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This business investment cash
  1842. 2:25:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker train closely mirrors that structure so that we can offer a similar up to $20,000 per business grant for businesses investing in eligible improvements.
  1843. 2:25:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So good old town, kind of
  1844. 2:25:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker double dip both the ERA and this?
  1845. 2:25:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So one thing that I, is not on this slide, we didn't want to be too worried, but it is an eligibility criteria
  1846. 2:25:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the forbidden policy one you have to have active business license and then two you have to not receive the cash grid from the town within the last five years because we are really trying to spread the wealth here with
  1847. 2:25:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this program.
  1848. 2:25:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Is there any restriction on what they can use at 20,000?
  1849. 2:25:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Or does it improve primarily to improve landscaping the aesthetics
  1850. 2:25:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are,
  1851. 2:25:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker could they use it for anything?
  1852. 2:25:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What we're really targeting is something that will enable them to generate more sale size revenue.
  1853. 2:25:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if
  1854. 2:25:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker bullet is barrier to them,
  1855. 2:26:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that could potentially be an avenue for them, but what we're not trying to do is support
  1856. 2:26:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker general operating status group.
  1857. 2:26:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, relatively, the first location permit fee rebate is for home-based
  1858. 2:26:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses that are looking to move into the first locations.
  1859. 2:26:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the eligibility criteria for them.
  1860. 2:26:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They have an active business license and then they also have a letter of intent for
  1861. 2:26:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker their first physical storefront.
  1862. 2:26:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And what we're able to incentivize the reimbursement of up-to-fact signals for eligible,
  1863. 2:26:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the current fees and we want to capt this program at $20,000 available anyway the similar evaluation criteria is a history planning
  1864. 2:26:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker experience working with our department because we know there's a few new business operators and the performance requirements for both for both will be pretty standard open
  1865. 2:27:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and operating client but town right yellowishes and for the business investment cash grid in the former reimagine
  1866. 2:27:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So no questions on these two programs moving on to the final program which is the gap financing incentive which will be the most familiar.
  1867. 2:27:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It mirrors a lot of the agreements that we brought to you through the URA and the existing language of the existing policy must closely.
  1868. 2:27:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And
  1869. 2:27:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this is really explicitly to encourage the development of commercial inventory so this is less based on businesses like the first three programs are
  1870. 2:27:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and more based more targeted towards development firms.
  1871. 2:27:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The incentival amount will be the validated financial gap of the project, but it would never
  1872. 2:27:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker exceed a projected town fees or taxes collected over the term of the agreement so you know shouldn't have a project have a million dollar need and they're only generating 500,000 dollars
  1873. 2:28:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker moving forward with the $1 million.
  1874. 2:28:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the eligibility is new commercial inventory, excluding multi-family,
  1875. 2:28:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and then they had the demonstrated financial gap.
  1876. 2:28:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One additional change to the existing policy we wanted to make.
  1877. 2:28:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We always conducted party analysis right
  1878. 2:28:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker now that consultation fee comes out of our department budget we want to have applicants that are seeking more than $250,000 incentive money to pay a
  1879. 2:28:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker $10,000 fee to conduct that third party analysis,
  1880. 2:28:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but it is just another guard rail to leave you all rest assured that
  1881. 2:28:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we've done our financial due diligence for each project.
  1882. 2:28:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We bring to you.
  1883. 2:28:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then our evaluation will be based on the overall project finances and the validated financing need.
  1884. 2:29:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Fiscal
  1885. 2:29:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker impact, capital investment, community infrastructure, but community and infrastructure benefits and alignment with the town development priorities.
  1886. 2:29:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And also on that one, the $10,000 application feed mirrors what we already
  1887. 2:29:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker do with the Metro District applications.
  1888. 2:29:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker When we receive an application for a service plan for Metro District, we have to outsource the financial review to a third party.
  1889. 2:29:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In that service District policy, there's a
  1890. 2:29:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker similar $10,000 fee to cover that financial review.
  1891. 2:29:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we want to mirror that here currently.
  1892. 2:29:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Those gaps today is just coming out of our budget.
  1893. 2:29:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This allows us to offset that cost.
  1894. 2:29:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's slightly
  1895. 2:29:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker differently from the other programs for performance requirements, we want to make sure in every agreement, it's having a certificate of occupancy issued and
  1896. 2:29:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and whatever our defined percentage of commercial space leads.
  1897. 2:29:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, it's a certainty on the town's perspective that none of this money will be collected by
  1898. 2:29:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the firm until the project is delivered as described.
  1899. 2:30:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And from what we've done in the past, I'm like the RA, as soon as I'll also be time commitments with those performance
  1900. 2:30:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker measures club acts whatever it looks like yeah this is just where ura is not available and remark just talking about rebates of town sales tax town property tax not urea related
  1901. 2:30:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker benefit.
  1902. 2:30:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This offers the same tool just without the same toolbox.
  1903. 2:30:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1904. 2:30:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So can you give an example of something that would be eligible
  1905. 2:30:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for this, they get finance.
  1906. 2:30:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And you said it's for areas that are not included in a URI.
  1907. 2:30:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure.
  1908. 2:30:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's sort of what we were hoping to illustrate with
  1909. 2:30:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this following slide.
  1910. 2:30:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You know, so you give to give you all a sense of who we would consider an attractive, illegible, candidate for an
  1911. 2:30:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker incentive versus not meaning illegibility criteria or maybe not following some of the evaluation criteria leading our evaluation
  1912. 2:31:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker thrush holes as we define them.
  1913. 2:31:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I have much longer examples that Julian took out of the presentation in order to save some time, but I think for gap
  1914. 2:31:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker financing incentive this could be the county line road and banill avenue parcel that's not in a URI but is facing the same financing
  1915. 2:31:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker challenges that you've seen in some of the URA projects that you've, URA agreements that you've agreed.
  1916. 2:31:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's the end of sports complex.
  1917. 2:31:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's where that's at.
  1918. 2:31:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's kind of what we're seeing in the financial sector.
  1919. 2:31:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1920. 2:31:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It just has an example.
  1921. 2:31:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Sure.
  1922. 2:31:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For ones that are not in an existing URL.
  1923. 2:31:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  1924. 2:31:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And you might
  1925. 2:31:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker be saying another one coming even a couple months too not that one minute if you want so commercial we can see we don't have much inventory but we have a
  1926. 2:31:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker very solid project so today you plan on increasing the available locations right checkout so this
  1927. 2:32:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is our way of one world sort of constantly in contact with development firms and we're sharing things about our community that would begin and establish an attractive
  1928. 2:32:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker place to do a development from the ground up.
  1929. 2:32:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker From their perspective, they also need to make sure that they secure tenants.
  1930. 2:32:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we are also playing matchbaker with them.
  1931. 2:32:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But depending on the development that goes through, there can be a requirement for nationally credited tenets that
  1932. 2:32:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we are going through a separate approach to attractive areas.
  1933. 2:32:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there needs to be all
  1934. 2:32:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of these pieces that come into place at the right time, but we also want to be sensitive to bringing the type of retail that we know Erie residents want as well.
  1935. 2:33:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this is
  1936. 2:33:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker just a tool for those development partners that you know are open to us bringing our maybe local young businesses but you know are not seeing that they're
  1937. 2:33:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker able to charge a market rent board at private financing henceforth.
  1938. 2:33:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Maybe agreeing the gap that we've sort of already alluded
  1939. 2:33:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to through this program that you're familiar with in overcoming it.
  1940. 2:33:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, our commercial currency right right now is about 2%,
  1941. 2:33:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which means we're 90% occupied.
  1942. 2:33:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We would like to have more space available without businesses closing.
  1943. 2:33:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So then we're going to fix that formula as add more space.
  1944. 2:33:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I've been on a lot of panels, been through a lot of meetings whereby people
  1945. 2:33:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the development world, the commercial real estate world these days, are saying out of every 10 new commercial development deals, 9 required incentive.
  1946. 2:33:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This tool helps us get there.
  1947. 2:33:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We need that
  1948. 2:34:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker more space, but to add more affordable available retail space typically requires some type of assistance and this gap program gets us there.
  1949. 2:34:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It should also help us attract
  1950. 2:34:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the businesses that we want, right?
  1951. 2:34:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Not just the big boxer or correction that don't need incentives, right?
  1952. 2:34:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And what we have some businesses that have been
  1953. 2:34:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker in the queue in the pipeline for a couple of years that have been going through entitlements, their own financing, conversations, et cetera, that times change, terms change, cost change over the last couple of
  1954. 2:34:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker years.
  1955. 2:34:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, we've seen at first hand just whether it's the impact of the economy and the global economy versus localized issues and impact fees, impact fees, tap fees, water
  1956. 2:34:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker dedication fees, the cost to build has gone up exponentially in the last two years.
  1957. 2:34:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's been some commercial projects in the pipeline for the last two years whereby in their cost I've just gone up 3x4x in
  1958. 2:34:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that same time period.
  1959. 2:34:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Still for the same project, still the same affordability like Councillor Martin mentioned, but needing some assistance to keep the same rate of return.
  1960. 2:35:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This
  1961. 2:35:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker helps us do that.
  1962. 2:35:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So just on anchor these programs, we're looking at 60,000 a year for the business investment cafe.
  1963. 2:35:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's the cat annually.
  1964. 2:35:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker First location permit 20,000 a year cap.
  1965. 2:35:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's coming out of the general fund.
  1966. 2:35:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We have an incentive fund in that kind of leveling budget.
  1967. 2:35:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  1968. 2:35:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker As 200,000 in the budget
  1969. 2:35:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this year, 190,000 proposed for 2027, to fund some of those upfront grant style incentives.
  1970. 2:35:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Most of the retail attraction sales tax rebate in the gap financings, or
  1971. 2:35:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker set up on a reimbursement system.
  1972. 2:35:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's no upfront investment.
  1973. 2:35:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's reimbursement over time.
  1974. 2:35:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's what I figured on this.
  1975. 2:35:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just want to do sales tax once through the combination.
  1976. 2:35:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Could be through a combination of both.
  1977. 2:35:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Could be one we get.
  1978. 2:35:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And that's another way of sort of like budget neutral.
  1979. 2:35:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I guess because we're not collecting that correctly.
  1980. 2:35:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Jim, Jim.
  1981. 2:36:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right.
  1982. 2:36:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So sorry, I get a quick to the slide about, you know, what we're looking for for the retail attraction sales tax we made.
  1983. 2:36:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Again, it's not only for just the highest
  1984. 2:36:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker ticket sales such generators, it can also be for a national outdoor retailer considering EU foreporters.
  1985. 2:36:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And what we're really trying to draw in this example is
  1986. 2:36:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker this would be a destination retailer so this would be a lot of author provider that only has two occasions in the state of polarado that has
  1987. 2:36:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a proven track record of bringing in customers from a larger drive time than another duck, any other compromise type of retailer.
  1988. 2:36:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So this would be attractive
  1989. 2:36:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to us in a few different ways.
  1990. 2:36:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It would be, you know, we tell we don't already have.
  1991. 2:36:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It would be destination, so we would get even more outside of UrySales tax dollars,
  1992. 2:36:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and it's on our priority retail node.
  1993. 2:37:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One that would be not as attractive and not eligible is a retail that already committed to at least perform or
  1994. 2:37:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker assistance because this is a buck forensic but forensic instead of you were not too serious so we were not gonna give you we're not gonna end up into your agreement with them but business investment cash
  1995. 2:37:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker grant, this could be a restaurant that currently only does launch a dinner service.
  1996. 2:37:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They've been accepted and raised by the town.
  1997. 2:37:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They've really helped the business
  1998. 2:37:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This is revenue coming in.
  1999. 2:37:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They want to expand into coffee service the $18,000 to build out a pedio by an espresso machine and start serving and have morning hours
  2000. 2:37:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and increase the revenue that way.
  2001. 2:37:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker One that would not be eligible would be a never operating restaurant owner that's requesting $40,000
  2002. 2:37:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker for anticipated operating expensive software they have been forgot financing sort of already went into this one so it would be the attractive commercial flex development with the validated
  2003. 2:38:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker financing gap versus a storage project with incomplete financials and no demonstrated gap that we can identify.
  2004. 2:38:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So again, this is just underlining
  2005. 2:38:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that what we bring to you will need these eligibility parameters and also be attractive to us from our evaluation criteria.
  2006. 2:38:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not that
  2007. 2:38:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we're not already doing this for their current policy.
  2008. 2:38:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's that this makes it a lot more transparent for everyone involved in the process.
  2009. 2:38:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Would you refer to an existing
  2010. 2:38:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker business, it's closely mean for the motor.
  2011. 2:38:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker For the business investment cash grant in the retail attraction
  2012. 2:38:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker sales tax rebate yes uh the permit the first occasion permit fee rebate um since i name these programs they are in height and your point already but
  2013. 2:38:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker not just trying to be as explicit as possible.
  2014. 2:39:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That would be helpful.
  2015. 2:39:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Otherwise, thank you.
  2016. 2:39:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker These are some of the questions we
  2017. 2:39:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker wanted to discuss with you tonight.
  2018. 2:39:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker In our recommendation is to move forward with the revised policy as provided.
  2019. 2:39:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We didn't want to sort of gauge if
  2020. 2:39:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you know, moving from our current broad-based approach to four defined programs was something that the Council supported in general.
  2021. 2:39:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think so.
  2022. 2:39:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think the concept is great.
  2023. 2:39:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I like the analogy
  2024. 2:39:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker to the URA.
  2025. 2:39:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I like the way you look at the last year and a half when you learn and now have more targeted
  2026. 2:39:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker policy.
  2027. 2:39:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think that's great, younto of all that way.
  2028. 2:39:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Customer rebearer and e-commerce.
  2029. 2:40:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank
  2030. 2:40:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker you.
  2031. 2:40:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker No, I think this looks good.
  2032. 2:40:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I like the four incentive programs.
  2033. 2:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm sort of anticipating that we would maybe hear from
  2034. 2:40:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses around the retail attraction sales that the tax debate might not be available to
  2035. 2:40:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a
  2036. 2:40:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker retailer who wants to relocate.
  2037. 2:40:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think there's other incentives that can take advantage of, but as I was just listening, I think that's something I can imagine hearing.
  2038. 2:40:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but other than that i think that it's it's really great i wonder how having gap financing instead of available um kind of
  2039. 2:40:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker townwide how that would impact any new or different URAs.
  2040. 2:40:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We talked about expanding the airport URA and I wondered maybe that's just not even something we'll entertain in the
  2041. 2:40:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker future where how it will impact the conversations.
  2042. 2:41:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But yeah, just on that, I'm trying to keep this brief, which I socket doing.
  2043. 2:41:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker The benefit of a URA is that it allows you to access additional property texts that commit beyond the town's Mill Levy.
  2044. 2:41:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so if an area qualifies
  2045. 2:41:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and you establish the blame finding, adopt the plan, go through the impact of force, and negotiate with the taxing entities, it allows you to capture more property tax available
  2046. 2:41:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker beyond what the town might be able to offer just through the Senate policy, including portions of the county's Mill Levy School, Fire Library, etc.
  2047. 2:41:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So the URI allows us to capture
  2048. 2:41:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker more than the town's gap and center policy might.
  2049. 2:41:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's more powerful tool.
  2050. 2:41:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It allows you to capture municipal sales tax as well, but it just allows you to think a little bit more
  2051. 2:41:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker opportunity to be on just the town's portion yeah that's so true thank you for highlighting that i also was kind of wondering about the retail this the tax relate how
  2052. 2:42:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker does that as we're talking about you know these these sales tax increases on our ballot this year this November how does that impact
  2053. 2:42:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker kind of our plans for expansion for the reckoner?
  2054. 2:42:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Do we somehow like opt out some of the sales taxes?
  2055. 2:42:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I don't know how
  2056. 2:42:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker that works.
  2057. 2:42:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Did I ask that?
  2058. 2:42:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Clearly, does that mean sense?
  2059. 2:42:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, so that's sort of where we're in a different position
  2060. 2:42:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker than other places that have a lot of this retail space already built out.
  2061. 2:42:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker From what I can understand, you can follow up with Sarah.
  2062. 2:42:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is, you know, there's slightly more nuance to this answer because those are not sales tax that we're currently accommodating.
  2063. 2:42:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it's not that it would need to be like so I'm trying to say this whereas for where we do have this for an
  2064. 2:43:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker existing business, that's an existing space,
  2065. 2:43:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker we wouldn't need to rewrite any agreements where we'd have passed any new sales tax increases,
  2066. 2:43:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker but because it's not already being generated it would need to be considered in that future projections yeah i think this
  2067. 2:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker is net news sales tax not already budgeted or encumbered at any purpose so we're we're trying to attract new investment new sales tax revenue using that tax rebate so
  2068. 2:43:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the town will ultimately keep the remaining 50 for that five-year term so this is not pledging out or giving out any of the towns remaining other sales tax revenue that we're already receiving
  2069. 2:43:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker or have committed for purposes that makes sense yeah okay i'll be interested to see
  2070. 2:44:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker it right now.
  2071. 2:44:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I just needed to probably need a chart to help my brain digest it, but I think this looks good.
  2072. 2:44:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Thank you.
  2073. 2:44:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker comments, questions for Dark to...
  2074. 2:44:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's open here.
  2075. 2:44:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think so far you can piece the floor.
  2076. 2:44:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes, and nothing.
  2077. 2:44:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Number four, what
  2078. 2:44:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker modifications should staff incorporate before returning for formal consideration because you are planning on returning December 8th with this revised acquisition set to
  2079. 2:44:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker policy and we would just want to make sure we've captured anything um and i believe all these times have come back and consent as well so please let us know yeah i gotta feel this
  2080. 2:44:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker will be the implementing.
  2081. 2:44:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You see whether it was empty takers, if there isn't just adjustment, if you have a ton of takers in regarding the track program, how,
  2082. 2:44:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker has that been utilized much to do it again there's been interest without having set parameters in place the
  2083. 2:45:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker interest is all over the board.
  2084. 2:45:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've had a couple of agreements already out the door.
  2085. 2:45:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'll say for one example, we had an agreement out of our incentive fund when Lucio's
  2086. 2:45:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker closed down for two weeks to replace the Greece trap construct new sewer connection to the sewer.
  2087. 2:45:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They shut down their business for two weeks that took away a lot of their sales revenue.
  2088. 2:45:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was a good for public health and safety.
  2089. 2:45:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It was a necessary improvement.
  2090. 2:45:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We did a $40,000 incentive to support their investment in the business that required them to close.
  2091. 2:45:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That was one example.
  2092. 2:45:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We've had
  2093. 2:45:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker a few others.
  2094. 2:45:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right now, we have an application in right now for the commercial market of Western Lee, seeking size and bone incentive.
  2095. 2:45:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker We don't really have the program established yet to understand exactly how to set it up, but there's interest.
  2096. 2:46:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Outside of that, there's been a few applications for small cash grants anywhere from 7,220,000.
  2097. 2:46:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker This will help us administer the tool a lot better than the broad flexible program we have now.
  2098. 2:46:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker What was the 124th?
  2099. 2:46:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Existing
  2100. 2:46:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker businesses making investment in their current business, that was one single business.
  2101. 2:46:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  2102. 2:46:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Just curious, like,
  2103. 2:46:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker are these caps something that you feel comfortable with?
  2104. 2:46:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I think you're good.
  2105. 2:46:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right, Bob.
  2106. 2:46:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker You were forward to seeing you in December.
  2107. 2:46:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, we're back.
  2108. 2:46:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So we have council and we can council like bring up for our
  2109. 2:46:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker own procedures.
  2110. 2:46:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'll just do it over the last couple of years.
  2111. 2:46:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker That's a dollar.
  2112. 2:46:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's not directly not in here, but it's a big benefit to
  2113. 2:47:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I usually the AL bus line that goes from one not to DIA there's a stock in Lafayette and it's very convenient the market park and ride and Lafayette's
  2114. 2:47:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker the last stop before DIA and the first stop coming back from DIA.
  2115. 2:47:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So there's no lot of waiting in different stops and whatnot.
  2116. 2:47:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Very cheap and very convenient.
  2117. 2:47:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, especially for over 60 um yeah about 35 yeah so i'm thinking about i'm gonna do it my next trip to the airport and check it out so yeah seven days a
  2118. 2:47:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker week, right?
  2119. 2:47:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker let me move the bottom out of there and it leaves the airport at the top of the hour.
  2120. 2:47:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So, can you take it here?
  2121. 2:47:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Are we going to do the last week?
  2122. 2:47:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, yeah, of course.
  2123. 2:47:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Where's the drop-down?
  2124. 2:47:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
  2125. 2:48:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker with a train.
  2126. 2:48:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  2127. 2:48:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Alright, because I think you'll be on the train and did you go to the dumb dumb never?
  2128. 2:48:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  2129. 2:48:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker They're just gonna go around all the while and...
  2130. 2:48:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Did you leave your car
  2131. 2:48:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker at the parking right now?
  2132. 2:48:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  2133. 2:48:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah.
  2134. 2:48:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay.
  2135. 2:48:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
  2136. 2:48:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker He's an awesome servicer.
  2137. 2:48:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  2138. 2:48:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yes.
  2139. 2:48:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I mean, take a legend.
  2140. 2:48:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm not a servicer.
  2141. 2:48:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker I'm
  2142. 2:48:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker buying bucks i think yeah it's close it's it's easily as fast as going down there and parking you rewoltly and getting
  2143. 2:48:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker on the shuttle linguet down there and it's a lot cheaper too.
  2144. 2:48:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Nothing can isolate those.
  2145. 2:48:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker It's getting bucks for anything today.
  2146. 2:48:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Councilmember Bear, anything tonight?
  2147. 2:48:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Hi, we just add to that that Boulder County also just launched Ryde Boco
  2148. 2:49:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and you can it's a service they have an app now it looks like it's up and running you can also call to a book and you can get poked up from the boulder county side of Erie or in Old Town
  2149. 2:49:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker and they will, I think they'll take you to that park in Red and Lafayette and catch the AO and then you don't have to leave your car there.
  2150. 2:49:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And it's a fan free service
  2151. 2:49:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker kind of like the B.
  2152. 2:49:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And the wonderful thing is that it connects with the Ridebooko Connect Swift Waffiet Louisville Insuperior.
  2153. 2:49:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And so we're able to connect with other
  2154. 2:49:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker communities and utilize there to be in this micro transit services as well.
  2155. 2:49:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if you close slowly, go ahead, sorry.
  2156. 2:49:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Yeah, if you caught the ERB, they wouldn't
  2157. 2:49:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker go over there because of Sloth yet or with that work too.
  2158. 2:49:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Right.
  2159. 2:49:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So Erie B, we have very limited areas that B will stop outside
  2160. 2:49:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker of Erie right now we stop in the Walmart coal's parking lot which there is a mobility have you can catch a boss there and we also go to children's hospital and so in future expansions of the
  2161. 2:50:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker B, we'd like to extend to the Colorado Seven Mobility Hub so that we can catch the busting.
  2162. 2:50:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And then also always working to coordinate with Lafayette and Dreamfield
  2163. 2:50:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Bongmont to connect our microtransits.
  2164. 2:50:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker But for now, Ryan Boko is a great answer for getting to that AL bus in Lafayette,
  2165. 2:50:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker which is the number one request that I've always heard from folks is they want to bus, or I guess, a bus to the plane.
  2166. 2:50:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So I'm glad you got to use that, and that's awesome.
  2167. 2:50:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker cool all right anything else um no not really um just we have native this week and we won't get enough date from Dr.
  2168. 2:50:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Cogg around our
  2169. 2:50:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker growth projections and numbers there's a lot of different entities that use those and so that's been a really important conversation and i'll report back on that maybe next week all right cool
  2170. 2:51:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker And we have a legacy while meeting tomorrow, so we'll be doing that as well.
  2171. 2:51:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Okay, Mayor Protect.
  2172. 2:51:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Another for me tonight.
  2173. 2:51:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker All right,
  2174. 2:51:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker nothing for me either.
  2175. 2:51:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker So if that will adjourn this meeting.